10 Worst TV Role Models of 2011 -- Part 2

By the time we're adults, most of us have figured out the difference between the kind of behavior that would get us booked on a reality show and the kind of behavior that leads to healthy, productive lives. But kids and teens are still figuring out who they are. And they're using television -- at least partly -- as a barometer of what's socially acceptable.

(See the first five Worst TV Role Models)

Talking about TV characters and their choices can be a great way to start conversations with your kids about their own behavior. Are your kids absorbing messages from any of these characters?

6. All the Housewives, Real Housewives of Orange County, Beverly Hills, New York City, New Jersey, etc.
These materialistic drama queens are poor role models for many, many reasons. But we particularly dislike the way they constantly gang up against each other and form mean-girl alliances.
Why it matters: Being mean to others is so much easier in today's 24/7 digital world. Between social media, texting, and email, being a cyberbully has never been so easy.
What you can do: Encourage kids to think before they post. And remind them not to say anything online that they wouldn't say face to face. And if they've been bullied -- online or otherwise -- teach them how to respond.

7. Blair Waldorf (Leighton Meester), Gossip Girl
Backstabbing and always out to be queen bee, Blair is the ultimate mean girl ... with a killer wardrobe.
Why it matters: Blair's fashionable ways and runway style make her a key target for young viewers to look up to. And when kids who visit the Gossip Girl website can buy the clothes right off the backs of their favorite characters, Blair and her prep school buddies become covert salespeople targeting a key demographic -- your teens.
What you can do: Arm kids with the critical thinking skills to help them see through the hype and understand when they're being marketed to. Kids hate to feel manipulated, and when they understand that underneath promotions, free downloads, movie websites, or apps is plain and simple advertising, they'll be warier.

8. Nancy Botwin (Mary-Louise Parker), Weeds
She makes consistently terrible parenting decisions, getting her sons caught up in a world of drug dealing, crime, and violence.
Why it matters: Outrageous -- not to mention illegal -- parenting behavior sends a message that abandoning responsibility is the only option when life gets overwhelming.
What you can do: You'd probably never miss a soccer game or back-to-school night, but do you know the ESRB ratings of your kids' favorite video games? Do you let your little kids surf the web unsupervised? Did you know that your Wii can surf the web or that your kid has a MySpace page? Get involved in your kids' digital life so that you can make informed media choices.

9. Strawberry Shortcake, Strawberry Shortcake Bitty Berry Adventures
OK, she's not actually that bad. But her character has morphed from a cute, plump kid in baggy jeans to a svelte tween with a glamorous hairdo. What's up with that? On top of that, she and her berry-named friends tend to needs lots of reassurance for every decision they make, and their vocations tend toward the stereotypical (food, dance, hair-care).
Why it matters: Girls are increasingly being sexualized in the media at a younger age, leading to a limited sense of self.
What you can do: Watch out for stereotypes in TV shows and other media, and point out when girls are rewarded for their looks and boys for their strength. Teach kids to question these messages and reinforce behaviors that don't emphasize their looks.

10. Candace (Ashley Tisdale), Phineas and Ferb
Her primary motivations are pleasing her boyfriend and getting her brothers in trouble. All while being a screechy, whiny stereotype of a girl.
Why it matters: In the media, women are still too often relegated to the roles of love interest, sex object, selfless saint, or nitpicky nag -- despite overwhelming real-world evidence to the contrary. When kids see characters portrayed that way over and over, it reinforces gender stereotypes.
What you can do: Talk to your kids about strong female role models who've achieved success through hard work, intelligence, discipline, or business savvy. These can be everyday heroes -- like your child's teacher -- or famous women your family admires or even a strong female character on television.

About Sierra Filucci

Sierra has been writing and editing professionally for more than a decade, with a special interest in women's and family subjects. She has a master’s degree in journalism from the University of...

