Another reason to question the ConnonSense reviewers
Great book and great reading. Great story that lets kids get absorbed into a fantasy world that is built around them in classic language and artistry that is CS Lewis. The CommonSense reviewer feels that he needs to tell parents that this is "Dated" and "Simple"? PLEASE! Why not warn parents about books that have vivid descriptions of violent acts against children, infanticide, and other inappropriate content for these ages? Many newer, "award winning" books that get raves are "current" and are trash and are no where near appropriate for the ages these reviewers say.
This is a good story that centers around the battle between good and evil. There is mild violence, but it is nothing more than an eight-year-old can handle!
I feel so bad about saying it.....but I didn't like it.....
I feel bad about saying it, because C.S. Lewis seems to have so many fans, but I didn't really like the book. I read it when I was 9 for a class project and was not very impressed. I understood it perfectly and thought the language was excellent, but I guess it was just too imaginative for me. It lacked, in my opinion, a way to make it entirely believable. Sorry all you C.S. Lewis fans! Unfortunately, I just didn't fall under the spell.
My 6-year-old son and I just finished reading this book aloud. He really enjoyed it and is chomping at the bit to start Prince Caspian. For a 6-year-old, some of the language was a little complex and I did check in with him from time to time to make sure he understood what was happening. Also, we had to translate some of the British-isms. But he loved the story and the characters, just as I did when I was a girl.
I was quite disappointed that the movie of this book downplayed the most important aspect: this is a representation of Jesus' death and resurrection! C.S. Lewis wrote many wonderful Christian books that are not preachy, but certainly get the message across. If you read the book with your child and you have EVER been to church, you can't miss the message!
It is HORRIBLE to say that this book has no action, and to say "If you're going to write it again" and "don't use such old fashioned language" is ignorant. C.S. Lewis is one of the most amazing writers that has ever been, and he wrote the book in the early 1900's. This book is a complete masterpeice, and any kid should be encouraged to read it all the way.
i absolutely LOVED it its just such a great book!!! everyone must read it and the rest of the series...my personal favorite is the voyage of the dawn treader, but this one comes into close second!! this book was written a really long time ago and the movie was just made. always, ALWAYS read the book before you watch the movie! the ice crack wasnt in the book as well as some other things it was added into the movie!
I waited until my son was 9 to let him read this book. I am glad but I think it was right on par for his age. The violence is exciting and not too intense for him and has reason and consequence to back it up. We are dealing with non humans, which helps in the discussion. I liked the social aspect as the behavior of Edmund and his siblings provided true feelings, consequences and teaching opportunities and space for forgiveness. The gender roles were traditional yet, aside from Ms Beaver loving to sew and the girls given weapons for protection and emergencies, I personally don't have a problem with the women not being sent into battle...
I thought this was a pretty good book when I read it. It is suspensing and it has a good storyline in which you must think in order to fully understand it. Considering C.S. Lewis writes all his book with inspiration from Lord of the Rings, you will see similarities according to people who have read both (I've only read this one).
Now a lot of people don't know that C.S. Lewis is a Christian author, and this book was written with Christian symbolisms. The fact that the boy (been so long since I read the book I can't remember his name) follows the witch was C.S. Lewis's way of showing someone falling into the traps of Satan. The fact that the lion gets killed and resurrected shows a symbolims referring to Jesus being killed and later resurrected. If you overlook C.S. Lewis's reasoning for everything in the book, you will view it inappropriate and not too good.
Has a verry important message of how you have to learn to forgive others. I loved it! Even though I've read sadder books, when Aslan forgives Edmund I cryed so bad! And I like the fact that it doesn't all end so wonderfully well. The next book (the horse and his boy) is really good and explains a lot!