The Perfect Thanksgiving - Eileen Spinelli

Thanksgiving isn't about having the "perfect" day.

(Flash is loading. If this text does not disappear you need to install the latest flash version)

Common Sense rates it
4
Read the book?
1799_orig.jpg
Book details
  • Author:Eileen Spinelli
  • # of pages: 32
  • Publisher:Henry Holt & Company, Inc.
  • Original Publication Date: 11/17/2003
  • Genre: Fiction - Holiday
  • Hardcover: $15.95
  • Publisher's Recommended Reading Level: 4-8
  • Read Aloud: 4+
  • Read Alone: 7+

Parents need to know

Parents need to know that this story has a clear moral: that the success of a holiday celebration depends more on what you feel than on what you see (or taste).

Families can talk about what makes a holiday meaningful. What's important to you at Thanksgiving? What about the other holidays your family celebrates? How are your friends' celebrations similar to -- or different from -- your own?

Message

Social Behavior:

Consumerism:

Drugs/Alcohol/Tobacco:

Violence

Sex

Language

Common Sense says

What's the story?

Reviewed by Amy Brotman

On alternating pages, the young narrator, along with two talking turkeys (one "real" and the other a cutout finger turkey), compare her own family's Thanksgiving celebration with that of her friend Abigail Archer's family. Abigail's family is quiet, polite, and formal, while the narrator's is loud, rather wild, and informal. Abigail's mother serves homemade pies with fancy whipped cream swirls, while the narrator's mother serves store-bought pie and jello mold with no whipped cream. Admittedly quite different in style, both families are loving and kind, so the narrator gives them both marks of "ultra perfect."

Is it any good?

4

Is one family's way of celebrating a holiday better than another's? The author of this colorful story says no. She compares and contrasts a "perfect" family's Thanksgiving Day with that of a more ragtag crew and finds them to be equally good because of the love that is apparent in each family. It is not the family's style that counts, but the feelings between the family members.

The humorous story is written from the child's point of view and focuses on just the sorts of things that a child might notice. As the young narrator goes down her list of things that are right about Abigail's family and wrong about her own, the reader can tell that she fears that her family will not make the grade. Happily, in the end, she can see beneath the contrasting exteriors of the two families to the close-knit feelings in each. The gouache, colored pencil, and collage art is zany, contemporary, and attractive.

From the book:
My family and the Archers
are different-this I know.
We can't tell peas from green legumes
or snails from escargots.
But we're alike in one way,
the nicest way by far-
alike in just how loving
our different families are.

Other choices

Also by Eileen Spinelli
Thanksgiving at the Tappleton's

More Thanksgiving
Thanksgiving is Here by Diane Goode

Parents and kids say

Be the first to post a review.

Log in or Register to post a review
Review It
Which fantasy book creature has the best name?
Fluffy (3-headed dog, Harry Potter)
33%
Mister Grin (giant crocodile, Peter and the Starcatchers)
17%
Vermicious Knid (shapeshifting monster, Charlie and the Great Glass Elevator)
0%
The Incredibly Deadly Viper (harmless snake, Series of Unfortunate Events)
8%
Bunnicula (vampire bunny, Bunnicula series)
42%
12 votes