The Wish List

 Review

Common Sense Media says

Wicked is the key word here, in all its senses.
greenON: Content is age-appropriate for kids this age.
yellowPAUSE: Know your child; some content
may not be right for some kids.
redOFF: Not age-appropriate for kids this age.
not for kidsNOT FOR KIDS: Not appropriate for kids any age.

Find out more

Quality
 
Sometimes media can be age appropriate but a real waste of time. Our star rating assesses the media's overall quality.

Find out more

Parents say

Kids say

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that Colfer offers a view of the afterlife that may conflict with some religious beliefs; you might want to have a chat with your child about this topic.

  • Meg lies, trespasses, breaks in, steals, and pursues revenge. Black humor.
  • Belch shoots Meg, his dog attacks Lowrie, Meg's stepfather slaps her around, Meg and Belch fight, Meg punches her stepfather. The two main characters die in a fiery explosion.
  • Not applicable.

What's the story?

Meg Finn's short life has been a mess. Her mother is dead, her stepfather abusive, and she has fallen in with the wrong people and turned petty delinquent. But when a burglary goes wrong she and Belch, the brutal moron who talked her into it, are killed. Belch, merged with his pet pit bull, goes straight to Hell, but Meg, whose good and bad deeds are perfectly balanced, is sent back to atone and tip the balance by helping the old man, Lowrie McCall, whom they tried to rob.

Lowrie is a dying old curmudgeon who has a list of things he wants to do before he dies, and it's Meg's job to help him succeed. But Beelzebub, on orders from the Devil, sends Belch, armed with a nasty computer chip in what's left of his brain, to make sure she fails. But even without his interference her trip may not get her through "the Pearlies:" almost everything Lowrie wants to do is illegal, and Meg still wants revenge on her stepfather.


Is it any good?

 

Eoin Colfer knows how to grab his readers: The first 10 pages contain a robbery, a pit bull attack, a shooting, and the death of the two main characters in a fiery explosion. And he knows how to hold them, with a combination of action, B-movie cliche, black humor, and gritty, muscular prose that hints at more violence than it actually reveals. It's no wonder he's the darling of the video-game generation. Reluctant readers and avid ones all enjoy his books, and with good reason.

Wicked is the key word here, in all its senses. It describes Colfer's humor, his no-kid-gloves approach to his readers, and, quite literally, the plot. He manages here a view of the afterlife that is cynically funny without being out-and-out blasphemous (and least to this reviewer) and makes a weird kind of sense to boot. While this book lacks anyone quite as funny as Foaly in the Artemis Fowl books, it makes up for it with a bit more heart -- nothing soppy, of course, this is a Eoin Colfer book after all, but just the hint of a warm glow in the testy developing relationship between a crusty old never-was and a hardened little never-will-be. Colfer may talk tough and mean to thrill his audience, but it's just possible he has a heart of mush.


Explore, discuss, enjoy

Families can talk about the author's view of the afterlife. What are his beliefs? Do they differ from your own beliefs?


This review of The Wish List was written by
Teen, 13 years old
April 9, 2008
 
I love it
I first read it when I was eleven or twelve, and it's a very good book that keeps you entertained. I think it has a lot of food for thought, and it teaches you a little bit, although you don't know it. It's got humour, drama, and of course, suspense. A very good novel from a very good author - I would definitely recommend it for anyone who asks. ~Hermit

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 15 years old
April 9, 2008
 
I loved this book! Everyone should have a chance to read it!
I loved this book- it was funny, sad, exciting... just an all-around great book. My friend chose it for a book club- and WOW does she have good taste! I read it in 2 days- it wasn't too hard, and keeps you interested from the first page to the last. I'd definitely read "The Wish List"- it's one hell of a book! (if you excuse the pun!) :)

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 13 years old
April 9, 2008
 

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 14 years old
February 15, 2011
 
I simply love the book, the only thing is that for youngster it may be confussing because of the way they humoresly describe heaven and hell.

