About our rating system
ON: Content is age-appropriate for kids this age.
PAUSE: Know your child; some content may not be right for some kids.
OFF: Not age-appropriate for kids this age.
Learning ratings
BEST: Really engaging, great learning approach.
GOOD: Pretty engaging, good learning approach.
FAIR: Somewhat engaging, OK learning approach.
NOT FOR LEARNING: Not recommended for learning.

A safe community is important to us.
Please observe our guidelines.

All teen and kid reviews for Twilight: The Twilight Saga, Book 1

Age
11
Teen, 14 years old
May 9, 2010
 
Horrible Characters, Horrible Messages, Horribly Boring
This book was horrible. All of the Twilight books were horrible. I just can't get over the fact that they're 17! And excuse my reference to other books in the series (as well as some possible spoilers coming up) but they get married at 18, at 19 (or still 18?) they have a baby... I mean, the author is basically sending the message that "If you believe you're in love when you're only 17, go for it! Get married in a year, have a baby the next. You know your love is true and because you've been together for almost a year, you two are perfect for one another. You'll never get a divorce." Okay, my friend (a seventh grader) was with a boy for a year. Does that mean they were planning to get married? No. But teens might start thinking about that earlier and earlier if we send out messages like this. The book was awfully boring, dragged on and it was just horrible. Vampires aren't meant to sparkle and make out with humans. Now, Bella isn't even a character. Well, she has no emotions anyway. She's somewhat dumb and naive, too. What a great role model. Honestly, this entire series is horrible.

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 15 years old
May 7, 2010
 
All right. First of all, I hated this book pretty bad. I mean, it had an okay plot and all, and when I read it the first time I said to myself, "Well, all right. This is an okay book." Until I read it a second time. I'm a book freak, and the first time I read a book that actually interests me (I'm an extreme book critic as well) I sort of gloss over the flaws in it. Until I read it a second time. I read Twilight once more, sort of half-skimming through the pages, and then notice one thing that really bugs me, since I'm a half author, half editor (Well, very nearly, and no, I do not vomit out some vampire crap): Spelling, punctuation, and, most of all, grammer mistakes. It's one of my biggest pet-peeves besides socks and pillows, as well as the texture of my walls (I know; I'm a strange one). The second thing I just happened to notice was that Bella, the main character, is a really big whiner. Now, whiners also annoy me, and I started to think, "Now why the heck did I read this book in the first place?" Bella also depends too much on Edward, who sort of gives off some creepy stalker vibes and an impression of a serial killer (Seriously, I had nightmares of him stalking me. Just a tad strange). And then I read, once more, the part of how he sparkles. Really, now, we know Edward is hot (In the book), but you're seriously overdoing it now. I'm thinking, "Really? Does he really need to SPARKLE?" Then I noticed the dad, Charlie. He's the worst dad ever, or haven't you noticed that? I thought I noticed you noticing. Seriously, though; all he does is sit around and watch TV, talks to Bella about once a week, goes fishing every day and leaves the kid unsupervised, and doesn't seem to really give a crap about the poor girl. No wonder she's such a whiner and willing to have any man, right? I also noticed that Meyer adds tons of weird and unrelated details to the book, the h--- word is used every once in a while, and, the biggest problem of all I read in Newmoon, Bella gets a little on the suicidal side. Seriously, she got my friend thinking that jumping off a cliff is really cool and fun and that she should try it as well. Meyers has also gotten two of my friends thinking that they're vampires, and she got my friend on drugs lined with BLOOD. Seriously. I'm getting a bit worried about our society and the Twilight series. My other friend is a literal addict of it, and it's creeping me out about how loyal she is to the books/movies. And yet another thing: Bella has no personality. She's all whiney and dependant, yes, but pretty much nothing else. Even in the movies (Really bad acting, by the way), the person who plays her has like, this blank stare the entire time. Even when the one guy kisses her at lunch, she's giving the girl next to her a look that says, "What? Did I pee myself again?" It just...bothers me. It's unnatural. And little ten-year-old girls, believe what you will. But really, you shouldn't be reading this stuff. Why not read Catherine Called Birdy? Best and most funny book of all time about this stubborn, personality-packed girl who's being forced to get married--to the ugliest, most disgusting man ever. But will she have to marry him? Not if Birdy can help it, with a little luck with accidentally catching the privy (bathroom house) on fire and running away multiple times (She always comes back to her friends, of course). Now THAT is a good book!

