No Roses for Harry! - Gene Zion

Everyone comes out a winner in delightful story.

(Flash is loading. If this text does not disappear you need to install the latest flash version)

Common Sense rates it
4
Read the book?
1652_orig.jpg
Book details
  • Author:Gene Zion
  • # of pages: 32
  • Publisher:HarperCollins Children's Books
  • Original Publication Date: 01/01/1958
  • Genre: Fiction - For Beginning Readers
  • Paperback: $6.99
  • Publisher's Recommended Reading Level: Ages 4-8
  • Read Aloud: 4+
  • Read Alone: 6+

Parents need to know

Parents need to know that the depictions of dogs, cats, birds, and insects, not to mention Harry himself, are a delight for both children and grown-ups. Harry goes to great lengths to try to "lose" an unwanted gift.

Families can talk about embarrassment. Have you ever felt silly about wearing something? Why? What did you do?

Message

Social Behavior:

Harry tries to lose a handmade gift.

Consumerism:

Drugs/Alcohol/Tobacco:

Violence

Sex

Language

Common Sense says

What's the story?

Reviewed by Amy Brotman

Who hasn't received a well-intentioned but totally inappropriate gift? Harry determines to lose the embarrassing rose-patterned dog sweater from Grandma, but his efforts are constantly thwarted, until he receives help from a loose stitch and a nesting bird. Marvelous illustrations keep kids giggling at fashion victim Harry even as they sympathize with his plight.



Is it any good?

4

Although children today are in less danger of receiving hand-knitted horrors from their grandmothers (who are probably busy doing other things), the subject of clothing continues to be relevant.

What parent hasn't discovered some mysteriously unacceptable gift lurking in the furthest reaches of the closet? Or delivered some version of "By the way, whatever happened to the T-shirt with the bears that Auntie Mary sent you from Yellowstone?"

Graham's deftly rendered Harry's features--ears, eyes, tail, and posture--eloquently convey Harry's dejection and shame when he finds himself being mocked by his canine peers. Likewise, as his family searches fruitlessly for the missing sweater, Harry assumes a look of combined innocence and craftiness.

Children getting into the peer-group and fashion-consciousness mode of preschool and first grade readily respond to this story, which safely and humorously displaces some of their concerns onto Harry the dog. The old-fashioned style of the book (first published in 1958) doesn't seem to be a problem, and, for many grown-up readers, it's a bonus. Nostalgia-prone adults will love Graham's small town, where people dress up to go shopping and every little store has its resident pet.

Try the first book in the Harry series, >i>Harry the Dirty Dog. Other amusing picture books about dogs include Norman Bridwell's Clifford series, beginning with Clifford, the Big Red Dog.

Parents and kids say

Be the first to post a review.

Log in or Register to post a review
Review It
Which fantasy book creature has the best name?
Fluffy (3-headed dog, Harry Potter)
33%
Mister Grin (giant crocodile, Peter and the Starcatchers)
17%
Vermicious Knid (shapeshifting monster, Charlie and the Great Glass Elevator)
0%
The Incredibly Deadly Viper (harmless snake, Series of Unfortunate Events)
8%
Bunnicula (vampire bunny, Bunnicula series)
42%
12 votes