I am a die-hard sisterhood fan so this book kind of annoyed me. These characters didn't have any of the same charm as Tibby, Lena, Bridget, or Carmen. I'm the same age but I couldn't really relate to any of the events in the story. I also thought that making out with a random stranger on the bus was pretty irrational behavior for 14 year olds, most of the people I know would never do that. It wasn't anything special really, but it wasn't too bad.
3 Willows
(2009, Fiction - Friendship, Written by Ann Brashares)
-
Is it age appropriate?
About our ratings -
Is it any good?
-
Common Sense says
Brashares' novel charms even without magical pants.
Why We Rated This 
for Ages 12–14
The good stuff
What to watch out for
-
Violence:
-
Sex:
-
Language:
-
Consumerism:
-
Drinking, drugs, & smoking:
What Parents Need to Know
This review of 3 Willows was written by Stephanie Dunnewind
Parents need to know that this book from the author of The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants ultimately delivers positive messages about doing what's right, making good choices, taking chances, and accepting oneself. Along the way, the three young teen protagonists deaI with a borderline eating disorder, an alcoholic parent, a fickle cute boy, and the tribulations of fitting in with the popular crowd. The book name-drops characters from the author's Traveling Pants books but is targeted at a younger audience than that young adult series.
Families Can Talk About
Talk to your kids about the media in their life. We have more tools and tips that can help
- Families can talk about Polly's choice to start dieting and her obsession with models. Imagining herself as a model pictured in magazines distributed all over the world, she believes "you could see so much more of the world when you were flat than when you were full ... I'd like to be two-dimensional, she thought. That was what models got to be." What do teens think about the idea of being reduced to a two-dimensional picture? How does Polly's attitude change over the course of the book?
Have you read it? Review It!
More on 3 Willows
Book Summary
First things first: There are no magical pants in Brashares' newest novel, despite 3 WILLOWS' tagline: "The sisterhood grows." Like many girls, three old friends -- Ama, Jo, and Polly -- wanted to emulate the famed Sisterhood, still a neighborhood legend despite moving away to college. "It's the best reason I can give for a lot of terrible-fitting jeans in our middle school," Ama notes. Instead, the motif that ties these friends together is their planting of three willow trees in elementary school. Now, during their last summer before high school, the girls must figure out if they will grow together or grow apart as they each face their own challenges. Jo gets a job -- and a new boyfriend -- while her parents go through a divorce; outdoors-hating Ama must hike and rock climb; and sweet Polly decides to become a model, despite her short stature and buck teeth. Are their bonds strong enough for high school -- or is their friendship something that belongs in the past?
Is It Any Good?
Brashares' strength is creating believable characters imbued with true-to-life faults. The 3 WILLOWS teens are not all beautiful, rich, and confident. Her insights into relationships with friends and family will garner a nod of agreement from many teens. When Polly's mom tries to make her feel better for being "weird," Polly confesses that she doesn't want to "interesting." "Maybe it was okay when you were grown up and in control of it, but being interesting in high school was no fun at all." Jo feigns indifference to her father's announcement about her parents' divorce, only to get angry at her father's relief. "Maybe she was a jerk to act like she didn't care, but he was a jerk to buy it."
The book starts a little slow and some of the lessons are predictable. However, teens who enjoy books about friendship will find these new "sisters" worth knowing.
Publisher’s Details
Publisher: Delacorte Press, Publication date: 1/13/2009
Number of pages: 320, Price: $18.99 (hardcover)
Read Aloud: Teen, Read Alone: Teen
Number of pages: 320, Price: $18.99 (hardcover)
Read Aloud: Teen, Read Alone: Teen
Our Members Say
See 3 member reviews
Most Recent Reviews
-
I rate this title iffy for age 12 and give it
-
I rate this title iffy for age 12 and give it
I am a die-hard sisterhood fan so this book kind of annoyed me. These characters didn't have any of the same charm as Tibby, Lena, Bridget, or Carmen. I'm the same age but I couldn't really relate to any of the events in the story. I also thought that making out with a random stranger on the bus was pretty irrational behavior for 14 year olds, most of the people I know would never do that. It wasn't anything special really, but it wasn't too bad.
-
I rate this title iffy for age 12 and give it
A Pretty Good Book
I did enjoy this book, but some parts were a little slow. The letters were all flashbacks and kind of confusing at times. Basically, if you can watch PG-13 movies, there won't be anything in this book you haven't seen or heard before.
Give Recommendations, Get Them, Too!
Become a member and get recommendations from other parents based on your child's age.Tell us your child's age:
Already a member? Log inOur Members Rate It
Have you read it?
For Your Family
Get age-based recommendations for your kids:
Customize based on your child's age
Nerdy_Mamma recommends:
I'd Tell You I Love You, But Then I'd Have to Kill You
for kids age 6
See more from Nerdy_Mamma
I'd Tell You I Love You, But Then I'd Have to Kill You
for kids age 6
See more from Nerdy_Mamma