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
April 9, 2008
 
good book
soo.. hi.. a good read...

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 14 years old
July 20, 2010
 
THE BEST BOOK EVER
I love this book. i read it when i waz like 11 and it still would have the same suspense and adventure for me as it did when i first read it. its the best book ever. i recommend it for anyone.
What other families should know:

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 14 years old
November 23, 2010
 
Really good books for children are rather rare to one who deosn’t have a penchant and desire to laboriously scour the shelves of a local Waterstones retailer for hours; a search that too often ends in an underwhelming ‘Twilight’ rip-off that is the exact same as the aforementioned teenage novel, absolute drivel. Nevertheless, stumbling upon ‘The Wish List’ was a pleasant surprise- I rarely pick up a teenage fiction book (Despite actually being a teenager) normally because the storyline and characters are poorly written, and the ethics and morals put forward are so seemingly fed out of a tin of ‘Moral and Ethics for Teens’ it’s unbelievable. The first page of Eoin Colfer’s ‘The Wish List’ sets the tone for the rest of the story- suspense and character is conveyed and then something dramatic happens; generally relating to the character’s personalities that so effectively persuade the story to adhere to their eccentric disposition, something irritatingly overlooked in many works of fiction. The characters are believable and likeable; and the story is written to not only reinforce this; but aid it. The story itself tells the rather idiosyncratic and aberrant tale of Meg and Belch. The two characters begin the story by attempting (unsuccessfully) to burgle an old man: Lowrie McCall (ironically and intelligently portrayed as a stereotypical OAP) this murder ends in the untimely death of both- but this death, rather than being the end is a beginning for both characters. Belch is sent to hell, for being a generally evil person, but Meg is given a second chance- a return to Earth to right her wrongs by supporting the elderly McCall in performing his wish list. This sets the scene for a beautifully written, zany novel which offers a valuable lesson for life (for those of any age) while packing in a story that is full of suspense and excitement. The perspicacity of the old man and the reluctant-to-bond young Meg form exactly that; a bond between to generations so rarely understood. Colfer manages all of this without making anything sound too cheesy or puerile; while spinning what is essentially the perfect tale. A great example of this is the love story between Cicely (a TV star in the style of Alan Titcshmarsh) and Lowrie, when Lowrie asks her if she remembers ‘that night,,,, after the cinema when I didn’t kss you, do you ever wonder’ to which Cicely quite delicately replies ‘Every Day and night Lowrie McCall, every day and night’ suggesting the regrets of a pensioner that (with only half a year to live) can never be rewritten. A masterpiece for this generation; a book that should be read regardless of age. Pure literary delight.
What other families should know:

Flag as inappropriate 
Kid, 12 years old
July 4, 2010
 
erfect for a large variety of readers
i think it is good
What other families should know:

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 13 years old
May 16, 2010
 
for teens who love adventure
it is a good book and full of adventure and suspense
What other families should know:

Flag as inappropriate 
Kid, 11 years old
September 12, 2012
 
The Wish List
I think it is a great book with an amazing battle of good vs. evil but might be a conflict with people with different religious beliefs. There are some parts with some violence. The violent parts are when Belch (Meg's boss in crime) attempts to scare Meg (the main character) by shooting the gas cans but ends up killing them both. Another violent part is the two times Franco (Meg's stepfather) hit her. over all is a good book. I would recommend it to kid's that are at least 11.
What other families should know:

Flag as inappropriate 

This review of The Wish List was written by
Author:Eoin Colfer
Book type:Fiction
Genre:Fantasy
Publisher:Hyperion Books for Children
Publication date:November 17, 2003
Number of pages:252
Publisher's recommended age(s):10 - 14

This review of The Wish List was written by
 

Review It

Share your review with others

Hang on! You need to be a member to post your review.
A safe community is important to us. Please observe our guidelines.

Learning Products Quick Finder

Great alternatives handpicked by our editors