About our rating system
ON: Content is appropriate for kids this age.
PAUSE: Know your child, some content may not be right for some kids
OFF: Not age appropriate for kids this age

A safe community is important to us.
Please observe our guidelines.

All member reviews for Catching Fire: The Hunger Games, Book 2

Judles10
parent of 12 and 14 year old
 
Stick to young adults - if that!
Every review I read about this book points to the premise of teenagers pitted against other teens to kill each other. To KILL each other? My 6th grade son was reading this and the prequel. Is this appropriate at a 6th grade level? The book reviews all state how violent and gory the book is. Some web sites say it might be appropriate for 12 and above, but most say that it is meant for young adults - not 6th graders. When my son told me about the plot - I asked to see the book. The first page I opened to had this excerpt: (SPOILER ALERT) "I glance around the training center. Peeta is at the center of a ribald circle of knife throwers. The morphlings from District 6 are in the camouflage station, painting each other’s faces with bright pink swirls. The male tribute from District 5 is vomiting wine on the sword-fighting floor. Finnick and the old woman from his district are using the archery station. Johanna Mason is naked again and oiling her skin down for a wrestling lesson. I decide to stay put." I am not a prude, but there is something wrong with exposure to this kind of information. VOMITING WINE? GETTING NAKED AND OILING HER SKIN DOWN? (SPOILER OVER) Not exactly the images I want my 11 year old, impressionable son to have in his mind. I wouldn't want him to see that in a movie and I do not want him reading such things. So here is my dilemma. I think that I am fighting against a society that feels that books and media about death, vampires, violence is OK for kids of all ages. I am up against a society whose rationalistic response is: "Oh they probably see worse things on cable TV". My son's response to me about this book is that one of his teachers read it and thought it was great. He said that his home room teacher recommended it. I tried to explain that just because an adult likes a book does not necessarily mean that it is appropriate for all kids. I told him that I like plenty of books, music and movies that he may not be old enough to be exposed to. That's why they put ratings on such things. So I monitor the TV, Cable, Music, computer games and Movies, but when these books are in the public library and are actually being encourage by the adults in his life; the adults he respects, how am I supposed to help him to see the hazards of reading such material? I am not only fighting against peer pressure, but pressure from all of society. Even looking at the reviews here is encouraging this book. So I was wondering why in the time he read the book my son was having a hard time sleeping and seemed a bit distant. We all wonder why there is such a bullying issue in schools and in society. I cannot help but to think that it has something to do with these images in his and other kids minds. It is a proven fact that exposure to such things has consequences. As an aside, I did not read the entire book, but I cannot see what all the rave reviews are referring to. From the little bit that I read, I think this is an extremely poor example of American Literature and English Grammar. All of the reviews talk about how riveting it is and how people cannot put it down. I found it quite boring with short choppy grammatically incorrect sentences. I am sure that one factor that compels a child to move to the next page is to find out if someone is going to get skewered or bludgeoned. If this is the best we can offer our kids, then we are a lost society indeed. And guess what - now they are looking at making a movie of this!

ReillyGuy2
kid, 13 years old
 
Very very good!
Not as good as the first but still very good. Some people below have put that it is not appropriate for teens but I disagree. One the best books I have ever read. It made me laugh and cry.

NoOneGurl
teen, 14 years old
 
Sparks have ignited!
Okay, here is my Catching Fire rant. W.O.W. Part one of the book, the victory tour, had plenty of (fake!) romance. On the train, Peeta and Katniss sleep together, but nothing happens. He's just there to keep away the nightmares. The romance just kept getting better and better. I must refer again to twilight here. The love triangle of Catching Fire is so much more complex. Katniss is confused and very indecisive about who she should choose. She has never been in love before, nor plans on it, because she doesn't want kids, at least not while she lives in Panem, anyway. In twilight Jacob never really stood a chance, whereas it could go either way in Mockingjay. The announcement of the Quell calls for some drinking between both Haymitch and Katniss. It also describes the after effects, which sort of encouraged the fact, don't ever do it! And when they arrive in the capitol, one character is found naked twice. No one shows any signs of discomfort but Katniss. Once the games begin, they are just as violent as ever, with a little more nudity. One line in the book says, "Our house has been so full of naked men this year." The ending was where a lot of loose end were tied, but more revealed as well. This book has it all -- action, thrill, suspense, romance, twists and turns that almost seem to make the page turn themselves. This brilliantly plotted, perfectly paced novel will not dissapoint. The cliffhanger ending will leave readers breathless and highly anticipating the next installment, Mockingjay. Excellent, absolutely excellent. ^ I rant about these books WAY too much. P.S. Team Peeta. Don't fight it.

