Parents need to know that this beautifully written and heart-rending story effectively depicts the suffering caused by war.
Positive messages:This book shows how war affects ordinary people and changes their lives
forever. Effectively exploring the complex issues behind the war, Irene
Hunt's well-researched historical tale is captivating and memorable.
Positive role models:One character defends the necessity of slavery. A brother opposes the
wishes of his family and leaves to fight for the South. Some young men
clamor for war; townspeople express hatred for Southerners and call for
them to be lynched.
Violence:Graphic reports of battles. Jethro is attacked, and his family is threatened by mob violence. The family's barn is attacked by an angry band of men. The death of a brother and near death of a friend of the family.
THIS IS THE WORST BOOK EVER WRITTEN IN HISTORY!! I had to read it for a history class and i hate it! It is the most BORING book ever published! It is so STUPID! It goes on and on and on about every little detail! For example, "Jethro went into town, he got to eat at a RESTAURANT and he got APPLE PIE! He walked with his right foot, then his left, right, left, right, left, and on and on and on. Then! He sat down then he carefully lifted his pie to his mouth and chewed slowly, savoring every piece...... and on and ON and ON!" Except in the book, it would have gone 20 pages about HOW he chewed and so on and so fourth.... AGAIN THIS IS EXTREMELY BORING. this book should really be revised to this: "Jethro is a very boring 10 year old boy who lives in a very boring town with his very boring family. Anyone who reads this book is promised to die of boredom. THE END." ;) I would NNNNNOOOOOTTTTT recomend this book to ANYONE!!!!!!
I thought this book would be pretty good. Unfortunately, it was incredibly dull and monotonous to read. Here's where the author went wrong: she chose to make the protagonist a person in the Civil War's younger brother. She should have made the protagonist somebody who was actually in the Civil War. It would have been much better that way.
I am an eighth grader in Ohio, and this book was in our curriculum. I am appalled at the comments posted by children of my age that use improper grammar, and are down right rude and offensive.
I've noticed many of the reviews mention a high amount of violence. I won't launch into a rant on this, but that's how things were, and we can't learn from our mistakes if books are sugar-coated. The descriptions are not that graphic.
I think this book has positive messages because it tells a story of how a family endures it's hard times in a decent way.
Overall, it was a good book. It was slow to start, but once it started, it was quite interesting to read about life back in the times of the Civil War. I enjoyed the bit of romance between Shadrach and Jenny. I feel it lit up the novel, showing how love can even blossom in the midst of death and war.
It was a good book, and I would reccomend it.
Across Five Aprils is by far the worst book i've ever read. i thought that the book would place scenes at the real battle, not just talk about it! It just talked about love or death, but........ if you love educational books than this one is for you.
I thought that the book was great. It told of the Civil War through a boys point of view that had to stay home with his family. It had love, family, and war in it.
The book is quite violent in some parts, but more than that, it's just BORING. I had to read it for school, and I have to admit, though it's NOT a good idea, I did skip some pages. At the climax it got better, but by the climax there were only about 30 or 40 pages left in the book. I don't really suggest reading it to anybody, because I don't want to waste their time.
well, it not easy to read and it depends on a person. If your kid likes books about war and how people do kill each other as soon as war is not only pretty uniform and beautifully trained soldiers.
This book perfectly describes how war can change someone's life.
However, it s a good book yo read in grade 9 as it has lots of history events.
I hated this book i had to read it for a book report and i fell asleep in every chapter im not even kidding. i DO NOT recommend this book for any person dead or alive
THIS BOOK IS CRAP. IF YOU WANT TO BE SO BORED ONE DAY, READ THIS BOOK! I WAS BORED TO DEATH. A5A IS A REALLY BORING BOOK. I THINK YOU GET MY POINT. IF NOT: ACROSS FIVE APRILS IS BORING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
This book is pretty boring at first and the dialogue is hard to read until you get used to it, but by the end you really feel something for Jethro and his family. Maybe the reason I didn't like this book so much was because it we had to read it for school.
ok so i just got to say when i read this book i was bored at the beginning then it was getting a liltle interesting but then it just got just as boring as it was in the beginning.
maybe i would of liked it a liltle more if i didnt have to read it for school. i would say over all...i wouldnt pick this book to read if i didnt have to.