About our rating system
ON: Content is age-appropriate for kids this age.
PAUSE: Know your child; some content may not be right for some kids.
OFF: Not age-appropriate for kids this age.
Learning ratings
BEST: Really engaging, great learning approach.
GOOD: Pretty engaging, good learning approach.
FAIR: Somewhat engaging, OK learning approach.
NOT FOR LEARNING: Not recommended for learning.

A safe community is important to us.
Please observe our guidelines.

All parent reviews for Eragon: The Inheritance Cycle, Book 1

Age
11
Parent of 7 and 10 year old
August 8, 2010
 
This is a book for people looking for a light,easy, and mildly entertaining read. It's not meant to be some fabulous work of literature - it was written by a teenager! That means there is plenty of action, a young man trying to figure out his purpose (and choosing to do what is right and use his gifts for the good of many rather than himself), a little romance, and a dragon. My 9 year old girl read this book on the advice of our local librarian and she loved it. I read it too and thought it was a nice way to spend an evening. Great writing? Not totally. Easy to read for an adult? Yep. A challenge to read for a younger child? Yep. The violence is what you would expect from a teen, and yet there is an entire section devoted to Eragon's uneasiness with a companion's violent actions - so much so that Eragon suggests a means for the companion to make up for it. As a character, Eragon questions himself and tries to do what is right. He is accepting of others that the society of the book deem unworthy. He does not blindly trust, but relies on more than just what someone says to form his opinions. And with any form of media, most of these kinds of lessons are lost if you don't discuss them with your children after they read it. While the descriptions of violence are graphic to an adult, is that the same image a child will conjure (unless they have beene exposed to those images in video games or movies)? I am looking forward to book 2.

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
February 3, 2011
 
It has language!!!
I started reading this book and loved it. But I read farther into it (where Eragon is talking to the butcher) and, to my dissapointment, there was some language. I do not believe in reading, hearing, or saying any language, and I stopped reading the book right there. I would not recomend this book.

Flag as inappropriate 
Parent of 8 and 10 year old
November 11, 2010
 
A great read for teens and even adults, but too violent for younger kids.
I read this book when it first came out and loved it. I have since read all the others and anticipate the fourth (and final) installment when it comes out. However, when my 9 year old daughter brought it home from the library, I was concerned it may be too violent for her. She is a sensitive child and I am afraid the imagery may be too much for her right now. (An instance of a pile of dead bodies including an infant with a spear through it especially concerns me.) After reading the reviews on this site, I have decided to ask her to wait to read it until next year at the earliest.

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
January 9, 2011
 
Pure inspirational: A must read for fans of fantasy
Probably the most inspirational thing about this book is how a young writer accomplished such a great piece of literature. I recommend this for pre-teens and up. The only content that may be questionable is the depictions of blood and gore, and some people might be turned off by the use of magic and divination.

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
April 9, 2008
 

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
April 9, 2008
 
THis book is the best since thae lord of the rings trilogy.
THis book is appropriete for people 13 and up. It has some complicated words to it that make it kind of hard to follow.

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
April 9, 2008
 

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
February 10, 2009
 
One of the most overblown books I've ever read
When I look at all of the popularity that this book has garnered, I ask myself, "Is the audience a bunch of kids who have never even picked up a real fantasy book before?" The number of cliches, and words thrown in in Paolini's own "language" is ridiculous. In the later books, it only gets worse. I am forced to constantly (especially in Eldest) turn to the reference page in the back that details the meanings of his "words of magic". This alone shows pure inexperience. There is also great evidence that he used a thesaurus in numerous places in order to "expand his vocabulary". Sometimes the words he interjects may be classified as synonyms, but they do not mean the same thing. Lastly the plot is painful obvious as being imitated straight from the epic Star Wars series. Not worth the buy, or the time you waste reading it.

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
April 9, 2008
 
Very good, we have a new author to watch
This book was very well written. I think that Christopher Paolini is a very good author and will most likely have a very long career as an author. Any Lord of the Rings or Well of Time fans will enjoy this book. I personally cant wait untill the second book comes out.

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
April 9, 2008
 
A wonderfull book!!!
I love the book and I am only on page 35!!!

Flag as inappropriate 
Parent
October 29, 2011
 
violance
don't read it!

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
October 20, 2009
 
Not Too Objectionable, Just Bad
The most surprising thing about this otherwise flat, overlong retread of ground blazed by Tolkien and Campbell is its atheist agenda. You see, the elves in this book are atheists, which would be fine in and of itself, but they're also an entire race of Mary-Sues. They're the most beautiful, magical, and good creatures in Paolini's derivative world, and anyone who disagrees with them is either stupid, evil, or both. This is a relatively minor issue in the book, though, and were the content worth reading, it wouldn't be enough to stop me from recommending the book. But, as many other reviewers have said, Eragon is a shameless copy of Star Wars: A New Hope cloaked in generic high fantasy tropes. Actually, that may be giving Paolini too much credit. Had he ripped off Star Wars more closely, Eragon might have been a gripping narrative, if nothing else. But the author has pretensions to, well, pretentiousness. So he plumbs the thesaurus for fancy synonyms without understanding their connotative meaning, claims to have invented a new language when all he's done is made up a couple dozen words, and sends his protagonist on a textbook hero's journey without any idea how to make that journey compelling. In lieu of organic characterization, the reader is bluntly told what characters are supposed to be like. Magic, rather than operating according to coherent rules, works (or fails to work) as the plot demands, in often self-contradictory ways. The story is so full of plot holes that it only functions because characters--ones we've been told are intelligent--consistantly make the stupidest possible choices. If you're easily frustrated by bad writing, you'll hate this book. If not, you'll likely just be bored.