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 17 years old
October 18, 2009
 
Edward Hottsickle!
It's Twilight, is there anything else to add? I got this book because of how popular it was. I'm pretty mainstream when it comes to books. But this was the worst book ever! Okay, my thoughts on this book... For a romance, it's completely dumb and I wouldn't never recommend it. Here are my reasons. It is extremely anti climactic. Vampires sparkle in this book, what a pathetic thing for a vampire to do! I expected him to rise up in the air with fire spurting out of his mouth, his eyes burning out of their sockets and his skin become chard and black...but no...he sparkles. The author is a quack, she thinks of the weirdest things. The end of the book was descent enough, but mediocre to say the least. The characters are weak and Bella is a completely obsessive person who makes wrong decisions for her boyfriend stalker, Edward. This book encourages kids to not take drugs (in this case cough syrup)...unless there's a hot boy in the equation. It's also okay to be stalked, I mean, who doesn't find it hott to be stalked!? And having a creepy boy watching girls sleep, no that's not a pervert at all! Edward Cullen, the boyfriend stalker, also is very sexist. He wants to protect Bella with the simplest things--which is not what life is about. She worships him as if he were a god, but this is stupid. She’s not independent, and I feel that if girls read this book, they will not think of the flaws, but only how Edward Cullen is hott! I haven't bothered to read the second book because it was boring and had negative messages—but I heard Bella jumps off a cliff after Edward dumps her. I also feel the author was a very religious person, involving old customs into this book. What I'm trying to say is that, I don't not like it for the plot--I hate it for its message and the way the plot was pieced together. It also made me want to puke with how romantic it was. It could have been more interesting, but it failed miserably. The movie was surprisingly better.

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 16 years old
January 30, 2011
 
Lust? Excitement? Yes. Love, feminism? Never.
Parents, as an AVID teen reader, I do NOT recommend these books for your young girls. This book is about lust, male dominance, and has no literature upholding whatsoever. First, Bella Swan is a Noncharacter. She doesn't develop, she constantly complains, and is completely dependent on "Edward" The series, sure, is engrossing, but it is based on lust and want, not love. Read the series, first, at least.

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 15 years old
June 5, 2010
 
Awful messages. Awful book.
As all the hype about this started up around me, I decided to buy all four (what a mistake) books and read them. As I finished Twilight I wondered why on Earth was there so much w=hype about it? I simply couldn't identify with Bella, as all she seemed to do was whine and complain and by the end (or maybe even the middle) I was sick sick sick of reading about Edward's "marble dazzling chest" and "smoldering topaz eyes". It seems like Mrs. Meyer simply did not know when to stop, because some books just shouldn't have been written- The Twilight Saga is a perfect example.

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 16 years old
April 18, 2010
 
Sucky.
Sucky. Just plain ol' sucky. Sparkling vampires? What is this...? And what's with Bella's personalityless...ness? The whole movie just failed. It has a negative influence on most the population and many twifans obsess with it to the point of violence and unhealthiness. 1.5/5

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 15 years old
April 19, 2010
 
Bad, bad book
This book is awful. This series is awful. I don't think anyone should waste their time reading this, it is not well written. Meyer gives unimportant details and Bella Swan way to boy-obsessed for her own good. Her boyfriend leaves her, and she becomes a zombie, only to become happy again from yet ANOTHER boy. She hears voices. She is whiny, and to all children reading it: DO NOT LET A GUY SLEEP IN YOUR BED IF THEY COULD BE POTENTIALLY VIOLENT OR MURDEROUS. Especially not if your parents don't approve of him. Edward is creepy, stalkerish, and Bella's goal in her life was to become a vampire. She didn't care for school, or even her own health! Also, the characters were clearly not well developed. They all had the same voice, with the exception of Emmett and Alice. The setting became confusing.

