My teacher has this book in her class and she doesn't think it is that appropriate and I agree with her which is why I think Kids my age should not read this.
i love these books! although Seth is a complete idiot, and stays that way through the series, he ends up cleaning up his messes. he's a terrible role model, Kendra, however lame she is, is a terific role model, and my sister's favorate charachter. there is one scene where Grandpa and the Saytrs are celebrating, and drink a bit.
Some very intense parts during a chapter title "Midnight Summer's Eve" where a young infant is depicted walking on a a roof to lure Seth to letting demons into the house. Other that one chapter I loved the book and the series. I recommend it highly after instructing parents to read the above chapter and decide if it is appropriate for their child's level of maturity.
I just selected 2 years old for the age cause i think everyone should be allowed to read it...moving on.
This is probably the best series I've ever read. My favorite character is Warren ( the catatonic, Dale's brother) because i like the idea that he has all these compressed emotions under his blank expression because I can relate.
I stumbled upon this book while seeking something to replace the gap left by Harry Potter. While the writing isn't as good, and Mull is just getting started here, I found myself swept up in the magic, and eager for more. I went into it not knowing anything about it at all, which is the way I like to approach new fantasy, so every experience is unexpected. The book is classic good and evil, where two children unite to save the world. Some scenes may be difficult for the very young, but overall, I found it enchanting and something I want to recommend. As far as stereotyping, Mull could have switched the genders, but then it would have been an obvious ploy at political correctness. I've had enough of that to last me, thanks. I give it five stars for multigenerational inclusion and family togetherness.
It teaches you that life is not always as it seems, and that sometimes you need to get over your fears to save someone else. Seth and Kendra are willing to save each other's lives and care about each other very much. Best book ever! My 8-year-old sister read it and she LOVED it!
Wonderful Fantasy Book, Even Non-Fantasy People Would Love It
When I read this book, I loved it. It is amazingly enjoyable, and every book in the series gets better than the last. As for the content:
Language: Absolutely none. The kids tease eachother a little bit, but there is no cussing.
Drugs: In the second book (I'm reviewing the entire series) to the last book, there as some "potions" that people can drink that give them "fake emotions" like false bravery, but no actual drug use.
Violence: There is a little bit of violence, but nothing graphic or described.
I really would recomend this book to anyone, no matter what the age. The only possible thing I can think of that some parents may not like is like the CommonSense review states, Seth is constantly disobeying. He does get better at making decisions throughout the books though.
Bottom line, even if you don't like fantasy books, you'll probabl like this. I hate fantasy. XD
When I read this book it I couldn't put it down. I think I ended up reading the whole thing in a week. I was thinking at the time that it was the best book I ever read. Then I started reading the sequal: Rise of the evening star and REFUSED to pick the book back up after I put it down.
ClaireGuthrie parent of and 6 , 9 , 11 , 18 , 19 year old
7
Awesome......but watch out for the disobedience
Probably the best series I have ever read. My kids from 4 up to 16 enjoyed it. We listened to it on CD on a road trip. The constant disobedience of Seth is not a good role model..... this concerns me. I have had to talk to the kids about consequences to bad behaviour, because this character is not really ever punished for his disobedience.
This was a great book that I didn't want to put down! The main characters Seth & Kendra are likable and you can't help but wish that they make the right choices when faced with the never ending obstacles and situations they encounter while staying with their grandparents at Fablehaven. Magical creatures abound throughout the story and pay attention because many will resurface in the books 2-5. Although Seth sometimes goes against the rules, his heart is in the right place. A great beginning to a great kids series!
Read with your child - you'll both enjoy this book.
Good and bad role models. As others have stated, Seth's behavior doesn't seem to receive much punishment and he never quite seems to learn. I hope to see the character develop a little maturity soon.
On the upside of negative role models, it's a great read and a perfect opportunity to read with your kids. Opens up great dialogue about appropriate behavior and the dangers of breaking the rules. Easy to equate with their own neighborhood and why we have family/friend rules.
Personally, I adore these books (all of them) and my daughter does, as well. She loves to read but still looks forward to our reading time together when it comes to these books. I would highly recommend reading the book with your child! It's a great escape for both of you!
this book is one of the best ive read ,once you start reading it you can not put it down!! Perfect for anyone who loves action,adventure,and fantasy should read this book!
I loved this book! My kids loved it, even my 10 year old that doesn't like to read. Seth does make some pretty bad choices but I feel like he suffers the consequences for those choices. I like the opposites in Kendra and Seth. It really shows kids that they don't have to make the wrong choices. I love how magical the story is and my children loved escaping into that world when they had a hard day. I also like that I don't have to worry about language or sexual references.
Great read...fun storyline and fatastic characters! I would recommend it to anyone.
This novel I guess was okay. The characters were not really the greatest kids. I probably wouldn't want to meet them. The violence isn't too exciting and isn't really anything new. The plot: Two kids, Kendra and Seth have to spend their summer with their grandparents, who they haven't even met before. Their grandparents end up being caretakers of a magical refuge for mythical creatures such as, witches, fairies, goblins and the like. I guess Kendra and Seth are good siblings, but Seth is way too reckless. I have never, ever met any kid that stupid, or reckless with annoys me a lot. The only reason why I read it was because my Grandmother got for me, and I didn't want to just leave it on my bookshelf collecting dust. After I finished it, I still had a urge to read the rest, so my grandmother got me the next two books, and I really saw the beauty of this series... the excitement, and action that led ahead. I would of given this series two stars, but because I liked the other books, I'll give it one more. Because this review is sappose to be only about the first one in the series, I'll continue talking about the book. So, I guess if you want to get your kid something they'll really read get them a copy and see how they like them... enjoy!