About our rating system
ON: Content is age-appropriate for kids this age.
PAUSE: Know your child; some content may not be right for some kids.
OFF: Not age-appropriate for kids this age.
Learning ratings
BEST: Really engaging, great learning approach.
GOOD: Pretty engaging, good learning approach.
FAIR: Somewhat engaging, OK learning approach.
NOT FOR LEARNING: Not recommended for learning.

A safe community is important to us.
Please observe our guidelines.

All member reviews for City of Bones: The Mortal Instruments, Book 1

Adult
April 17, 2009
 
Unpleasantly surprised
I was unpleasantly surprised at the inaccurate review given for this book. It doesn't mention language or sex and there was enough in the first chapter to cause me, an adult, to stop reading it. The first scene in the nightclub had sexual innuendo and harsh swearing. I am new to this website and it leaves me doubting the accuracy of the reviews. I am a positive person, but this left me jaded.

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
July 18, 2009
 
best since harry potter
i love love love LOVE this book. best ever. the characters suck you into the story and keep you guessing till the very end, and even after that. there is just enough romance to get tweens interested but not so much that they're lying awake thinking about terrible things. the blood is no big deal because THERE ISN'T THAT MUCH. great book, i highly reccommend

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 17 years old
June 24, 2010
 
a twist can ruin a book
ok i officialy loved this book... till the turn at the end of the book... (dont read any further if you havnt fully read it)... this book seemed like the perfect book... im pretty good at telling what is going to happen next in a book and by about the middle of the book i knew that either jace or clary were going to be valintines children... i even had the idea that they both would be valintines children, but i would always push it to the back of my head because i though the author would be crazy to make them related.... aparently she is.... ill give her props for making the book take a different direction... i mean after all every book now a days has the girl and guy fall in love... but for once i think it wuld be better that way. sometimes you shouldnt mess up the classics. this book would be a perfect 5 if it wasnt for them becoming brother and sister at the end

Flag as inappropriate 
Parent of 5, 7, 10, and 11 year old
October 27, 2009
 
Has it's moments but not good for young teens
This book about the hidden world where good and evil are at war is action filled and has it's moments. That said it contained LOTS of sexual innuendo, homosexual romance (more in the next books with an adult male with a teen male), some graphic violence, and the adults in the books are generally not good or iffy at best. The teens in the book are on their own to solve their problems and break rules or deceive the adults in charge to do it. The underground world is full of drinking, sex and violence for both the "good" and "evil" characters. Very little separates one group from the other in some aspects.

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 14 years old
June 9, 2011
 
Amazing!
This is an amazing book that I absolutely loved. The action is suspenseful, the characters full of personality and excellent role models, and the message of staying true to yourself is clear throughout the entire book. *SPOILER* I was extremely disappointed when we found out that Jace and Clary were siblings, because it was so obvious how much they loved each other. I'm really, really hoping for Magnus and Alec- they're awesome!

Flag as inappropriate 
Parent of 13 and 15 year old
June 29, 2009
 
A Twilight-esque fantasy that will appeal to boys.
It's hard for me not to review this novel independantly of the second and third book in the trilogy - which reader's of the first novel will be compelled to read. They are fun books with lots of references to demonology and angels - most of which are based in Judeo-Christian mythology. The books, in my opinion, neither support nor directly contradict a reader's faith (or lack of faith) - and reader's will likely put these books down entertained and with their world-view unimpacted. There are no explicit sexual encounters, but there are numerous scenes with lots of sexual tension and kissing. Many of these scenes are between two characters that believe they are biological siblings. Two supporting characters have a homosexual relationship. Teen characters drink at parties. There are almost constant and graphic descriptions of demon-killing. The adults in this novel are almost all negligent, untrustworthy, or evil. I read these on the recommendation of a ninth-grade student. I think they will appeal to teens and will likely interest boys much more than the Twilight phenomenon has. However, due to the content and the teens behaving solidly as teens, I'd put the age limit a bit higher than the main review and reserve them for high schoolers.

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 17 years old
July 27, 2009
 
Adored this book!
This is one of my favourite books! It's exciting and always keeps you guessing with new suprises at every turn. From the moment I picked up this book, I was addicted! Cassandra Clare keeps you hanging with every page!

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 16 years old
April 13, 2011
 
Definitely iffy for teens and definitely NOT for tweens.
This series, as a whole, is too sexual to be appropriate for kids 12+. There are multiple scenes implying sex, especially later in the series. A girl is described as having her shirt unbuttoned displaying her bra while kissing a boy.

Flag as inappropriate 
Parent of 15 year old
August 27, 2009
 
Great for adults, use discretion for tweens, inappropriate for children
There was a lot of minor curse words and one gd word in this book. The book would have been just as good if not better if it had left out the language. The plot was awesome, the action kept you on the edge of your seat. Could not put it down. As a parent, I edited out the curse words so my 14 yr old could read it.

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
February 5, 2009
 
Wonderful Read!
This book was absolutely amazing! A beautiful plot, intriguing characters, and great action. There is swearing fairly often, including sh-t, p-ss, d-mn, h-ll, -ss, and the Lord's name in vain. One guy is mentioned as being gay, and another man winks at him and says 'call me'. Maybe an innuendo or two. It was truly a wonderful book that I recommend to anyone thirteen and older.