Add comment

Login or register to post comments

Comments

Venezia Apr 12, 2013
I agree with evolinag. Also there are really bad reality TV show role models.
Kid, 12 years old Nov 19, 2012
NO!!!!! Don`t put Phineas and Freb on here
davercks Sep 17, 2012
Had to laugh at the Candace one. I feel most teenage girls act like this. More the boyfriend part. I don't think she's necessarily a bad role model but then again its a cartoon??
gothic_unicorn May 6, 2013
Sierra's just being a soccermom, putting Candace and Strawberry Shortcake on this list for such ridiculous reasons.
DangerRanger101 Sep 7, 2012
CommOnSense, I honestly think you made too big of a deal about Strawberry Shortcake, sure her wardrobe has changed but just because she's not dressed casualy like she used to be but she's still a fairly good role model. I really think you should have done more research because there are plently of worse role models, like the dance leader on Dance Moms or all of the mothers on Toddlers in Tiaras.
dani59 Aug 13, 2012
I never really looked Atvs show as it was real life this s eye opener every thing you read watch listen to you get smarter
smartkitty Aug 2, 2012
I think starwberry shortcake is kinda a cute show.
Kingdestroyah Jul 17, 2012
You forgot just about any character from any CN or nick show...
Kid, 10 years old Jun 25, 2012
number 8 should be 1
Kid, 10 years old Jun 22, 2012
Do you really think kids our gonna care about modeling their cartoon characters. Cartoon characters do some stupid stuff that can kill themselves ( or others) but that doesn't mean kids will. Anyway in perspective kids role-models are usually real humans someone they can copy more realistically in the good and bad. But otherwise I mostly agree with your opinion.
evolinag May 5, 2012
Barney Stinson in "How I Met your Mother" is missing. He is just as inapropriate as Charlie Harper. Toot Braunstein, Clara, Captain Hero and Spanky Ham in "Drawn Together". They is just... pure evil (watch 1 episode and you will know why). Dr. Dr. mag. Sheldon Cooper in "The Big Bang Theory". Though being the funniest character in the show, he is pretty arrogant. Sam Puckett in "iCarly". She is a rowdy and does not care about others (except Carly) I love all of these shows, but none of them are educational)
CSM Screen name... Feb 24, 2012
Thank you for another fantastic blog. Where else could I get this kind of information written in such an incite full way? I have a project that I am just now working on, and i am sure this will help me a lot..and I have been looking for such information since from few days....Thanks!!!!! Crescent Processing
LtCentaur Feb 24, 2012
I'd strongly disagree that Candace is a bad role model. She actually does really love her brothers a lot, and she is just trying to protect them from dangerous things they do. As for her boyfriend, she does indeed go a little crazy for him, but a lot of teens go through this. Besides, she even learns from her brothers it's okay to have fun. I'm pretty surprised Candace made it on here. There are much worse role models in cartoons you know, like Spongebob, and Family Guy characters. That's just my say though.
Kid, 12 years old Feb 19, 2012
All the housewives - Not a big fan. :). I don't even watch it, it looks stupid. Blair Waldorf - I've never seen Gossip Girl, and I'm not planning to, but everyone has someone like her in their school, right? Nancy Botwin - OK, I don't watch Weeds, and I'm sure any sane parent wouldn't let their child either. Strawberry Shortcake - :D. I can't stop laughing. Little 4-year-olds watch this show and I don't think they watch it and think, "Wow, she's perfect." :P. Candace - I hate Phineas and Ferb, and, the other day I was going through Disney shows to see which ones didn't have to do with girls and boys throwing themselves at each other. I found none. ~ This was written by an 11-year-old.
bioniclecomeback56 Apr 26, 2012
You don't like Phineas and Ferb!!!!!!
Kid, 12 years old Feb 17, 2012
I hate it when kids try to copy P&F. YOU CANT BUILD THOSE THINGS IN LIKE 10 MINUTES!!! Its so stupid.
Kid, 12 years old Feb 17, 2012
I agree with @LuckyPleo. I mean I think that young girls arnt gonna go around dying their hair pink and acting whiney and annoying. I think their just going to watch it and giggle!
AthenaRox23 Feb 14, 2012
Candace? For real? THANK YOU, Desmat, for saying EXACTLY what I was thinking!!! Vanessa is Dr. D's daughter, and I don't have any real problems with her, her figure is reasonable and her clothes are modest too. A big "Bad Role Models" show is Good Luck Charlie (also Disney Channel). P. J. is a dope, and in some episodes fantasizes about women?!? Teddy whines and complains and is a brat and can't get enough whatever. Gabe we all laugh at but succeeds to put down the parents and trash whatever respect he has for them, or any shred of dignity they remain with, and Charlie is just a cute face. Also, sure, Spongebob can be pretty put-down full, but it's a classic. Seriously! And never once while watching it as a 7 year old did I think, wow, I'll go out and call my friends and family language that Squidward uses! Please. Ok hope that wasn't too long.
