I personally read the novel. I am 17 and have read this book for a class. The review points out the negatives about the book but not the positive of the book. I do not think that parents should worry about what their children are reading at 15,16,17 or 18. Our lives are way more detailed than what our parents lives were. Which makes my classmates angry when we read these reviews and they are all negative. Focus on positive things in life and pick your battles. This isn`t on of them to fight.The morals of the book are what to look at, not the "several kissing scenes", which have NOTHING to do with the book! IF parents are going to be like this, then they need to be glad that their child is reading. Most kids today do not read.
This book is beyond well-written. It engenders your mind into vividly imagining everything described in this novel. You really begin to feel for the characters and develop an understanding towards their fear for being 'unwound'. Outstanding.
I (grandma) LOVED the book as did my 15 year old grandson and his old mother. It is extremely well written with absolutely delicious descriptions, great building of characters, fascinating concept and full of "discussable" moral dilemmas. Grandson and I "read" this via audio book while on the road and couldn't wait to get back in the car to read some more! We were so disappointed the book ended because we wanted MORE of these characters! I recommend this to anybody 13 and up...parents should read it as well as it has many great opportunities for starting parent-child conversations, discussions of values and thought-provoking possibilities! My grandson, a voracious reader puts this book at the top of his favorites list as do I!
My 11-year-old son heard about this book from his advanced Language Arts teacher (!!!) and brought it home. I often like to read the same book he is reading, so we can have fun talking about it.
I was shocked beyond belief upon reading just the first few paragraphs of this book. I eventually took it away from him and said it was not appropriate for him (made him mad at me, but oh well...).
I cannot see that this sick book about the government-sanctioned murder and dismemberment of children would be appropriate for ANY age child. And I am an avid science fiction fan!!!
BEWARE!!!! STAY AWAY!!!
I love it it's a book with Scary Yet Mysterious: Is Connor Going to make it is he going to be able to run away from Unwind with his friends Lev and Rosa ?........Well read the book and You'll find out
This book is a very interesting mix of levels of complexity, which raises the question of whether it is appropriate for kids. The three main characters are a boy named Connor is a delinquent who has anger management, a Girl named Risa who is a state ward, and Lev who is a wealthy boy heavily invested in religion. But despite their very different backgrounds, they all have one thing in common; they're being sent off to be unwound. Unwinding was the solution that concluded the heartland war between the armies of life and choice. The theory of it was that it could remove people who were considered societal problems without killing them, and it would even provide for those who would remain. The practice itself is a horrifying prospect; as it involves the amputation of every body part during a painless operation until each unwind is nothing but the pieces that once made up his whole. But despite the horrifying nature of this practice, Neal Shusterman is quite obvious about this fact, and the children facing the unrelenting fate sugarcoat nothing. As I read through the story, I saw unique leadership unfold as Connor was proclaimed to be a hero. He became one despite his violent tendencies, simply because he has a kind heart and received a random chance at survival as we know it, and unlike others he took it and didn't look back. I felt the unique experience wash over me as I walked in Connor's shoes, knowing his fear of being unwound, and feeling his hesitant wonderment at what might come after. I wondered at length what made a human who he was at the end of this story, and my answer was similar to the words of one of the unwinds "I think I'll still be alive, as long as I can keep my soul". Although the implications of violence and the well translated fear of the characters may be of impact on a child, those with maturity will have an interesting exploration into Unique leaders, Strange alliances, and children near their own age fighting valiantly despite having the world against them, to prove that existence is a right and not a privilege.
I allowed my teenager (13 at the time) to read it after I had. Sorry the other mother had an issue with it---not so in my house. We talked about many of the ideas presented and how some people may find it a reasonable answer to many problems. Gave it to my classroom and all of the students talked to their parents about the book, discussed it openly in class, and urged other students to read it. Seems like what a good book should be.........
A review from my fifteen year old daughter:
I'm a fifteen year old girl who loves to read, especially science fiction, and this is the most disturbing young adult novel I've ever read. The 'bad guys' are doctors, parents, and the church. This idea causes kids to doubt their security. It takes away all the people kids can trust in when they are afraid, so that they are only trusting in one another. I know that it's fiction, but sometimes it's difficult for a kid to separate fact from fantasy, especially when they don't know all the facts. I had nightmares for a week because I had it in my mind that what happened in this book could actually be possible.
I believe that the book has excellent messages, but not any that kids need to know. I would classify this as an adult book. Neal Shusterman is trying to make a point by taking things to the extreme. I understand that. But does the point have to be made to kids?
Good for all ages. Kids who can understand the message. 13+
Being a senior in High School this book has touched my heart. I really enjoyed the book's thematic and plot makeup. The author makes every character important in it's own way. It does require a medium-High level of understanding of the problems in the "utopic" society presented. It includes very light love scenes (no mature situations). This book will capture the heart of anyone who is a rebel at heart.
This book really made me think about the value of human life. I am a 30 yr old stay a home mom of 2 small kids. I looked at my children and wondered how anyone could Unwind them. But it also makes you think about the way society makes thing ok or not ok. Again it was a thinker of a book
Although disturbing, this book is a compelling read. The author never judges or takes sides in this story of a future gone wrong. It forces the reader to think about the value of life.
This book was awesome!!! This book has many good messages because it makes you think of where would we be if this actually happened would it really be this easily to sign you kids off to die? But this book also makes you think of how precious a human life is and it also makes you think about the wonders of the human soul. I would read this book again.... in a heart beat!!!!
Awesome book. Loved it . Very thought provoking. Some educational facts. Conveys a positive message.
Depicts loyalty with facts.
Do your parents love you or do they want to get rid of you?
abook that makes you think about the hard questions in real life
All I can say is if I lived in this time, I wouldn't know whether to be pro life because of unwinding, or pro choice because of storking. But I do like the way the author put it - if there were more organ donors then there would never be unwinding. I'm all for organ donations!
I loved this book. There were many times that I thought it might cross the line to be inappropriate for my students (aged 10 to 14), but although I think the author managed to graze the edge of inappropriate without doing it. I recommend the book for kids who are 12+. The ideas are really deep and possibly disturbing at times, so be prepared to discuss it, especially if you have a sensitive child.