You know what! I am 9 and i loved this book, I just loved it! You know people might say it is " babyish" or " boring" but it really is not at all, it is really entertaining! The only reason i said for ages 8 and up was because it is a chapter book. Mabye littler kids could have their parents read it to them, and a 16 year old just give the book a chance and see the whinnie the pooh is not always " babyish!" Also do not go on saying " Oh, on common sense media i read a rating from a 9 year old and said that she liked whinnie the pooh:0" well give the poor honey loving bear a chance and read the book!