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
April 9, 2008
 
Challenging, original fantasy for middle school children and their parents.
As an avid reader of science fiction and fantasy, I couldn't believe I was enjoying a "children's" book. An engaging central character, intelligent writing and a thrilling plot kept me interested to the end. I recommend you read it before your child does to judge whether some of the violence ( father figure viciously dispatched) will be too emotionally charged.

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
April 9, 2008
 
Geez, I am blown away!
This book was so amazing! I loved it so much! I read it like three years ago, and last winter I read it a second time! I'd say it would be for ages twelve and up, because there is a lot of death and fighting, but there wasn't anything inappropriate in it whatsoever. Eldest, the sequel, was just as good! I don't know if I'll ever be able to find another series this good!

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
April 9, 2008
 
I read this book... obviously...
This book was wonderful. I am currently working on the second, Eldest, and the story is completely consuming. I loved this book and started reading it the day I got it and read well into the night until my mom made me stop. The next day I started reading it again and read until I had missed the opportunity to go to the movies with my friends. I totally loved this book and recommend it to everyone.

Flag as inappropriate 
Parent of 13 year old
July 8, 2010
 
Great Book for Fantasy Lovers!
My daughter and I both read this book and really liked the fact that a teen actually wrote it! I thought it was good, but you do have to be a fantasy lover to get through all those pages! My daughter started it when she was eight and put it down, but when she was twelve she started reading it and really liked it! She could have read it earlier but all those pages can be pretty daunting to kids under 9. I didn't think that the violence was that big of a problem but it can get really dense at times if you are not a fantasy lover! :D

Flag as inappropriate 
Educator and Parent of 11 and 11 year old
September 11, 2009
 

