I loved the book but one disturbing episode verges on self-multilation
I took turns reading this book out loud with my 9 year old daughter. We both loved it but there was one chapter that I found disturbing and wanted to share with other parents. Early on in the book, Harry is sent to detention and asked to write lines "I will not..." as punishment by a sweetly sadistic new teacher. As he writes the lines with quill on paper the same words appear as cuts on his hand, due to the curse/magic the teacher has placed on him. Though the cuts are extremely painful, he decides to bear them without flinching under her gaze, and does not report the punishment (which he is quite certain is illegal) to Dumbledore. This punishment is repeated several times, each time with the cuts/scars getting deeper. I found this a pretty close and disturbing analogy to secret self-mutilation. And though this association went over my 9 year old's head - it might not go over a teen's.
I was really looking forward to this book and was a little disapointed with the way it was writtien.
First of all Harry is alway angry. He thinks everyone is against him. He is yelling at everyone at his teachers, friends and supporters. He, once again, doesn't ask for help from Dumbledor. Harry feels everyone is against him. This gets old fast. He also gets punished by not being able to do a lot of his favorite things.
Harry gets his first kiss, but it wasn't handled correctly. The book tries to deal with it in a non romantic way and it makes Harry look like he didn't really want to kiss the girl but felt he had to.
Some parts of the book are interesting. Snape teaches Harry how to block thoughts and Harry gets to go into Snapes darkest feelings. Harry learns that his parents were not as perfect as he thought they were. It's an interesting twist, since he has only heard only positive things about his parents.
Someone close to Harry dies in the book. Harry had a lot of questions that he wanted to ask them which will now remained unanswered.
The Weasly twins were great in this book. They had a lot of neat jokes and stunts that they were pulling.
Overall, it's the same formula. Harry doesn't trust any of the adults and doesn't go to them for help. The kids need to fight evil in the end and come out victorious.
Also I felt there were too many characters for kids to follow. She also doesn't give any introduction of what happened in the previous book. Kids will need to get updated themsleves.
I still gave the book a 3 star rating. It was interesting and took me less that 24 hours to read.
the book is too long and the story drags on and on. Many people will not like it and some younger kids won't undesrtand or remember anything that happens.
Good for tweens if they know the things in it arent real.
Harry is a good role model because hes brave and keeps trying and that is like a highlight for little kids cause they may mess up once but like Harry Potter he keeps trying to get rid of his enemy . But some messages are not good ones like in Harry Potter 4 when Harrys enemy kills a student that is a terrible thing so make sure kids about 10 years old know these things are not real then its okay to let them read. When you get down to it and think about it in a positive way its a really good book.
Once I read the first word of this book, I couldn't put it down. This is one of the greatest books I've ever read. J.K Rowling made me feel angry and sad. She is such a great writer I recommend this book to anyone who is old enough to read.
Great book for pre-teens and up. It's hard to put it down.
This is a great book. J K Rowling leaves you with a cliffhanger at the end of each chapter, so it's very hard to put down. There was one instance of an inappropriate word that I wouldn't want any of my children repeating. Otherwise I found it enjoyable to read & look forward to the time that my daughter can share this book with me.
So wonderful you'll be reading ahead long after your child is asleep
This is a truly great book - the best of the series. I am awed by JK Rowling's storytelling; it's complex, compelling, laugh-out-loud funny, but most importantly, a profound commentary on human relationships , particularly those between adults and chldren. I honestly came away from reading this book with a renewed sense of how I want to parent my daughter; to give her my trust, opportunities to be independent, and make mistakes but also to guide, admonish, support, and fight for her. When the most powerful magic and key to Harry's survival is not his smarts, his courage, or even the comradarie and support of his friends and teachers, but rather his mother's love . . . well that's a pretty profound message for both a mom and her daughter. Read this book with your child!
Harry potter and the order of the phoenix (hpootp) is a really fun book for kids 8+. Sirius's death is sad, but im sure the author wouldn't have done it if it wasn't necessary to the plot. Butterbeer is not even really alchoholic. No-one other than elves actually get drunk off it. Great read!
That the Harry Potter series is rated for older than Percy Jackson is ridiculous. Percy Jackson is WAY more violent even than the last books of this series. My daughter and I read them together is first grade and she LOVED them. They fired her imagination and got her very excited. She really looked up to Hermoine and found her to be a great role model for a girl who didn't like to do all of the silly girl stuff but liked to read and learn and play well with boys. I think perhaps my daughter is advanced, but when I hear that some parents have not let their children read the entire series of Harry Potter but let them read Percy Jackson and the Kane Chronicles, I know these parents did not actually personally research the books. I have read them ALL before allowing my daughter to read them. And I have put the brakes on Percy, not Harry.
I had to arm wrestle my kid to get the book away from him (I put him to bed early so I could read it when he slept) and now I look forward to reading it to him out loud. Remarkably, Rowling has not only sustained her characters but she has managed to make them appropriately complex and compelling. The book is a total page turner for adults as well as kids and her world remains a place that any adult who still loves fantasy will enjoy spending 800 pages. My regret is that it ended too soon. I cannot bear waiting another three years for the next one. I enjoy nothing more than these books.
Fun to read and as enjoyable as all the others. The 870 pages had a few slow moments, but the charcter development and action made it a pleasure to read. Harry's getting older and it's impressive how we can track his emotional development.
This amazing story makes you want to never put it down until you're done!
This exciting tale is the best one yet and definitely my favorite book! I loved it sooo much I read it 12 hours straight! I can't wait to read the sixth!