 
Simply epic. What more, it's full of HUMANS!
Its one of the best books I've read in a very long time. Its honestly impossible to put down. Katniss is an amazing teen heroine and her story is amazing. This book had me laughing, crying, gasping... everything I need! It was actually quite educational! If I ever get stranded in a rainforest, I'll know exactly what to do :P The only thing that annoyed me was the ending. It left too much of a cliffhanger for my taste, although I will be at the bookstore the day it opens to by Mockingjay, the sequel and last part of the trilogy.

pepsicola14
teen, 13 years old
 
Parts a little gory for some adeunces
In a part of the book, there is a part where Katniss is talking about and discribing a nakes girl. she also talks breifly about sex. And I don't know why common sense media diddn't say anything about this, but there is a part where a main chricter is brutily beaten with a whip and then vividly discribes his wounds and recovery. And if you ask me, that my be hard for some people to handle.

movieviewermom
parent of 15 and 17 year old
 
A great read for teens and adults
This book (and Hunger Games before it) was hard to put down. Of course you know the heroine will survive, but it was still very suspenseful. My teenagers gobbled these books up. Due to the violence I wouldn't recommend this book for elementary aged kids. Anxiously awaiting Mockingjay......

girlbooklover96
teen, 18 years old
 
Ages 12+, Awesome!!!
I totaly loved Catching Fire. My class had to read the first book in the series, Hunger Games, and I checked it out of our local library, and couldn't wait to finish it. I already finished Catching Fire, and can't wait for the next in the series. For all the parent out there, his book is appropriate for kids, proabably ages 12 or so up, and for kids who won't take the violence seriously. There is quite a bit of violence, killing, etc., but a whole lot less then the first book. This one is more about how people don't like the government and what it is doing. BUt the book is great, and I think everyone should read it, even if they don't like sci-fi or fantasy!!! Hey don't pay attention to the age thing I am only 15!

AwalkeratCSM
teen, 14 years old
 
Tweens are ON!
My MOST favorite book in the Hunger Games trilogy! About everyone else' too. Crammed with action, suspense, and the terror of an evil government, this is probably one of the best books for teens in the bookstores. It gives teens a good beginners lesson on corrupt governments and thoughts about a dark future where the Constitution was a thousand years ago. The action would definitely be to boys liking, though the ongoing and torn romance would definitely make them disgusted. What drove me, past the darkness of rebellion and the shadow of the Capitol in this book, was the thirst for justice for the lovable characters that were killed for terrible reasons and all the devastation caused by the Capitol. Despite the deep depression and consequence embedded in the pages of this book, the readers will be driven to finish this epic tale of Katniss Everdeen to seek the truth of peace and justice. On the bad side, this book, like its precedor, carries some heavy and mature themes. Katniss has to return to an arena where children, and this time adults, have to kill each other in hideous ways to win the games and survive. The main character also has pretend, though she truly is, in love with another victor in the Hunger Games and some of the ways this was expressed I didn't consider appropriate. Haymitch, one of the characters, is a HEAVY drinker. The book is overall very dark and at times VERY depressing. You often feel as if the main character and everyone around her was sinking deeper and deeper into a black hole and unable to get out. Almost all the characters have distinctive flaws that play a lot in their actions and thoughts. A few are sweet and long-suffering, but this is not a good role model book. Despite these flaws, this is a GREAT book for tweens and teens alike. They will be glued till the end and then they'll think, "Wow, that was prize-winning!"

corina164
teen, 15 years old
 
I think it was 10 times better than 'Twilight'. Katniss's pain was so strong after loosing the people she cares for, I can feel her agony and grief through the pages. All Bella did was worry of everyone's safety when she never lost anyone too close like how Katniss lost her father and so many other people. She has reason to worry. Pick up Mockingjay, the story just gets better and sadder.

jenniejoy
parent of 8 and 10 year old
 
First of all I must say that one shouldn't review this book unless they read it. A reviewer below gave a long negative review of this book by reading only one page of the book. I find that ridiculous. I am parent of 3 children under the age of 10. I am very strict about what my kids can read, watch and play. When they reach the appropriate age....which I think is close to the actual age of the character Katniss, I can only hope my kids will read this book and we can discuss the incredible themes of this story. Themes of war, survival, friendship, politics, thinking for yourself and loyalty. I highly recommend this book. There is so much educational philosphy to be gained from this story. Its a horrific story......but the good in the human spirit prevails.

lilypadd
kid, 12 years old
 
<3
luv it

mandalouie143
parent of 19 year old
 
I read both the hunger cames and catching fire within two days; i couldnt set the book down i swear i cant wait till the third arives august 28,2010 and a movie triology is in action with the hunger games coming out in 2011.

