Wintergirls (by Laurie Halse Anderson)

common sense media says

Disturbing, lauded eating disorder read; discuss with teens.


parents & educators say
  • 75% say there are positive messages
  • 50% say violence is an issue

What parents need to know

Parents need to know this is a very, very intense book about the mental and physical pain endured by teens with eating disorders. The two main characters, the "wintergirls" of the title, both have emotional problems that lead to and exacerbate their disorders. The book starts with Cassie dying from repetitive vomiting. The very graphic detail about their physical deterioration as the girls starve themselves is painful to read. Parents may find this award-winning book educational -- not only about the pressures today's teens feel, but also about the way these girls maintain their lies and how others enable them to do so. 

Educational value: This book can help readers and parents delve into a slew of difficult topics, mostly having to do with body image and eating disorders. Check out our "Families Can Talk About" section for some ideas.
Positive messages: This is a powerful story about the pain and brutality of eating disorders, the mental anguish suffered by those suffering from anorexia or bulimia, and the pain their loved ones feel watching them. This is difficult but important material for teens and parents to discuss -- and ultimately, there is hope.
Positive role models: Like any addiction, Lia's eating disorder drives her to behave badly in order to get away with the lying required, and the narcissism. But she is someone that readers will relate to -- and root for.
Violence: This book offers a very, very intense look at the mental and physical pain endured by two teen girls with eating disorders, one of whom dies by repetitive vomiting. There's very graphic detail about their physical deterioration as they starve themselves. Lia also begins cutting herself when she is 12. There is a subtle hint early on that Cassie had been sexually assaulted when she was very young.
Sex: Some boys are vulgar when Cassie develops breasts in fifth grade and refer to "jugs" and "hooters." Eli asks Lia if she wants a kiss, who jokes that she wants to have babies with him.
Language: "Hell," "s--t," and "bitch."
Consumerism: Not applicable.
Drinking, drugs, & smoking: Eli smokes cigarettes; Cassie and Lia start drinking alcohol when they are about 13, but drinking is not a focus of the book, not glamorized. Cassie is wasted when she dies. Some abuse of the various prescription drugs used for depression and eating disorders.

More on Wintergirls

What to talk about

Talk to your kids
  • Families can talk about body image, healthy self-image, and cultural expectations for women's bodies. Parents may want to read through Common Sense Media's body image tips for girls and women, and even for boys.

  • Do you think this book's discussion of eating disorders will help prevent them (and provide support for victims)... or do books like these cause more teens to try out the methods described here? What responsibility does an author have for what her readers do after reading her book?

  • Also, this book has an official trailer, just like a movie. Have you seen these for books before? What do you think of this marketing effort? How else can publishers let teens know about new books?

What's the story?

What's the story?

Eighteen-year-old Lia wakes up to learn her former best friend, Cassie, has killed herself. The night she died she called Lia 33 times, and Lia didn't answer. In fifth grade, they were best friends, so close they swore to help each other be the skinniest girls in high school. When their eating disorders spiral out of control and repeated stays in treatment centers don't help, Lia finally distances herself from Cassie. Even though Lia can't give up her obsession with losing weight, she hates herself and relieves some of her mental anguish by cutting and self-medication. Her parents try to help but are easily fooled into believing she is better, even after Cassie dies from bulimia. Cassie continues to encourage Lia to starve herself even after she is dead by haunting her; and Lia's guilt helps drive her down into one more bout of starvation that sends her to the hospital again, where she is committed and treated for mental illness.

Is it any good?

Is it any good?
 

WINTERGIRLS is very painful to read and very, very powerful. It is not for the faint of heart, but fans of Laurie Halse Anderson may find it hard to resist. Teens will find it depressing -- parents will find it even more so -- but Anderson's beautiful and evocative writing will compel them to read to the end. Anderson says in an afterward that she wrote this book because of so many readers who asked her to write about eating disorders, cutting, and feeling lost. It's hard to imagine anyone doing a better job.

An innovative style of journal writing is used to further illustrate a troubled mind -- some pages are blank while others feature crossed out words. Lia references fairy tales and fairy tale images that will appeal especially to female readers. This story has more brutality than a fairy tale from the Grimm brothers.  As Lia says, there is no magic cure for girls like her, but there is a tiny, potent thimbleful of hope in the end.

 

Book themes & details

Book Details
Author: Laurie Halse Anderson
Publisher: Viking
Publication date: March 1, 2009
Number of pages: 278
Hardcover price: $17.99

This review was written by Debra Bogart
 
 

Review It

 

Review Wintergirls





Hang on! You need to be a member to post your review.
A safe community is important to us. Please observe our guidelines.
 

What parents & educators say

14
Based on 4 parent & educator reviews:
  • 75% say there are positive messages
  • 50% say violence is an issue
  • 50% say there are positive role models
  • 50% say it's educational

Most useful reviews by all members

AGbookworm
teen, 15 years old
 
Powerful Story
This book was very moving. At times I was upset with the way Lia treated people but its very realistic, I have a friend who is having a rough time seeing that she really is a beautiful person and I am defintley lend her this book to show her how horrific her life would be if she starves herself. I think Cassie is kind of a bad role model because she does not have the strength and will to recover. If you know anyone who has an eating disorder LEND them this book it might very well save their life!

