Parents need to know that this story, based on one from the author's own life, is of a father-daughter hunting trip. Though the father carries a rifle, he does not use it. All of the hunting is done by the little girl and her crow call. Though the story finishes on a happy note, the ending is a bit unusual
and may be confusing to younger children. So, though the book itself is
aimed at a 4- to 8-year-old audience, it seems more appropriate for
kids in the older part of that range.
Positive messages:Spending time together helps bring the young girl and her father closer together.
Positive role models:The father is tender and thoughtful with his daughter. He shows that he appreciates her, values her opinions, and enjoys letting her be her own person.
Violence & scariness:The father goes out with a gun meaning to shoot birds but doesn't use it.
Our ratings and reviews are informed by child development guidelines. Learn more.
Althought the story fits with an older age group, the format fits with a younger. In the end, I found that no one wanted to read it.
Although it was recommended for my 8 year old, the book is in the children's section and recommended by Chapters for ages 3-5. My 8 year old would be insulted that I didn't buy her a chapter book.
I'm sure it's very good, but it seems conflicted that the format is for 3-5 year olds, but CommonSense puts it at 7+