*This review contains spoilers* I no longer use CSM (except to attempt to set the records straight when books/games/movies are rated unjustly), simply because I don't trust their reviewing anymore. It's usually inconsistent, it gives things too low age ratings and then turns around and rates things way too high. This book is certainly not bad enough to be marked no kids, and it was very well written; there is no reason why it should be rated two stars for reason of content alone. The language is mild compared to other YA novels, although I agree that the violence is very brutal. But things like this happen, and believe it or not, your children know about it. The sexual content isn't that heavy either, nothing is really described, and although the main character (who is female) has an affair with another girl, nothing "sexual" really happens. Here's my normal review for the book: I didn't care much at all for the first half of this book; I thought it was rather dysfunctional and not very gripping, but the second half was outstanding. The ending was rather vague, but still very satisfying, and it did a good job closing the generally gritty story on a happy note. This is the author's debut novel of course, and therefore we can't expect this to be amazing, although I see great promise in her. This is an author I will probably track, because her prose really is outstanding, and I found it nice that she tackled such heavy subjects so well in her first novel. The characters were built up very well, although there are absolutely zero adults that are good role models. The Haitian culture is a little hard to understand at times, but the author did a pretty good job of explaining why the family acted the way that they did. I would have liked the book to be a little longer, because I felt like it ended just when it was getting good. As I've said before, I didn't like the first half very much, but the book got exponentially better as it progressed, and I was sorry to see it come to such an abrupt close. I think the relationship between Karina and Rachael could have been explored a lot more, and the storyline still had a lot of promise to it. I suppose that it's a good thing that the book didn't go on too long and milk the characters and plot dry before it ended like a lot of YA books do these days, but I was left wanting more. So I rated the book two stars for the first half, and four stars for the second half, which should be three stars, but as a whole it actually has a pretty lasting impact. .
Tools for this page
Touching Snow
(2007, Fiction - Family Life, Written by M. Felin)
-
Is it age appropriate?
About our ratings(Flash is loading. If this text does not disappear you need to install the latest flash version)
Not age appropriate for kids under 17, age appropriate for kids over 17; suggested age 17. -
Is it any good?
-
Common Sense says
Vicious, graphic child abuse; not for kids at all.
Why We Rated This 
What to watch out for
-
Violence:
-
Sex:
-
Language:
-
Consumerism:
-
Drinking, drugs, & smoking:
What Parents Need to Know
About Touching Snow
Parents need to know that the horrifying and graphic depiction of child abuse marks this book as not for children. There is also plenty of swearing and drunkenness. Moreover, though the author herself is of Haitian descent, it would not be unreasonable for young readers to come away from this book with a very negative impression of Haitian people.
Read our full review by Matt Berman
Families Can Talk About
- Families can talk about Karina's dilemma: Should she turn in her stepfather to protect her siblings, which could cause them to all be put out on the street and their illegal relatives to be deported, or lie to protect him and hope that he will change his ways? Also, you could discuss the publisher's age-rating of 12 and up. Should children be exposed to this kind of material at 12? Why or why not? For what age do you think it is appropriate?
Our Members Say
Most Recent Reviews
- I rate this title iffy for age 15 and give itMy concerns are:
- Excessive violence
- I rate this title off for age 17 and give it
what was the aurthor thinking
the book has swearing it must costs alot of money and it is a rare book
- I rate this title on for age 2 and give it
Give Recommendations, Get Them, Too!
Become a member and get recommendations from other parents based on your child's age.Tell us your child's age:
Already a member? Log inOur Members Rate It
Ratings at a Glance
| 100% | of parents say it's too violent |
Have you read it? 
For Your Family
Get age-based recommendations for your kids:
Customize based on your child's age
