Going, Going, Gone! with the Pain and the Great One - Judy Blume

Classic picture book revamped for new readers.

(Flash is loading. If this text does not disappear you need to install the latest flash version)

Common Sense rates it
3
Read the book?
9159_orig.jpg
Book details
  • Author:Judy Blume
  • # of pages: 128
  • Publisher:Delacorte Press
  • Original Publication Date: 08/12/2008
  • Genre: Fiction - Family Life
  • Hardcover: $12.99
  • Publisher's Recommended Reading Level: 5-9
  • Read Aloud: 5
  • Read Alone: 7

Parents need to know

Parents need to know that a younger brother ("the Pain") and older sister ("the Great One") call each other by nicknames and bicker constantly. There are some mildly tense moments: The Pain ends up in the emergency room with a seed pod up his nose on one occasion and gets lost in a mall on another. When they finally find her brother in the mall, the Great One insists, "I always knew you were okay. I mean, who'd want to steal you? You were just being a pain, same as always."

Families can talk about compromise. When Jacob and Abigail can't agree on a movie, their dad says they need to compromise, or decide together. Given the option between red and blue, Abigail suggests they choose purple. But as their dad notes, sometimes there is no purple. Families can talk about how they find compromises. Can kids think of recent examples where they took turns or came up with another solution?

Message

Social Behavior:

The siblings bicker and call each other by nicknames ("the Pain" and "the Great One"). Abigail taunts her younger brother when he is afraid to swim in the ocean. Jacob dismisses the film his sister wants to see as a "girl movie." Boys push pussy willows up their noses; one ends up in the emergency room when it gets stuck. A visit to the doctor prompts boy laughter about body "holes," which the doctor, sighing, insists on calling "bodily openings." Lessons about not doing something just because friends do, and about compromising.

Consumerism:

Grandma buys her grandkids Boogie boards and a Wolfman mask. The children go on Super Slide and Gravitron rides at the fair.

Drugs/Alcohol/Tobacco:

Violence

Sex

Language

"Booger"

Common Sense says

What's the story?

Reviewed by Carrie Wheadon

Judy Blume's THE PAIN AND THE GREAT ONE debuted as a picture book in 1974, a classic tale about a brother and sister each convinced their parents love the other more. The feuding siblings, now gracing a new beginner chapter book series, haven't aged a day since. Abigail (aka the Great One) is still the know-it-all third grader, lording her two years over her mischievous first-grade brother Jacob (aka the Pain). Six short chapters alternate between big sister and little brother viewpoints as they hit the county fair with their aunt, try Boogie boarding at the beach, get lost in the mall, and go canoeing in the Everglades with their grandparents. In a humorous twist, the seventh and final chapter is told by their pet cat Fluzzy, who is annoyed about being left home alone while the family is on vacation.

Is it any good?

3
Blume's vignettes, punctuated by black-and-white line drawings, are timeless in their simplicity and old-fashioned charm. The gentle humor rises from familiar kid situations (boys sticking pussy willows up their noses and calling them furry boogers) and word play (when a doctor warns the boys not to put anything in "bodily orifices," the Pain wonders, "Body offices? I started thinking about having offices inside my body. And every day tiny people would to work there.").

The appeal here isn't fast action or edgy language; instead, it's Blume's spot-on depictions of kids and their squabbles. Even adults will smile at such understatements as "If [the Pain] fell in and got eaten by an alligator, Mom and Dad would be really mad at Grandpa Pete." Affection between the siblings is begrudging but nonetheless evident despite their best attempts to hide it. The verbal scuffling never turns physical, but these siblings definitely aren't role models for familial harmony. With chapters split equally between the Great One's and the Pain's perspectives, readers will likely identify more on birth order than gender.

Other choices

Other Books with the Pain and the Great One:
The Pain and the Great One (picture book)
Soupy Saturdays with the Pain and the Great One
Cool Zone with the Pain and the Great One

Other Young Reader Books by the Author:
The One in the Middle Is the Green Kangaroo
Freckle Juice
Tales of a Fourth Grade Nothing
Otherwise Known as Sheila the Great
Superfudge
Fudge-a-Mania
Double Fudge

Other Sibling Books:
Zelda and Ivy: The Runaways by Laura Kvasnosky
Judy Moody and Stink series, both by Megan McDonald
Ramona the Pest (and the rest of Ramona series) by Beverly Cleary
Julius, the Baby of the World by Kevin Henkes

Parents and kids say

Be the first to post a review.

Log in or Register to post a review
Review It
What do your kids do online?
Surf
44%
Homework and research
11%
Download music
7%
Chat with friends
38%
45 votes