Parent of 6 year old
November 11, 2010
Lots of creative fun
The heroes of these books, George and Harold, are hardly good kids, endlessly pulling pranks and annoying people. But when there is a problem, they do whatever it takes to set things right, whether or not they are at fault. They are very creative, they don't take things personally, and they are quite forgiving and good-hearted.
George and Harold do love potty humor, which I know annoys a lot of parents. My daughter thinks it's hilarious, and who am I to tell her what is funny? We talked about what is appropriate to say around people, and what might make others uncomfortable. And while potty humor isn't my thing, there is enough humor for adults that I don't mind when she reads them to me, which she insists on doing fairly often.
I get the feeling Dav Pilkey genuinely likes and understands children, and the "About the Author" section makes it sound like the books came from his own childhood imagination. With so many moralistic, sanitized children's books for sale, I thought it was a relief to find some that were purely for fun.
I know a lot of parents give these books to reluctant readers, but enthusiastic readers also like them. They also invite kids to make up their own superheroes and villains, and to try drawing and writing stories.
The violence is cartoony, but it is in there, and parents trying to minimize exposure to violent stories might want to give them a miss.
What other families should know:
Flag as inappropriate
A Great Book for Avid and Reluctant Readers Alike
This is a beginner's chapter book, more obviously geared for boys than girls. While the bathroom humor can get out of hand, Pilkey always gives the kids a good laugh.
What I like most about the series, is that in the end of some of the books kids can write in for "fun stuff" from Scholastic if they've "spanked themselves eleven times and been sent to time-out" for reading the "incredibly graphic violence," or "Gotten in Big Trouble for Shouting Ka-Bloooosh."
All in all, it's a cute and very interactive series. It's ideal for a child who has advanced reading skills at an early age, as well as reluctant older readers. There's plenty of good vocabulary words, but the text itself isn't too dense to scare off new readers. Pilkey did an excellent job with this series.
One caveat, however, when the protagonists self-publish their comic books within the book, there are intentional misspellings. Use them as an opportunity to point out phonetic spellings versus actual English usage.
Flag as inappropriate
:an epic novel
The book is really funny.But kids probably think they can buy a ring and go yell at their principal and tell them to go around in their underwear.So here is the story: two friends get tired of their principal being mean, so they buy a 3-D power ring and hypnotize him. And they say for him to be captain underpants.So he goes off and fight crime.Captain underpants hangs a guy on a pole,robots almost KILL the two kids.But this book is harmless.
What other families should know:
Flag as inappropriate
Parent of 8 year old
May 9, 2011
Completely Unbeneficial.
If you want your kid to start making bathroom jokes at the table, buy this book. I really think it's closer to the iffy side than anything else. I had bought a couple of these for my son, but we read them together and I was so grossed out. When did it become acceptable for children to speak this way in society? When I was a child, we never learned to speak in such ways. We were taught it was socially unacceptable and rude, and as our mother always told us, nobody would ever invite us to their dinner table with mouths like that. There are so many better things for children to be reading than these.
Flag as inappropriate
Parent of 5 and 7 year old
March 28, 2010
We laughed out loud together as we read this book.
Flag as inappropriate
Parent of 10 year old
August 16, 2010
my kid age 10 and 3quarters reads it i think its really good for kids with crude humor
Flag as inappropriate
If your kids emulate really easily, don't let them read this.
Honestly, I never had any issues with these books. I never had a negative effect with them and often found myself crying with laughter over how funny these all are. I would say that any kid over 8 should be fine as long as they don't start getting mouthy or anything. It really is pretty dang funny XD
Flag as inappropriate
Parent of 5 and 7 year old
March 14, 2010
A smidge GROSS?
Well, James has always loved these books, but I find them awful. I wish he would move on to a different series already, but at least he can't stop reading!
Flag as inappropriate
Teen, 15 years old
April 9, 2008
Huh? This is supposed to be funny?
I read this "book" when I was in grade 5 and it left me scratching my head. Why would anyone want to read this? Why would parents let their child read this? Why was I reading this? To say the least, I didn't read any of the others in the series. Parents, really, if you can't get your kids to read, let 'em play outside instead. This "book" isn't worth their time and they will definitely learn more running around with their friends than reading this rubbish.
Flag as inappropriate
Teen, 15 years old
April 9, 2008
OK
I used to read it and it was pretty funny. Absolutely no inappropriate stuff in my opinion, just tons bathroom humor.
Flag as inappropriate
Teen, 13 years old
April 9, 2008
Good, but not great
This novel is not the best book in the series.
Flag as inappropriate
Parent of 2 and 6 year old
September 24, 2012
So many better books out there.
Another parent said her son liked these books so I tried one out and I was appalled. The boys in this book have no redeeming qualities that I can make out. They are unkind to other children and adults alike. To call them "pranksters" is to laugh off a total lack of kindness, respect or empathy. Shouldn't kids be taught to consider the feelings of others? The ability to use funny potty language does not compensate for lacking a conscience.
Flag as inappropriate
SILLY, FUNNY, AND VERY CREATIVE!!!
This is a hilarious book! It has goofy illustrations, humorous characters, bad puns, a silly plot, and even a section of "flip-the-page" animation! I used to read this to my dad before he went to bed; he even found this book funny! Some parents may not like the poddy jokes, but come on! It's made to make you laugh! I LOVE THIS BOOK!!!
Flag as inappropriate