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 18 years old
May 8, 2010
 
Literally the Most Boring Book I Have Ever Read
This book is incredibly boring. The characters are very one-dimensional, with no real depth, especially Bella. The plot lacks good development. The biggest problem I have with the book is the fact that stephanie meyer obviously did no research on the mythical creatures. Not only do the vampires not get weakened by sunlight, the SPARKLE. They do all sorts of things real vampires would never do. I hate this book.

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 16 years old
January 21, 2011
 
This book is a disgusting, and if I ever have children, I won't let them lay a finger on this scrap of garbage. Before I actually begin my review, I have a few things to point out about myself. 1. I am an obsessive horror fan 2. I have huge respect for any author that manages to keep me awake through the first fifty pages. and 3. I've never been a romance fan, though I do like a slight sprinkling of it through a series. Okay, I was first introduced to Twilight when I was given a ton of pop magazines (don't give me that look, I got them from my cousin because she thought I was out-of-touch with society). I was curios and put an order down at my library and waited anxiously for the books arrival, since, as my mother is constantly telling me not to do, I had judged the book by its pretty cover. A week later I sat down with it, hoping all the hype wasn't just...well...hype. I was finished within twenty-four hours and thought to myself, okay, good book, a bit on the obsessive side, but still, good. I even went so far as to buy the entire series to add to my collection. As I usually do, I picked up the book for a second, more thorough read. I found that I didn't exactly connect with Mrs. Meyer's writing style, and her constant descriptions rather annoying, then maddening. I have read many books by respected authors, and they didn't feel the need to constantly describe how particularly 'dazzling' a certain characters eyes were. All in all, I found it ridiculous and was disgusted in myself for ever considering that it could even measure up to other literature I have read. This book is all hysteria by fangirls who have never read anything else but Twilight, and think they know what they mean when they say Twilight is the best book ever, when, in fact, its just a small bit of garbage made famous by lonely house wives. .... No offense or anything. I wish I could give this book a big, fat zero, but I have to give at least one star for trying.

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 15 years old
February 28, 2011
 
Not good reading for anyone
The book is overrated. The whole point is exploring how Bella basically wants to lose her virginity to...uh, a vampire. Not only that, but she wants to become a vampire. Not exactly bedtime reading material for kids.

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 15 years old
September 12, 2010
 
Vampires don't sparkle, girls.
Flat characters, idealistic romance (obsession), and really lame storyline. Bella is designed to be liked by completely average girls that like to fantasize about fairytale princes and the world revolving around them. Also, the depiction of the vampires and other creatures are downright ridiculous. Overall it's not as horrile as everyone says but it's not like it's good either. Just... not worth it.

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 18 years old
January 2, 2010
 
Feminist Backlash?
Twilight is an essentially negative force on teenage girls today. Edward, the dream-vampire, is overly Byronic in temperament and psychopathic. He stalks Bella, and watches her while she sleeps. He has the gall to ask Bella's father for his permission way after having spent the night in Bella's room. Bella is a classic case of why Showing is better than Telling. We are repeatedly told that Bella is academically briliant, yet she acts like an idiot. She is vapid, colourless, and moronic. The support characters are empty vessels. The whole series seems like propaganda for Ms. Meyer's religion. These books have a bad message: that it's okay for women to be enslaved and treated like possessions. Not that Bella is in any way sympathetic... In the end: Just plain boring.

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 15 years old
June 28, 2010
 
Worst book of all time. Go read Harry Potter instead.
Title says it all. Harry Potter for the win.

