As far as I've read, which isn't very far, maybe half the book, violence is a small issue for me, but otherwise it is amazing and I adore Christopher Paolini for writing the Inheritance cycle . Yes, many deaths and piles of bodies does sound very gross and inappropriate. As a preteen, I find this mild as I prefer to read books out of my age group. It simply must cling to the plot as it is a good vs. evil story. Language is not a major issue either, so far, in my perspective. Others say the butcher and Eragon's conversation is not needed, inappropriate and especially the one word used. The conversation with the butcher and Eragon is a mild argument, from my thought, as the butcher is implying that the Spine is a cursed place, referring to a description earlier in the beginning where strange men and creatures emerge from the woods. Eragon is great role model to young children who can understand the book. He holds bravery and confidence in his grasp. I would also suggest to parents that if your child is reading for fantasy enjoyment or educational purposes alike, let them read in a silent area such as their room or a library if you come across one. I read in my sun room as noise doesn't pass through the walls as much. Also, if they are reading and concentrating hard, and keep repeating the same page out of noisiness from others, turn the volume down on TVs, computers, stereos, and such. Otherwise, perfect for a vocab lesson, which can be educational if they are entering middle school. Many words are from Paolini's big vocabulary; some being unreadable at first, but will be understandable afterwords.