I am a director of education and read contemporary juvenile and young adult literature so that I am aware of what many students are reading.
I was SHOCKED by the contents and characters in Sara Shepard's _Pretty Little Liars_. I found the characters to be plucked straight from TV shows that are aimed at adults and the plot developed as a situational comedy/drama.
I do not think that it is an appropriate book for any youth in high school or younger to read. The author has placed her teen age characters in adult situations. In addition, none of the adults in the book is a good parental model. The adults are immature, self absorbed, and emotionally still adolescents.
The teen aged characters lie, drink, do drugs, steal cars, have sexual encounters with teachers, have sexual encounters with older young adults (one character goes after her college-age sister's boyfriend who is in medical school.) and show no remorse or examination of conscience for their actions. If find such behavior in high school sophomores to be high inappropriate for a book aimed at middle- and high-school students.
On page 88 the author refers to one mother as a MILF. I was not familiar with this acronym. When I learned that it means "Mother I'd Like to F*#%", I couldn't believe that an editor and publisher allowed it to appear in a book for youth.
I am not a prude, but I do believe that books for youth should not further sexualize teen girls and young woman, especially through situations that have them lusting after older men (who are happy to return the lust).
It is a sad reflection of our society that editors and publishers believe that this book is appropriate for youth. But, they are as greedy and driven by market success and money as the characters in the book, no matter the true cost to others and the harm done in the long run.
Equally shocking to me are the parents who allow their children to read these books without first reading, reviewing, or at least reading reviews of them. Parents NEED to parent. Just because a book in labeled and marketed as Young Adult does not mean that the book is appropriate for youth.
It is negligent (if not criminal) that this book is able to be published and marketed as a book for Young Adults.
Obviously, you're not going to use the characters in this book as role models. There's a little bit of everything--eating disorders, sexuality, cursing, violence, drinking, and sex, but in all, it's entertaining. I really enjoyed reading this book and didn't find it as shallow as other teenage books. It was a little creepy, with Alison's disappearance and the messages that are popping up everywhere, but it added an edge to the story. The characters are all a little extreme, in my opinion, but that makes the story interesting. I say read it if you're looking to relax but to also get a little something from it. It's a little mature, but I wouldn't say 15 and up. We all know about this stuff anyway.
I loved this book and all of the others in the Pretty Little Liars series I read them all very quickly.
They may have a lot of bad things, but nothing that a 13 year old wouldn't already know about. I enjoy the mysteries and drama and how everything is weaved together in this series.
It was a really good book. I don't understand what everyone is so concerned about. None of the girls in this book have sex. One likes other girls, one is secretly dating her English teacher, one doesn't even have a boyfriend, and ones boyfriend refuses to have sex. And it's a good mystery.
I think that the message this book sends out to readers is that, it is never good to lie. This book is a perfect example of bad things that could happen if you dont follow the rules.
I love these books! Yes there is bad language, sexual aspects and drinking but if your kid is 12, 13 and if your kid is like me, about 10 there is nothing new in this book. Chances are your kids say most of the words in this book when you aren't around and see this type of stuff on tv, in movies, and in other books and magazines they have read or their friends have.
There's absolutely no problem with this book. Any kid aged over 15 understands that just because they read a book where they do bad things, doesn't mean they should do it. Just because a book isn't completely G rated doesn't mean that teenagers can't understand. Because they befriended this Queen-Bee Alison, they were caught up in this. It is BECAUSE they drink, do drugs, smoke, hook up with teachers, etc. that they are in this mess. When I read this, a lot of what goes through my mind is "Huh. Wow. I definitely shouldn't make out with my English teachers then." And her friend having gone missing... well that actually happens in real life. You can't pretend that a 15 year old doesn't understand that it's a dangerous world out there. Giving her kiddy books that make the world look like sunshine and rainbows is only going to make her an idiot.
Perfect for anyone whos not being closed out from the real world!
I love this book. At least your kids are reading something they like instead of watching it on TV. Kids see worse movies on TV this is novels that are amazing they trap you so that you cant put the book down. Each book iv'e finished within two days!
Pretty Little Liars is a well-written guilty pleasure novel that is an enjoyable and entertaining read for 6th grade and up. Kids will enjoy the fun details of the wealthy and privileged. Your children should be smart enough to realize that this is guilty pleasure fiction and should not be taken seriously. A+
This book was an addiction I couldnt settle. Just waiting for the next book tugged at my heartstrings. Although the books were amazingly written and crafted, there were many things that shouldnt be read by children. There is sex, drinking, violence, bad choices, and bad messages. But I just cant pry away from the page turner.
These books do have a bit of inappropriate content, but trust me, it's nothing that your child hasn't been exposed to at school, or television. This series displays how people can make big mistakes, and how it has all come back around and they've had to pay for them. If you think that your child hasn't been exposed to this kind of stuff, then wake up already!! The author Sara Shepard is displaying to young girls across the country how stupid you look in the end, when you lie, cheat, steal, or abuse alcohol or smoking. Contrary to what some parents and educators might think, she is not glamorizing these issues, but showing the reality of them. Many people think like to make themselves think that their child hasn't been exposed to something, or they want to ignore a topic because they feel it is inappropriate. I'm sorry, but here's a wake up call: When You ignore something, it doesn't go away; It only makes it worse.
I understand what people are saying about the violence, etc, but you will find that in most teen books, television, and even the real world. I don't see why teenagers wouldn't be mature enough to understand it. Also, when they speak of bulimia and shoplifting, it is addressed that it is the wrong thing to do. These girls are obviously not role models because they do bad things and recieve consequences. No teenager would read this and think that they want to do these things too. For instance, Spencer plagiarizes her sister's essay and she gets in major trouble. She is humiliated and her parents nearly disown her. This book isn't any worse than the other things out there.