Counting on Grace - Elizabeth Winthrop

Compelling, fact-based story of child labor.

(Flash is loading. If this text does not disappear you need to install the latest flash version)

Common Sense rates it
4
Read the book?
6330_orig.jpg
Book details
  • Author:Elizabeth Winthrop
  • # of pages: 232
  • Publisher:Random House
  • Original Publication Date: 03/01/2006
  • Genre: Fiction - Historical Fiction
  • Hardcover: $15.95
  • Publisher's Recommended Reading Level: 8-12
  • Read Aloud: 10
  • Read Alone: 10
  • Awards:ALA Notable Children's Book

Parents need to know

Parents need to know that there is a horrifying scene of a boy deliberately putting his hand in a machine, which mangles it and cuts off two fingers, so that he won't have to work in the mill anymore. Sensitive children will find both the scene and its implications disturbing.

Families can talk about Lewis Hines and child labor. Why did Hines use a camera instead of writing? Why shouldn't children work to help support their families?

Message

Social Behavior:

Consumerism:

Drugs/Alcohol/Tobacco:

Tobacco

Violence

A boy has his hand mangled and two fingers cut off by a machine. An old man is killed trying to board a moving train.

Sex

Language

"Damned" used once.

Common Sense says

What's the story?

Reviewed by Matt Berman

Twelve-year-olds Grace and Arthur are the best students in their one-room school in Pownal, Vermont just after the turn of the century. So their teacher, Miss Lesley, is more upset than usual when they are pulled out of school to join the many children already working in the textile mill to help support their families. Grace accepts this as the norm, but Arthur is angry and frustrated, determined to find a way to escape the mill.

Secretly, Miss Lesley begins giving them lessons on Sundays, their one day off. And she encourages them to write to the National Child Labor Committee about their mill. The NCLC sends Lewis Hines to photograph and document the children working in the mill. But as time goes by, and nothing seems to change, Arthur becomes increasingly withdrawn and angry, until he decides to take drastic measures.

Includes author's notes about Lewis Hines, his photo (on the cover) that inspired the story, and references.

Is it any good?

4
This fascinating and, at times, horrifying story will open kids' eyes to what the lives of some children in America were like not all that long ago. Now required reading throughout the state of Vermont, COUNTING ON GRACE is based on the true story of photographer Lewis Hines' crusade to reveal the realities of child labor to the public. It was inspired particularly by one of his photos that shows a young girl with a haunting expression, dressed in rather filthy clothing, standing in front of a spinning frame.

The author does not pull any punches here: actions have consequences, lives are altered and sometimes shattered, and things don't turn out the way anyone in the story hopes, though there are signs in the end of a brighter future for Grace. This compelling and very readable fact-based story about a time with parallels to our own shows kids a part of history they may not have heard much about in school.

Other choices

Other Books by Elizabeth Winthrop:
The Battle for the Castle
The Castle in the Attic
The First Christmas Stocking
The Red Hot Rattoons

Kids Working in Mills:
The Clock by James Lincoln and Christopher Collier
The Winchesters by James Lincoln Collier
Lyddie by Katherine Paterson

Related Web Sites:
Author's Site
Lewis Hine Gallery
Child Labor in America
Library of Congress Collection

Parents and kids say

All Reviews

There are 1 reviews.

1

Posted on 10/29/07 by Anonymous Kid contributor, age 10

DO NOT READ THIS BOOK!

If this book it reccomended for 10 year olds, the person who decided that must be completely crazy. Only a totally phyco person could ever say that a book including content like this could be a good book for 10 year olds. The fact that this book is based on real life and true facts makes it even less appealing- if that's possible. And to think that any one could even think to call this book "COMPELLING" or "APPROPRIATE".

Adult Reviews

There are 0 reviews.

There are no adult reviews.

Kids Reviews

There are 1 reviews.

1

Posted on 10/29/07 by Anonymous Kid contributor, age 10

DO NOT READ THIS BOOK!

If this book it reccomended for 10 year olds, the person who decided that must be completely crazy. Only a totally phyco person could ever say that a book including content like this could be a good book for 10 year olds. The fact that this book is based on real life and true facts makes it even less appealing- if that's possible. And to think that any one could even think to call this book "COMPELLING" or "APPROPRIATE".
Review It
What do your kids do online?
Surf
44%
Homework and research
11%
Download music
7%
Chat with friends
38%
45 votes