This is a great book! What are you guys talking about?
"Iffy" for age 13? Off for under that? You've got to be kidding me.
Annoying Overprotective Parent (AOP): Isn't Ponyboy in a gang? I don't want my darling little -insert name here- reading that.
Me: Yes, he's part of a gang, but it even says in the book that it's not an organized gang. The only fighting they do is self defense against the Socs, a group of vicious rich kids who jump Greasers for fun.
AOP: So the Socs are bad, then? That's still setting a bad example!
Me: They're villains; they're supposed to be bad. Isn't the big bad wolf a bad example, too?
AOP: I heard that they smoke and drink a lot in the book.
Me: This was written a long time ago. Everyone smoked. Adults even smoked with little babies in the room.
And for drinking: Ponyboy says he tried some once, but when Darry (his older brother) found out, he got in big trouble.
AOP: What about violence? And death?
Me: Like I said before, violence is mostly self defense. And death? That's life. Get used to it.
AOP: I'll think about it.
So yeah, this is a really great book. If you parents out there prevent your child from reading this, I hope you know it's the worst mistake you'll ever make.
This is a very exciting book and I loved reading it. The book is about two rival gangs the greasers and the Socs, and it is told in the point of veiw of a greaser named Ponyboy. The gangs fight each other and the book is very violent, but it is exspressed in the book by Ponyboy that fighting tears people apart, and that fighting doesnt solve anything but makes things worse.
Although Ponyboy does some things that parents may not approve of, he is a good kid. Just read the book. You'll be glad you did.
I think rating it a 4 out of 5 for violence is ridiculous. The violence is no worse than Twilight. In fact Twilight's more violent. The violence is notable, but it won't scar your kid for life. They'll most likely just keep reading.
Read this book! It's a very good read and has been my favorite for almost a year! I am so glad we read this in 7th grade :D
i read this book when i was 12 for summer reading and i absolutely loved it... i didnt want to leave from the book. i love s.e. hinton she's a great author and i love all her books
I am 13 years old, and I loved this book. We read it at SCHOOL for my english class, and i swear, the only thing i had a problem with was the smoking. The message it gives out is really good and inspirational. I would totally recomend this book to any teenager.
This book is a classic. saying it's iffy for 15 year olds? give me a break. if you think your 15 year old doesn't know about fighting you need a reality check. this book is a classic! Im 13 and it's one of my favorites!
I absolutely love this book! I thought it was amazing, but I don't think kids under 12 should read it. Almost all of the characters enjoy smoking. Also, there are lots of fights, and sometimes people come out injured, or even dead. Otherwise, a great book.
I ABSOLUTELY LOVE THIS BOOK!!!!!! I AM 14 YEARS OLD AND I JUST LOVE IT!!! This book is a very good book.. I love how S.E.Hinton describes things so clearly... I love this book because I feel I can relate to it. I was a little depressed to find out that the only book that I could relate to and was interested in turned into a VERY sad story. I started getting interested after reading the first chapter and I just didnt want to stop reading... but it is a very sad ending. I dont really recomend this book to people who get really emotional about their reading though because I usually never get emotional with pretty much ANYTHING, and this book made me cry... so yeah. But this is an AMAZING book!!!!
I read this book and loved it! I started at 10:00 pm and did not put it down until i finished it at 1:00 am! It might be disturbing to other kids when Johnay killed that guy and the rumble and when *SPOILER* Dally got shot, but I enjoyed it.
<3Nessie<3
I agree with Common Sense Media's rating of iffy for ages 13-15. I recently finished reading this book in LA class. It's a great book, but it's violent and under-age kids almost constantly smoke. All in all, there are some descriptions of violence, upsetting deaths of characters, infrequent mild language, and pervasive smoking.
Even if you dont let your kids read it, its still requird reading in 7th grade.
Its a great book. I read it this week and I really liked it. It should be appropriate for 10 or 11 year olds. There is some fighting and killing but its not super bloody or anything. There is a ton of smoking, though. And some drinking too, but there isnt too much drinking.
This book teaches kids about prejudice and violence as Ponyboy Curtis overcomes so. It could get too violent and language wasn't too bad, but I trust the school in giving the book to its students.
I read this at 12, and I thought it was an extremely easy read. It was short, and hardly used difficult language. The slang can be hard to pick up on, though. I would guess that violence is the real issue here, but it's really not explained in detail. Barely graphic. Although, I was disappointed with this book. I found the plot predictable and the characters unappealing. I had to read it for an english class.
I thought this book was amzing! I personally didn't enjoy it but I think that it is important to tell what really happened in those times and you can't sugarcoat it.
this is an amazing book. i'd say a semi-mature 11 yr old could handle it. i was 10 when i read it and my little brother was 11, and he's not mature or gifted.