KK2000
kid, 12 years old
 
READ IT!!!!!
BEST BOOK EVER!!!!!!! I read the hunger games series in the middle of fifth grade. I loved it sooooo much! Some parents may say that it is too violent, and it is very violent, but I thought that it was not too terrifying in that way. As long as you keep in mind that the series is totally fake, you won't get scared. I fell in love with all of the characters- especially Finnick Odair. I thought that the group of characters who go into (SPOILER ALERT) the second hunger games (the Quarter Quell) were absolutely hilarious. Collins' writing was great! The way she narrated the story (in Katniss' voice) was very funny. I put down good role models because throughout the series, the main characters are trying desperately to save their family and friends, even if it means risking their own lives. For example, in the first book, Katniss volunteered to be a tribute in the Hunger Games instead of Prim. Even though, towards the end of the series, some of the main characters become weak and may only think of themselves, I still thought that they were good role models, showing us that we are only human. I have read some reviews saying that the book should be 16 or 17 and up. I completely disagree. Many of my friends have read the series along with me, and we did not read it just to watch someone get impaled with a spear. We understood the book, had long conversations about it, and everyone I have talked that has read it has had one or more dreams about the amazing series. I honestly think that anyone who loves science fiction and adventure and who is at least 11 or 12 should read THE HUNGER GAMES SERIES!!!!!!!!!!!!!

JesusFreak09
teen, 16 years old
 
Amazing Awesome Incredible
I loved this! Even more then the first one It was hard to put it down and many times ithought she can't do that NO! but i loved it. P.S I am Team Gale! All the way....

Katita
parent of 7 , 10 , 14 , and 15 year old
 
The book is gripping. Loved to read it and definitely recommend it for teens. It gives you a lot to think about and talk about.

party of ei8ht
parent of and 3 , 10 , 10 , 11 , 13 , 15 year old
 
This was a gripping book with believable characters and a setting and plot that drew us all in. The violence in the book was shocking, but I think it is meant to be, to be able to relate to the struggles of the protagonists. My only complaints are regarding the increased description of characters being naked. In the first book it was used to describe Katniss being groomed for the games. In the second it is just unnecessary. Johannas character at the training complex? I felt it just added to the shock value of th ebook and did not add anything to the plot. As a parent, I cringed when I read those scenes.

ahcim3
parent of 18 year old
 
good for 15 and up. others;read at your own risk!
after i finished this book just as i was going to bed and when i closed the book just sat and stared at the ceiling till 5:45 in the morning!! this is a wonderful and powerful book and i would recommend it to any one of my colleges the violence (like in the last one) was brutal but quite necessary for the plot to continue unbroken, A "smashing good read"

 
Good book
Only on the fourth chapter and I'm already mad about this book. The author of this book is a sheer genius. Katniss Everdeen displays a way of getting through teen issues and the ups and downs of being a winner of the Hunger games. She makes mistakes, but she makes those mistakes for the good of her family, friends, and the rest of her country. Though the whole book has one theme that keeps coming up. This theme is that the government can not and should to be trusted. In the beginning of the book the president is described as smelling strongly of roses and blood. It may scare some kids and the books draw you into the next book. The last one, I am told, is violent, bloody, and depressing. My friend said it was like watching a train-wreak, you don't want to watch, but you just have to. She said it was good though...

tweeni
teen, 15 years old
 
an absolute MUST READ!
one of my fave's! the plot gets more intense, and the characters and storylinge never falter! however, the violence in the arena may be sensitive to younger kids. people die in gruesome ways; poisonous gases, bloodthirsty monkies, tsunamis, etc. peeta and katniss kiss; peeta pretends katniss is pregnant to gain favor from the croud. in the end, a large region is destroyed, where many families live. **SPOILER ALERT** however, nobody in katniss' family is killed. anyways, an awesome book any kid over eleven should read!

Kassie243
kid, 12 years old
 
I know that I'm only ten and I read it cover-to- cover, but, I fell in love with the book! I almost auditioned for the first book's movie... WAY TO VIOLENT I figured. It would be most likely be PG-13. But my brother is going to a book club on the 24th of FEB At the New Milford Public Library,