i really loved this book as much as i loved eragon, but i noticed something in this book that hadnt been in the first. in one chapter, where an elf is talking to eragon, they are talking about beliefs, such as there is no God, etc. quite a few things were mentioned, and i was disappointed because it was made to look like the right point of veiw, and eragon leans toward this way, and that is a big influence on younger kids. personally i thought that the book didn't need that in there, but since it is, be prepared if you don't agree with it and read it before you give it to your kids.