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 17 years old
February 1, 2009
 
Beyond my Expectations
Considering this book sloshes together witches, warlocks, werewolves, vampires, and even demons, I was a little scared of how it would turn out. I was suprised. This book was really entertaining. It has some good twists, although you can probably compare some parts to other books and movies. Besides that, It's a great book. I absoulutely fell in love with Jace. But hey, is there many teen books where you don't fall in love with a character? I can't wait to read City of Ashes!! I only said 12 years old because i want kids to actually understand ans soak up all the great stuff theyre reading!

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 17 years old
June 30, 2011
 
Angels and Demons– done differently.
One of my top five favorite book series (up there with Harry Potter and the Hunger Games). While it may seem like a guilty pleasure novel at first, this story does have some intriguing allusions to angels and almost Islamic beliefs about them. It has positive messages about friendship and overcoming prejudice (One character is gay, another is a rather scary-looking warlock that's good at heart). Violence is prominent (hey, they're demon slayers) but is never overdone. Sexual references are present, but as I said, they're only references. Sex does not actually occur.

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 16 years old
September 4, 2009
 
this book is nothing less than brillaint! lovable characters and a excting plan line. the 1st books just leaves u graving for the next then the next.

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
February 19, 2010
 
There's no reason to hate it...
I will admit, within the first three chapters, I knew that Jace was her brother. It was just one of those books that it would happen. Poor kid, hahaha! (Sorry for the spoiler there, but it had to be said) I wouldn't want someone younger than 14 reading this, especially with the reference to homosexuality and the general sense of amorality and us vs them mentality in the book. However, once I read on I came to recognize the common themes that lace these types of books, where the individual strength of the person was the ultimate strength. As well as the darkened theme of good versus evil. I would by no means hand this book to a child and say to them "learn from it" but I would let them read it and say "here's something entertaining." It's not a waste of time, just something that will consume it more pleasurably than others.

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 17 years old
April 23, 2009
 
For an older audience
This book was amazing.Some sexual things mentioned,Very detailed,Gory,bloody, I shouldn't waited till i was older to read but still a awesome book

Flag as inappropriate 
Parent of 11 and 14 year old
January 8, 2010
 
I am reading it now and I am quite surprised that the main page says there was only a mention of herbal exctasy. In the first 5 pages there was a cocaine mention (packet of white powder), herbal exctacy(ha I cant even spell it!), not to mention the mention of a hardcore makeout session.. It stinks cause gramma got it and my 12.5 y/o is done with 1&2. Oh and the smoking of Clove cigs, which just became legal again where I live. However she knows my stance on drugs and she has one of her own. The thing is those things went right over her head. She didnt know what they meant. I wonder how much of the book she even gets. Seems like a complicated storyline if you dont even get those references. We'll use it as a way to talk about things. I read Christopher Pike as a 12 y/o and recently reread one. There were refernces to coke there even then. It's funny I didn't get it as a kid. But, It also didnt cause me to became a drug addict, sexual deviant or anything else I am worried about happening to my kid.

Flag as inappropriate 
Kid, 13 years old
July 4, 2010
 
One of the Best Books I've Ever Read
I thought the book was amazing! People are complaining about the coke and herbal ecstasy parts but they weren't even bad! It was mention ONCE! And none of the main character were even doing that stuff! And they sweared what?, twice in a book that's about 480 pages long! That's really good compared to most books! And about Jace and Clary being brother and sister, I'm pretty sure in the books to come it will be revealed that they really aren't. For two reasons: 1. Being that Jace doesn't look anything like Valentine OR Clary's mom, Jocelyn. Shouldn't he have at least one of their traits if he's their son?, but no he doesn't. 2. And I peeked in one of my friend's copie of a book later in the trilogy and Clary picked Jace over Simon, and since Simon is in love with her, I'm guessing that she was picking who she loved. Well anyways, I'll find out soon!

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
May 11, 2011
 
Caution, not for young teens.
I bought this book on the advice of a friend's 12 year old daughter for my 13 year old son. He was reading another book so I read it. I was a little shocked to be truthful. The kids go to all age clubs and are out at midnight or after on Sunday night. There is reference to drinking, drugging and smoking at the club although the types of drinks and drugs are not of our world. There is mention of Herbal Estacy use. One kid drinks a cocktail he shouldn't have and turns into a mouse. The cocktails are very attractively described in the book. There is clove cigarette smoking but not by the main characters. There is tons of bloody violence with lots of graphic detail. In the book they are killing demons and other creatures not of our world but there is still blood and gore and vivid descriptions of the violent killings. I think it's definitely a book for older teens and not appropriate for 13 and under. I have enjoyed reading the book and am now reading the next one (City of Ashes) but I am not going to offer them to my son just yet.

Flag as inappropriate 
Parent of 12 and 14 year old
April 7, 2011
 
Great Series!
Great series, good adventure

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 16 years old
April 3, 2010
 
havent read it yet but i know that stephenie meyers have and she said 13 and up so it cant be that bad

Flag as inappropriate