McKathlin Feb 14, 2012
I agree with Desmat: Phineas and Ferb are great role models! Candace definitely isn't, but she isn't meant to be looked up to as one. She's meant to be a lovable antagonist, a reverse role model. Like Donald Duck, she's neurotic and silly, and ends up in embarrassing situations because of her antics. Viewers laugh at her and feel sorry for her at the same time. Not many female characters have that kind of role, and I think it's fine that there are some. Not all girls on TV need to be perfect.
Seven22 Feb 13, 2012
Phineas and Ferb may be one of the few cartoon with an intact family where the parents are not portrayed as aloof dolts. It is a funny creative show. The boys, Phineas and Ferb , are smart, creative, non exclusive, and respect their parents and their sister. And, yes, Candace is a whiny, fairly insecure girl but she is also showed time and again that her insecurities are unfounded and that her family is really important. Also she is not portrayed in a sexual way, she doesn't have curves or wears clothes that are inappropriate. This is rare for cartoons these days. Even the villain, Doofenschmetz, has a conscious. I would disagree with CSM's review for Phineas and Ferb. I think it is one of the better cartoons out their for kids to see.
Kid, 12 years old Feb 12, 2012
Strawberry Shortcake...what the heck happened to you, girl!?Why did ya have to become some girlygirl with a lot of stereotypes?Man, even though I was born in 2001, I've noticed that the 21rst century is ruining everything.
Teddybear123456789 Feb 12, 2012
You definitely get scarred for life by cartoons. oh yes definitely! you are totally going to run to the ghetto and tell your mom about your brothers.
TabithaCatt Feb 12, 2012
i love phineas and ferb. but lets face it, that show is not meant to be realistic, they make rollercoasters that reach space! some people are too serious.
Teddybear123456789 Feb 12, 2012
I agree. yes to serious.
sisterwhocares Feb 11, 2012
YOU ARE FORGETTING SOMETHING CRITICAL!!!! Sorry for the caps lock, but this is very, very important for parents to know. From the Suite Life of Zac and Cody and the suite life on deck, Zac is a HORRIBLE role model. He is overobsessed with girls, and disney really pushes the line here. Pardon if I sound to extreme, but several times he calls women "babes" and acts like a kid version of charlie sheen. He is despicable, sexist, rude to his brother, unlikable, and a terrible actor! Still don't believe me? One time, when giving his brother advice on girls, he refers to them as "deer" or "innocent creatures" and him as a "wild animal" (sorry been a long time since watched this show). anywho, this is CLEARLY a sexual metaphor. It doesnt take an ideot to figure that out!
Kid, 12 years old Feb 12, 2012
@sisterwhocares:You are so right! Zac acts like girls are his only passion, and it gets so annoying! The Disney channel has changed SO much. No more good shows, always about boyfriends/girlfriends,kissing,etc. I really miss the good, clean show with good role models! p.s. Zac is truely a shrunk up Charlie Sheen.
Teddybear123456789 Feb 12, 2012
Ya! and also calls them gazelles
Big Time Mom Feb 11, 2012
I have got to agree with others that Candace should not be on this list. If you watch the show P & F, it is very clear that Candace is NOT held up as a role model, she the annoying sister that no one wants to be like.
CSM Screen name... Feb 11, 2012
let me guess you hate Tom & jerry to because it promotes interracial hate through the constant chasing and attempted murder via frying pans and mouse traps. and it promotes homelessness by jerry living in a hole in the wall, and freeloading because jerry has no job and constantly takes food from the fridge...??
John the Magic Elf Feb 11, 2012
Hmmm. 8 are female, 2 are male. I think this is a bit discriminatory (sorry!) We have our own bad TV role models here in the UK, but I'm happy to say neither I nor my kids have seen any of these programmes (although I think UK TV shows the one with Charlie whats-his-name)...
Saiya-STORY Feb 10, 2012
Although some of these are valid (Snooki and the real Housewives, etc), there are a bunch of other shows that depict much worse in characters. Tyra? Really? She promotes TZONE, and also has her talk show so I don't see why she should be on the list. If ANTM is at fault for reinforcing 'skinnier' and 'prettier' models then isn't American Idol at fault for preferring the same type of 'good-looking' and charismatic singers? As far as cartoons go, I didn't start watching violent ones until I was 9, so parents are responsible for knowing what shows are appropriate and which aren't. Do research. The 90's cartoons were FULL of sterotypes, but I turned out fine. Remember, each child and teen has their own personality, so they will respond to different media differently. Generally, this list isn't too bad though.
Fullmetal Heatran Feb 10, 2012
@jojovonjo: Agree completely Additionally, the main characters of most reality shows seem to be bad role models in general, which is why people should watch anime instead :D.
