Making Sense

Illegal Downloads: When Sharing Becomes Stealing

Help your kids learn the difference between rightful ownership and illegal downloads.
Caroline Knorr Parenting Editor | Mom of one Categories: Internet safety and privacy
Parenting Editor | Mom of one

Today's "pirates" are downloading games, music, movies, and software.

  • Under U.S. copyright law, illegal downloading could be punishable by up to five years in prison and $250,000 in fines

  • Internet Service Providers can detect connections to illegal sites and flag large file downloads

  • Illegally downloaded material can expose computers to viruses, malware, spyware, or other unwanted software, costing families hefty recovery fees

Talking to kids about illegal downloads

Many parents remember exchanging mix tapes or VHS copies of our favorite TV shows with our friends. But today's technology makes it much easier to get and give away copyrighted material illegally. And many kids are taking advantage of the access, downloading and sharing everything from games to movies to music to software. Unfortunately, while some kids are downloading innocently -- unaware of the ethical, legal, and security consequences of their actions -- other kids find the chance to get stuff for free just too tempting.

What is digital piracy?

Piracy is the act of illegally downloading copyrighted games, music, movies, TV shows, and software that you haven't paid for. Downloads are surprisingly easy to find on the Internet, mostly on file-sharing sites that kids hear about from other kids.

Why it matters

Not paying people for their creative work isn't just an ethical issue, it's illegal. Under U.S. copyright law, offenders could be punishable by up to five years in prison and $250,000 in fines. In some cases, modern-day pirates have been turned into the authorities by their Internet Service Providers, which detect connections to illegal sites and flag large file downloads.

Beyond the ethical and legal issues is the hefty price tag that many families pay because of piracy. Illegally downloaded material can expose computers to viruses, malware, spyware, or other unwanted software, all of which can crash your computer and lead to costly computer damage, loss of irreplaceable files, or even identity theft.

Tips for parents of all kids

  • Talk to kids about piracy. Remind them that just because it's easy to download, that doesn't make it right. A lot of people work hard to put together a song, a movie, or a software program. All of these people need to get paid for their hard work. Make sure kids understand that downloading is a form of theft. When you download a movie illegally from peer-to-peer sites, load an unauthorized copy of a software program on to your computer, or rip a music file from a friend, it's against the law -- even if you give it away for free. You can be fined lots of money or put in jail.
  • Use authentic software from authorized sources. Not all file-sharing sites are illegal. Many software tools let people share big files legitimately. Just make sure that you're using a legitimate product. Also, always check for security indicators, such as a padlock icon on your browser or an encrypted URL (commonly shown as https in your browser bar). And if a software program is ridiculously cheap -- at least 35% lower than normal costs -- then it's most likely not legal.
  • Lead by example. Make sure that every program, movie, music track, TV episode, or game that you purchase, download, or stream is authentic and legal. Make sure you abide by the terms that come with the software (called the end-user license agreement, or EULA). It sets a great example for your kids and ensures your protection from the pitfalls of piracy.


About Caroline Knorr

As Common Sense Media's parenting editor, Caroline helps parents make sense of what’s going on in their kids' media lives. From games to cell phones to movies and more, if you're wondering "what’s the right age for... Read more

Add comment

Log in or register to post comments

Comments (1)

That's that mean Frostwire is illegal too. Because people use it to download Music for free. So just downloading a song, Movie, or a TV Show. I could face up to 5 Years in Prison or pay a $250,000 Fine. Just for downloading 24 Songs for & then put it on my 3DS. The FBI Could check your computer and the Police could Handcuff me for doing it. Almost like an R Rated Movie But in real life. They post these stuff on Youtube and they are not stopping people from doing these stuff.