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
November 27, 2008
 
Eragon: A Boring Review
Eragon is the first of a trilogy of fantasy books written by the author, Christopher Paolini. This book was chosen by me because it was recommended as a fantasy novel that was rich in creativity, themes and surprises with lessons of life to be learned. The main character is supported by a variety of smaller secondary characters that are extremely diversified. This is what made me want to read this novel. The main character, Eragon is a poor farm boy whose destiny changes upon discovery of a polished blue stone that ultimately hatches a dragon that he names Saphira. Gifted with only an ancient sword, his loyal dragon and fatherly advice from an old storyteller named Brom; Eragon is soon swept into a dangerous tapestry of magic, power and glory. He is confronted with choices to save, destroy or be swallowed by the evil Empire of King Galbatorix. Eragon is transformed into a Dragon Rider through his bond with Saphira. He develops distinctive abilities such as sword fighting, magic and the ancient ways of the Dragon Riders and their Elven Language. The author captivates the reader by leading the main character through a variety of character testing encounters as he travels across harsh terrain in his quest to avenge the death of his uncle and the destruction of their village by King Galbatorix. The storyline is injected repeatedly with supporting characters that possess phenomenal abilities. I loved this book because of its distinction and difference from the other fantasy novels I have read in the past. Paolini has gone through great trouble to construct the plot of this fantasy. The introduction, however, is understandably confusing because a myriad of fictitious locations, mystical characters and unusual encounters forces the reader to really concentrate in order to develop a visual picture of what is happening. The author tries to make this easier with a map, printed on the inside cover of the novel. I found myself having to refer to the map numerous times in order to keep on track with the introduction. Even though it is difficult to understand the interaction of several of the characters, there are many small, but exciting events that escalate as part of the rising action of the novel. Examples of these include: the hatching of the dragon from the “polished blue stone”, the revelations by the storyteller, Brom, and the sudden invasion and destruction by the King’s servants as they search for the dragon egg. The rising action of this fantasy simulates the northern face of the Himalayas with jagged peaks pointing into the sky, which leaves the reader anxious for the fall. Almost the entire novel consists of a rising tension with gentle drops depicted by Eragon’s battles until the very end when his quest to become the ultimate Dragon Rider is fulfilled. The climax of the novel is very distinct when Eragon encounters the full force of the King’s army using all the skills that he has learned from Brom with the support of his dragon. Interestingly, the climax is not as enchanting as the rest of the novel and its rising action. Following the climax, the denouement is extremely brief, depicted as Eragon’s collapse with exhaustion and pain following his successful duel with Durza, the dark sorcerer. Subsequent to the denouement, the reader is found searching for a resolution that doesn’t exist as Paolini leaves the story at a hook. This hook prompts the reader, quite convincingly to read the next book in the series, Eldest. The main character, Eragon, is supported by a vast array of secondary characters. Confusion arises in the reader as it is difficult to keep track of each character and the rather small amount of time devoted to develop each individual. This is part of Paolini’s plot to replace many of the protagonists that are lost by death in each fight. Nevertheless, this keeps the book fascinating. Eragon, his dragon called Saphira and the elderly storyteller named Brom are put forward as the main characters around which many segments of the novel revolve around. Eragon is a brave, young, inquisitive warrior that receives guidance from Brom. He receives great support from his dragon Saphira, whose constant presence gives continuity to the novel. As some characters are lost in the battles, Paolini constantly introduces new ones. The theme of this tale can best be described with the words family, love, bravery and redemption. The concept of family serves as a driving force in the novel because the death of Eragon’s relatives by brute force propels him to seek out the evil doers and avenge his uncle’s death. It gives the reader something to relate to because we can empathise with him. Secondly, love allows us to see a very human part of Eragon in that he is not just a warrior. His love of family and in particular, the point in the novel when he falls in love with the poisoned elf, Arya allows the reader a chance to connect with the main character. Thirdly, bravery is seen repeatedly in every battle and in particular, his long journeys into the unknown where he is forced to prove himself. Finally, the theme of redemption is shown when Eragon assumes full responsibility for the death of his Uncle and hence, tries to make up for this tragedy by seeking revenge. The author brings up these themes of the book repeatedly and gives the reader an ability to predict Eragon’s next move because he acts by his conscience. The genre of this book is fantasy and fiction. The problem with fantasy is that it appeals to only a certain audience. I usually do not like fantasy very much, but this book was excellent. I liked almost every aspect of it; which was a pleasant surprise to me. The issue of fantasy allowed Paolini to introduce a tremendous amount of creativity into the novel resulting in a storyline that was quite unique. The use of fiction in this novel enabled a variety of fascinating settings, characters and moods. Hence, the use of fantasy and fiction was an excellent way to captivate the reader. The mood of Eragon was very similar to an emotional roller coaster ride that travelled mostly upwards into the climax. Discovery of the dragon egg, the assembly of the members of his expedition and learning that Saphira had supernatural abilities were really high points in Eragon’s travels. Unfortunately, there were many losses to Eragon and in particular when Brom dies, there is a powerful mood of sadness. When Saphira gets injured, not only is the reader disheartened but also, I felt like the book could easily lose a very fascinating character and its interest if she is killed. Finally when his friend, Murtagh is taken prisoner, and Arya is sent away by the dwarf king, it is very melancholy because this places the burden of the importance of this quest on his and Saphira’s shoulders alone. The emotional ride through this fantasy land really keeps the reader riveted. The tones that Paolini sets for the novel are sombre and solemn. The deep ambition of Eragon to avenge the death of his beloved family and the destruction inflicted by the King is depicted repeatedly throughout the novel creating a strong contrast of good and evil in every chapter. I really feel that although this is a fiction and fantasy novel, the tone gives it a lot of credibility. I think that this is an excellent choice of tone because when a happy event occurred, it created a great relief to me, even though I knew a sad event will follow. Paolini carefully describes a medieval type of setting in which his fictitious land through which Eragon travels is free of technology. There are no mechanical means of transportation and no machines described. One can not find any description of any electricity or artificial lighting and the people seem to keep themselves warm with the use of fire. This medieval setting is fascinating and creates an excellent background for the use of magic, witchcraft and sorcery. This setting also allows many battles to happen with the use of only swords and spears. These battles enable Eragon to display his wit, physical capabilities, and skill as a Dragon Rider. Inside the front cover of the novel, Paolini has produced a map of the villages in relation to the deserts, mountains and forest that can place the individual at a real challenge. In his journey, Eragon passes through many villages and cities. At each stop, he develops a new skill and learns crucial information. Arrival at each destination also results in an opportunity for a suspenseful encounter. He perfects his flying skills as a Dragon Rider by flying on Saphira from place to place. Hence, Paolini’s organization of the cities and towns are perfectly matched with the storyline and timeline. In conclusion, Eragon turned out to be a surprisingly riveting fiction and fantasy novel. The main character is one we can emulate and empathise with. I was surprised by how captivating it could be, despite my previous history of disliking fantasy novels. I would highly recommend this novel to anyone looking for an imaginary escape.

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
April 9, 2008
 
I can not wait for the next one!
Eragon is such a good book. I read it so fast because I couldn't wait to see what was going to happen next. I loved it so much that I'm reading again. Some people say that it is very similar to Lord of the Rings - I agree with them but it was just a little like it. All of the characters are so cool - (my favorite is either Murtagh, Durza, or of course Eragon). I also liked Brom, Saphira, and Arya. The author creates very interesting kinds of characters - urgals, shades, etc. My guess is that this book is better for kids than adults, (even though I really want my parents to read it). After reading it I must say I wish I was a dragon rider.

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
April 9, 2008
 
Star Wars on Dragons
The one good thing about this book is that it is written in a way that keeps the plot moving, and keeps you interested. However, the plot is taken straight from Star Wars: A New Hope. I also felt the author was trying to make this book COOL.

Flag as inappropriate