toolieloolie
teen, 15 years old
 
This book could save someone
Although people think that Lia might be a bad role model, Elijah and Cassie especially, they show the struggles of an average teen in this generation. I know that parents think that everything is fine, but it's not. This generation is worse than the others. There are younger and younger kids that commit suicide, that cut, or are suicidal. And its scary, but keeping your kids from knowing that wont save them. This book can actually scare you into becoming a healthier person. I actually had to put the book down and have a break when everything described just became too real, and I could actually feel the pain and the struggle. And in the end, Lia is a good role model, by trying to become better, and to actually accept help. There is also a positive message at the end, but if you don't read until the end, then you might not get it. Lia is only getting better for her stepsister. She didn't want her to be sad anymore. lia didnt want her sister to worry about her. And although I really did like this book, if you give it to someone too young, they might get the wrong message from the book

Kaylee0528
teen, 14 years old
 
AMAZING BOOK
i must say that this book is an amazing one!!! some people may not agree with me but i think winter girls was one of the best books i ever read. it might have had some iffy things or images in it but it was amazing, i think lia was a role model because in the end she did get help for her issues and it taught me to keep myself healthy and to not make choices like that. it was just an amazing book and i couldn't put it down.(:

Katy0
teen, 17 years old
 
Beautiful, Dark, Potent
Wintergirls, for all the violent/self hating narration, is a truly beautiful book. It is not your typical teen "problem book" where everyone with their cutesy problems is happy and popular with a boyfriend at the closing. It is realistic, gritty, and I believe it's a landmark in youth fiction. Everyone should read this book, male or female, people of every age.

2lildivasmom
parent of 10 and 13 year old
 
I just finished reading this book that my 12 year old daughter brought home from her school library. I find it unsettling that this book is accessible for her age range. Although the book describes the life of an ill/anorexic 18 year old, I think it also plants ideas into kids. Cutting, laxatives, how to count calories obsessively, lie, deceive, self destruct and down right kill yourself. My daughter is impressionable and having a book like this on her library bookshelf is scary. I don't need these issues shoved down her throat. I strongly urge parents to read the books their kids bring home. The messages in them are not only thought provoking but thought providing and could actually lead more kids down this path. I did not appreciate the author using homosexuality comments either. I believe there is a place for books such as these, but not for our young impressionable tweens and teens.

Reba9497
teen, 14 years old
 
Give it to someone with Eating Disorders, it might save them
Very very good book! Unlike what some people said (cough parent comment, cough) this book does the exact opposite but encourage you into eating disorders. It doesn't talk about how cool it is to have an eating disorder, it talks about the consequences and problems it involves. It is scary, but in a good way. It helps you get into an anorexic/bulimics head. I put it was educational because it helps u learn about eating disorders, which most people don't like to talk about.

racheli
teen, 18 years old
 
Must read for teens!
This book was absolutely AMAZING! I loved it! from the time I began reading it, I was just mesmerized, and i sat there curled in a little ball until I was finished. It was in a way scary though as well, because it was written in a way that was so real. Throughout the entire book, I kept identifying myself with Lia and I felt like I could become that girl.

 
pretty graphic...
I thought it was a very well-written book, but it was very graphic in describing the girl's eating disorders and other things.

cicoriac
teen, 15 years old
 
Excellent, powerful read
This is an excellent read, but some of the mature content might fly over younger readers' heads, like the detail and feeling that are mentioned.

♥TEAMEDWARD♥
kid, 13 years old
 
Amazing. Teens should really read this book, as well as Anderson's other pieces.
I really thought that this book was beautifully written. I can picture myelf easily in Lia's position. Many teens will be able to relate to Lia. It is actually scary, though. Not gorey scary, but the subject of anirexia and bulimia. Also, Cassie's death is while she is wasted and is caused by an eating disorder- bulimia. Teens really should read this amazing book. It really explores the dangers of cutting, drinking, and eating disorders. It is very easy to sink in and place your own self in Lia's (or Cassie's) place.

lelawow
adult
 
good for teens but not for youg=nger kids
This is a really great books. But its a little to dicriptive for its own good. But it was awsome.

brieona
teen, 14 years old
 
Scary but very good; could trigger some teens
This book is a very real look into the mind of a girl with anorexia. It's scary and probably not a book you'd want your 11-year-old reading, but the only reason it's scary is because eating disorders are too. The book will likely be a trigger for teens with eating disorders (as well as having exactly how much Lia weighs in the book at many points, it also describes how she fools other people into thinking she's not sick), and might trigger teens who cut. It's a really good book and does not glamorize being sick.

Anoleflash
teen, 13 years old
 
AMAZING!
This book was amazing. It perfectly depicts the struggles of a girl with anorexia. Lia is not a very good role model, but she does care about her stepsister Emma a lot. I couldn't put this book down!

letsflyaway19
teen, 18 years old
 
Very good book,deals with alot of insecurities and has a great message.

 
One of the best books!
Despite Lia's struggle of becoming healthy- she does over come her illness and succeeds so I think it is a really positive message! But I don't think this book is appropriate for anyone under 12... It does have a few minor swears and a few things that could give someone a queasy stomach! Overall: It is an amazing book!

mryellowplaid
teen, 17 years old
 
Perfect, amazing, beautifully written. 14+
This just might be my all-time favourite book. As someone who struggles with body issues I can very closely relate to Lia. And as someone with a mental illness, I can relate to her relationship with Cassie. It's gritty and realistic and I can almost feel myself get placed in Lia's shoes. Her experiences, relationships, and psyche are so relatable, it's mind blowing. The quote, “Tell us your secret,” the girls whisper, one toilet to another. I am that girl. I am the space between my thighs, daylight shining through. I am the bones they want, wired on a porcelain frame." haunts me everyday. You can re-read and re-read and the emotion is so raw every single time.

An independent voice for families
Age-appropriate reviews
 

vote now

Will you read Wintergirls?


Already read it? What do you think?

 

About our rating system
ON: Content is appropriate for kids this age.
PAUSE: Know your child, some content may not be right for some kids
OFF: Not age appropriate for kids this age