Desmat Feb 10, 2012
Ok, I am definitely smiling at some of the observations, and comments. Yes, cartoons can add to stereotypes, but not as often, nor as intensely, as 'real - life' shows. But, I have to make a comment on 'Phineas and Ferb.' Yes, I agree with your take on Candace. But, I have to say I LOVE this show, as much as, and dare I say it? maybe more than my three boys. I love that Phineas and Ferb use their imagination and creativity rather than sitting around, and that they ALWAYS clean their mess up (tongue in cheek, here)! And, of course, I enjoy the humor and the zippy songs. I love that they are always willing, and with enthusiasm, to help and support friends and family. Phineas and Ferb are almost always cheerful. And, no matter what Candace is doing to them, they still do the right thing. They treat her respectfully, and always show her support and encouragement. They keep her in mind through their many adventures, and try to help her. Phineas and Ferb doesn't let Candace's bad attitudes affect them. No, Candace is not a good example of a teenage girl, but it does provide a foil to show how you can respond in the right way. And that no matter what another person says or does, you are in control of your responses, and thus you can make your day/life, or not. I'm actually more concerned over (uh oh, spacing on her name right now - the evil scientists daughter), who is far too sexy (far more than Strawberry Shortcake) and emotionally detached, for my liking. I think I would put 'Wizards of Waverly Place' higher on the list than 'Phineas and Ferb.' There are some shows that I flat out refuse to let my children watch (is it 'Carly and Simon'?) And, as always, some shows are on the line, just watch it with the children. Then make fun of the bad, and point out the good. I love your site, Common Media, and your emails. Thank you. It gives me a place to start, and I can basically rely on your information when I do not have the time to thoroughly check out whatever it is the boys want. God Bless.
j10a1 Dec 27, 2012
YES YES YES! THANK YOU! One other thing I Iove about Phineas and Ferb is that when they never get "busted," they weren't sneaking around with their inventions. They WANT to show their mom! They are not being sneaky about it. I also love the plots and storylines, how the different aspects of the episode are all cleverly interwoven.....I love it! Plus, it's hilarious! EVERY show has a bad role model in some way, shape, or form. I do think certain shows, don't really have much of a problem with bad role models though; people can find something wrong with EVERYTHING! Sorry, bunny trailing. Anyways, I totally agree with you, I LOVE Phineas and Ferb, and I think it is a very good show for practically all ages.
bioniclecomeback56 Apr 26, 2012
I agree this is one of my favorite shows too, Candace is not ment to be a role model, though wizards of waverly place is not a bad show its just stupid, like you said Candace makes Phineas and Ferb look nice it is a major point of the show. Hope everyone gets this okay, but if you like Phineas and Ferb the more appropiate term is ***snap*** okay!
bbmcfarland Feb 13, 2012
I couldn't agree more, Desmat. My husband and I both love Phineas and Ferb for all the reasons you mention. Phineas is even-keeled, imaginative, kind and has a can-do attitude. Candace is a pain, but on rare occasions you see she does love her brothers. I also love the mom and dad. And the way the writers weave into the plot the ridiculous evil doings of Doofenschmirz and how Perry thwarts him every time is fascinating. Worst part of the show: the twisted relationship between the bully and the little Indian kid. They make light of it, and it really disgusts me.
Desmat Feb 10, 2012
Wow, didn't mean to write a book - I'm sorry!
Kid, 12 years old Aug 1, 2012
u didn't write a book! what u said was great. i think the same thing 2. my brother who is 3 is always trying to put things together. thats why im glad they have that show!
gblanco Feb 11, 2012
@Desmat: Don't be sorry. Great comments.
kpinsunnyaz Feb 10, 2012
I cannot believe the Bachelor was not among those listed. Talk about a poor stereotype of women, getting all dolled up to literally compete and sometimes fight with other women to win a man they don't know and cannot actually have any feelings for given they don't know him at all. And this is so called "reality tv" so kids really buy into this stuff. Yes, I know there is also a Bachelorette, but there just isn't the same stereotype around guys getting the girl.
LoveBittenWolf Feb 9, 2012
I agree with 95% of this list. I see the point of cartoon characters on the list because perhaps some young children cannot distinguish real and not real. Growing up my postive role models were the Care Bears, and the Popples. Lol, 80's baby. Yet, I knew they were ficticious, but they had some great lessons and values to learn from.
LuckyPleo Feb 9, 2012
Yes, cartoon characters are horrible role models, because so many people try to be like Strawberry Shortcake and Phineas and Ferb... not. :P

About our bloggers

Stay connected to Common Sense