Witness

 Review

Common Sense Media says

Confusing yet compelling tale of racism.
greenON: Content is age-appropriate for kids this age.
yellowPAUSE: Know your child; some content
may not be right for some kids.
redOFF: Not age-appropriate for kids this age.
not for kidsNOT FOR KIDS: Not appropriate for kids any age.

Find out more

Quality
 
Sometimes media can be age appropriate but a real waste of time. Our star rating assesses the media's overall quality.

Find out more

Parents say

Kids say

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that the subject of this book is a great topic for discussion -- racism, its permeation into everyday life, and the quiet way decent people stand up to it. This historical fiction can bring to life something that readers may
have encountered in history class. It can certainly lead to some good
discussions -- between teacher and class, or among family members.

  • This historical fiction can bring to life something that readers may have encountered in history class. It can certainly lead to some good discussions -- between teacher and class, or among family members. Young readers may want to know more about the Leopold and Loeb case.
  • This book provides a provocative look into racism and its permeation into everyday life, and the quiet way decent people stand up to it.
  • Characters have different opinions, but readers will be moved by people who change and also stand up to racism.
  • A man is shot and injured, a cross is burned, a boy dies when a sandbank collapses on him, the Leopold and Loeb case and other violent news stories are discussed. There is a reference to child molestation.

What's the story?

Life in a small Vermont town in the 1920s is disrupted when the Ku Klux Klan starts making inroads and picking up adherents there. With their usual tactics of threats, intimidation, and cross burning, they create a climate of fear and division, especially for two young girls, one black and one Jewish. But Vermonters, though certainly racist, don't respond in the same way as the Klan has been used to in the South.


Is it any good?

 

Written in free-verse poetry, divided into five acts, and told from the point of view of a large cast of characters, this is, at times, a confusing hodge-podge, and would make a better performance piece than it does a novel. Many (though not all) of the characters are listed in the front, with photos, names, ages, and occupations, and many readers will need to refer to this list frequently to keep them all straight.

Much of the style, including the rather flat-footed poetry, the lack of capital letters, and the cute but bizarre dialect invented for Esther, the little Jewish girl, seem arbitrary. Nevertheless, the story, revealed in bits and pieces through the poems, is compelling and holds the reader's interest. And somewhere, some avant-garde high school drama teacher is going to make a terrific little theater piece out of this.


Sign Up Message
Sign up for our weekly newsletter
Each week we send a customized newsletter to our parent and teen subscribers. Parents can customize their settings to receive recommendations and parent tips based on their kids’ ages. Teens receive a version just for them with the latest reviews and top picks for movies, video games, apps, music, books, and more.
Please enter an email address.
Please check your email address for possible typos.
Sorry, you must be 13 or older to subscribe to our weekly newsletter.
Sign me up!

What families can talk about

  • Families can talk about historical fiction. How is reading this book different than reading an actual history book? This book is set in the 1920s -- why is it important to read stories from the past?

  • This book is written in free verse poetry. Is it easier to read a book like this -- or does it make it harder to follow the story? What would be difficult about trying to write a book like this?


This review was written by Matt Berman
Teen, 15 years old
January 19, 2011
 
Educational and Great writing.
Its very good, and I suggest you dont let younger kids reading it. The racism in the book isnt a bad thing, its just educating people on how racism actually was. Great and educational read!

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 17 years old
April 9, 2008
 

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
February 17, 2009
 
I twas a challengingbook for the younger kids
I thought that the book as challenging even for some adults.

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 17 years old
April 9, 2008
 

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 17 years old
April 9, 2008
 
a must-read book for every middle schooler
Not for young kids, some violence, a lot of hatred against jews and blacks, and people die. Crosses are burn't, the KKK is back and is geting mean in Smalltown Vermont!

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 16 years old
October 29, 2009
 
I think you should read this a 10+
I tought it was kind of confusing because of so many characters and the open verse but other than that it was pretty good.

Flag as inappropriate 
Kid, 11 years old
March 20, 2010
 
Older Kids
Very Good ! But only for people +10 Good book and esther is a cute charter

Flag as inappropriate 
Kid, 13 years old
January 29, 2010
 
Just Beautiful
While some people might argue, the racism is a good thing. The bad characters are the racist ones, and everyone knows it. The characters are amazing, and cute and just...wow...

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 17 years old
April 9, 2008
 
Excellent Book
This book "Witness" is an excellent book for Black History Month!! Even if it is not Black History Month you can still read it. Their is a liitle "bad" language, but you should be able to handle it!! Hope you read the book!!

Flag as inappropriate 

This review was written by Matt Berman
Author:Karen Hesse
Book type:Fiction
Genre:Historical Fiction
Publisher:Scholastic Inc.
Publication date:March 6, 2004
Number of pages:161
Hardcover price:$16.96
Publisher's recommended age(s):9 - 12

This review was written by Matt Berman
 

Review It

Share your review with others

Hang on! You need to be a member to post your review.
A safe community is important to us. Please observe our guidelines.

Register now to save reviews and advice articles to your personal lists!


About our rating system
ON: Content is age-appropriate for kids this age.
PAUSE: Know your child; some content may not be right for some kids.
OFF: Not age-appropriate for kids this age.
Learning ratings
BEST: Really engaging, great learning approach.
GOOD: Pretty engaging, good learning approach.
FAIR: Somewhat engaging, OK learning approach.
NOT FOR LEARNING: Not recommended for learning.

 

vote now

Will you read Witness?


Already read it? What do you think?

 

Been There? Tell us about it