About our rating system
ON: Content is age-appropriate for kids this age.
PAUSE: Know your child; some content may not be right for some kids.
OFF: Not age-appropriate for kids this age.
Learning ratings
BEST: Really engaging, great learning approach.
GOOD: Pretty engaging, good learning approach.
FAIR: Somewhat engaging, OK learning approach.
NOT FOR LEARNING: Not recommended for learning.

A safe community is important to us.
Please observe our guidelines.

All parent reviews for My Brother Sam Is Dead

Age
12
Adult
August 14, 2009
 
A must read for anyone with even the slightest interest in history
I read the book when I was nine years old, and have read it several times since. Though an American by birth, my mother is British, and I was raised to see both sides of the American Revolution, not the whitewashed version presented by most modern history textbooks and films. My Brother Sam is Dead presents a side of the American Revolution not often seen today. The Meeker Family, though Loyalists, are shown as real people having real concerns. Especially poignant is the tension between the eldest brother Sam Meeker, the rebel, and his father. Throughout the book, Tim Meeker, the protaganist, is exposed to the best and worst of both sides of the war. Any kid with even a slight interest in history should read this book. There are a couple of "naughty words" mostly just the word "hell" and the D-word, but that might concern most parents. Also a concern to parents might be the fact that there is no happy ending.

Flag as inappropriate 
Parent of 11 year old
March 8, 2010
 
not that interesting, and not suitable for elementary children!!!
My 10 year old fifth grader was required to read it. I think the language is appalling, and that the beheading and violence and gore are completely inappropriate for a child this young. We do not use this kind of language in our home, and we do not attend media events where it is used or allow our child to do so. Why then, do we choose "newberry award winning novels" for 10 year olds (their teachers do) that slam them with this stuff? What happened to the classics?

Flag as inappropriate 
Educator
July 31, 2009
 

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
June 11, 2011
 
The writer's skill is worse than the violence or language.
The Language and Violence aren't appalling to me; when I read this back in the eighth grade, we were already using the dreaded "f-bomb". I just think that it's exceedingly poor writing, with terrible lines such as "Ned's head popped off". I mean, really? I can excuse violence and language, especially if it's backed by good writing or an emotionally significant message (see: Looking For Alaska). But I can never excuse a poor author.

Flag as inappropriate 
Parent of 7 and 11 year old
April 13, 2011
 
14+ not younger
Way too violent and graphic for my 11 year old. Execution and other killings described in detail and in first person

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
April 9, 2008
 
I felt that the book was great to read!

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
April 9, 2008
 
I lost three brain cells reading this
This is a simply written book which took my eighth grade advanced English class two months to read. SO BORING!! Ugh. SPOILER WARNING ***The title is a dead give away of the ending. Sam gets shot for a trumped up charge.*** The details are graphic, there is lots of drinking and descrimination, lots of death, and overall, it just gets repititive after about three chapters. Not very challenging, but mildly entertaining. Very depressing though at times.

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
April 9, 2008
 
the book is about a family in redding conn. sam the older brother has just come back from yale

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
April 9, 2008
 
Sad, but important
My Brother Sam Is Dead is an incredably sad, but honest portrait of Revolutionary life. Important for teens to read, because it does not gloss over any of the difficult decisions and moral quandries of wartime.

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
April 9, 2008
 
dumb don't waste ur time!!!!!

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
April 9, 2008
 
Great story line and great lesson!
i only had to read the first half of this book for my American History class, but i got so into this book that i finished the whole thing. it is an amazing book with a great story line and tons of history!

Flag as inappropriate