Flag as inappropriate 
Kid, 13 years old
November 22, 2011
 
Here's my Twilight rant. Read if you dare.
I cannot fully express my utter hatred for this book, but I will try. This series has been popular since I was in the fourth grade, and I remember everyone swooning over it. I never understood and still don't. I read the first book in fifth grade and was absolutely disgusted. Okay, for one thing, WHY ON EARTH ARE NINE YEAR OLDS READING THIS TRASH?! No wonder our world is so messed up today! No wonder girls think the world is coming to an end if they don't have a boyfriend!! I swear!!! Ugh. Okay, for one thing, Edward is a HORRIBLE boyfriend. He KNOWS he's a danger to her, but he never leaves her alone?! And he stalks her and watches her sleep?! What the heck?! What about him is so great besides his "attractiveness" (y'know, I didn't find him the least bit cute in the movies, so I don't see what the big deal is)? Yeah, he's nice and all, but a horrible influence. And don't even get me started on Bella. Oh, such a deprived child! (GAG!) SHE WON'T SHUT UP! She's constantly whining and complaining, and if not, it's because she's too busy telling us how wonderful Edward is! Oh my gosh, I'm getting annoyed just writing this. Girls, give it up - vampires don't sparkle. -__-" Parents: Be responsible, please! Pay attention to what you choose to let your children read. I'm only 12, not even a TEEN yet, and I would NEVER let my kids get within 5 feet of this garbage. Kids, go watch/read The Sound of Music or Anne of Green Gables. That's where you'll find some good role models and life lessons!!!

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 15 years old
January 15, 2011
 
Could a thesaurus be useful, Ms. Meyer?
One word to sum up Meyer's writing: repetitive. To the point where my OCD self wants to take a red pen and change the wording! Honestly, there's no shame in using a thesaurus! But I'm afraid that even that may no help the blackhole of mindless "Oh Edward is soooo dreamy" that is found every time Edward is mentioned! Yes, we get it, he's attractive, now can we get on with it please? When I heard that this book was about vampires, I pictured ruthless bloodsucking creatures of the night... and I was wrong. Reading this book really became a chore, but since I *never* leave a book unfinished, I trudged on. I'd never burn a book, but Twilight certainly had me tempted. Bella's "damsel in distress" image really had me annoyed, and she's such a WHINER! I thought (or hoped) that there would be some character growth by the end of the book, but apparently not! Of course, when Bella went to her new school everyone thought she was perfect, and adored the little self pitying excuse for a human being. Everyone except the emo, and brooding Cullens, who are too busy being beautiful, perfect, and sparkly. No, I'm not kidding (I wish I was). When she meets Edward, it was love at first sight, which was not sweet but positively irritating! For the next 50 or so pages, Bella constantly asks debates with herself whether she likes Edward or not, and whining about how much he hates her, while being a total snob to the other boys who show their affection in sweet ways (and by sweet, I mean NOT breaking into her house and watching her sleep. While she's sleeping. In the middle of the night. IN HER HOUSE). A plot (and I use the term "plot" very loosely) makes itself known when evil vampire James comes in, and he wants to eat Bella. James is the only character I like. Bella is NOT someone you want your teen daughter modeling herself after. Bella is a shallow, whining, self pitying toerag (shall I go on?) who does NOTHING with her life except for fawning over her perfect vampire boyfriend (and I do mean NOTHING except that) To be nice, Bella and Edward's relationship is extremely unhealthy. And that's me being nice. Just don't bother with this book.

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 16 years old
February 27, 2011
 
Horrible book
This book is just plain bad. The first half of it is of ummm who is the main girl again? I'll just call her 'Smith'. The first half is about Smith freaking out about Eddy and even liking it when he watches he sleep. That's creepy, and Eddy is 100 years older than Smith. Once again: Creepy. Most the book is 'Eddy's sooooooo hawt omg! <3' and there is no real plot. The characters are not memorable, and then there's Smith. She is a horrible role model for kids. All she does is whine, complain, and disrespect her father for a guy she's known for a month. Then she goes suicidal just because Eddy leaves her. No one should read this unless your 16+, understand Eddy isn't real and doesn't love you, and need a good laugh.

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 15 years old
October 29, 2010
 
ANOTHER long rant/opinion about this (spoilers) sorry its so long
It's good, and at the time I was very sucked into it (haha, sucked-get it!? ...That was by accedent) But as time went on, I began to hate it (called 'growing up') anyway, I did like it, it was excitting, I love things with vampires and werewolves... But, now that I look back on it.,, Edward, I mean, he can be romantic, but lets face it, he's a stalking killing machine. Well not a 'killing' machine persay, but you know what I mean. I mean, think about this Bella, he sat there and watched you sleep, and you saw it as sweet! I don't care how attractive he is (the actor is not-no offence) I would much rather not have a VAMPIRE that can kill me watching me sleep. That's a total invasion of privacy. And she says she's 'not afraid' but really, he can kill her at anytime, and she can't do a thing about it. She's totally dependent on Edward, and he's actually very.. agressive and pushy at times. I'm beginning to think that she only truely likes him just because he's exciting. He's not very good at keeping a secret because he decided to tell her about it. And then he goes on-and-on that he's too dangerous, she doesn't care, they kiss, then they do that again. I think the characters were well thought of, I like all of Edwards adopted siblings, and his adoptive parents, its just him I seem to have issues with. At least his family knows how to have fun, playing baseball and stuff. It's a well thought out story, and I understand as a future writer its a lot of pressure at times. Moving on, so there's this conflict where the vampires are trying to kill Bella (YES! -just kidding..kind of) and chase after her (although I don't understand why they can't find a better smelling human being) and the family protects her and takes her someplace else. I like the conflict, it excited me a little there. I also like how Edward protected Bella from (most likely) being raped. Anyway, she sacrifices herself to save her Father (I think thats what happened) and she faced it. That is when I respected Bella, but she began to get worse as the saga went on. So Edward comes in and saves her, and so does his family, which is nice, except for when they rip off his arms and whatnot. I mean this wasn't a bad book, I enjoyed it, but still looking back on it.. if she was more with her family and not obsessing over Edward I would have liked it more. Love shouldn't be about obsession. I hate it that he compared Bella to brandy or heroine, that's the stuff that makes you sick.. does Bella make you sick? And really, he was mostly attracted to her because she smelled good and he couldn't read her mind. But he did like her for being differen't, thats good. But really her only charictoristic is that she's clumbsy and albino, and for some reason the whole town praises her. What's so impressive? So her dad's the police chief, usually when your new your outcasted, or people are curious, but not like "Hey Bella, your so cool! Come sit with us!" and all these dudes try to ask her out. (Actually at my school if your attractive you get a boyfriend in like.. 2 days) I just don't get the attraction people have over it now, I mean 'Team Edward' 'Team Jacob' action figures, people are obsessed with it. And I was like 12 when I loved this series, so it appears to attract littler kids that are nieve and find it romantic. Little kids shouldn't be thinking about romance.. play with dolls, build a snow fort, don't read 12 inch books about sexy romance! And, its creative of thought, but vampires don't sparkle girls.. they would usually burn in the sun. Vampires have fangs, or else how would they get the blood out? How can they poke holes to get the blood? Oh, yeah, I forgot, fangs are frowned apon and 'unattractive' after all, we have to make this vampire guy hot, right? I mean you can't love someone unless they're hot! (That's the impression I'm starting to get-its not what you should believe in of course) half of the time Bella's talking about how attractive Edward is, and he's always saying how good she smells. .... just see for yourself this message is getting too long.

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 18 years old
June 9, 2010
 
How disappointing...
The only reason this book is so darn popular is because of an impossibly dreamy boy. The actual writing wasn't that great and it completely failed to pull me in. I found myself getting bored quickly and had to force myself to get through the book, thinking the ending would be better than the beginning. It was all very predictable and is overall ridiculously overrated.

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 16 years old
October 1, 2009
 
Book is written by and anti-feminist monkey(sorry to all the monkeys)
This book is written terribly and could have been written by an overly romantic monkey. The main character is an extremely weak women and the dad is the stereotypical idiot father. New moon is even worse when bella starts participating in suicidal activities just so she will get slightly crazier and here edwards voice. My inner feminist is crying right now and it makes me mad that so many people think this is a great romance with good role models. A much better choice is Buffy or for a book Blood and Chocolate or Tantalize

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 15 years old
January 28, 2011
 
Just terrible.

Flag as inappropriate