Lesson: A Creator’s Responsibilities (6-8)

In the Unit 2 for Grades 6-8

What responsibilities do you have to respect others’ creative work?

Students reflect on their responsibilities as creators and users of creative work.

Download Lesson Materials


Learning Overview and Objectives

Students view and discuss the video vignette, a documentary-style story of a young creator who uses video and music clips to make his own creations. Students then read case studies and discuss the particular ethical challenges that a “cut and paste” digital culture poses with respect to creative work.

Students will be able to ...

  • consider ethical questions about real-life decisions young creators make in exercising their creative rights and responsibilities.
  • understand that piracy and plagiarism are irresponsible and disrespectful behaviors that have ethical and legal implications.
  • brainstorm solutions to dilemmas creators might encounter.

 


Materials and Preparation

  • Preview the video, “Henry’s Story – Making Mashups,” and be prepared to play the video for the class.
  • Copy the A Creator’s Responsibilities Discussion Guide, one for each student.
  • Review the A Creator’s Responsibilities Discussion Guide – Teacher Version.

 


Teaching Plans

Estimated time: 45 minutes

introduction

Warm-up (10 minutes)

ASK: Can you remember when you last copied, downloaded, or shared some type of creative work?
Guide students to think about their everyday sharing of copyrighted work. They might not even be aware that they are using copyrighted work every day. Sample responses:

  • Downloaded a video from YouTube
  • Bought a song on iTunes
  • Cut out a magazine photo and put it in my locker

ASK: Can you think of a time when you used someone else’s work in something you made?
Guide students to be specific about what work they used, and how they used it. You may also want to ask about whether they acknowledged the sources they used by citing them. Sample responses:

  • Used information from a website in a school report
  • Used photos I found in Google Image Search for PowerPoint slides
  • Used video clips I downloaded from YouTube in a remix video I made

EMPHASIZE to students that they often use copyrighted work in their everyday lives: (1) they use and enjoy media as consumers, and (2) they incorporate media into their own creations (blogs, mash-ups, etc.). Whether they are just using material for enjoyment or using it to create a new work, highlight to students that they should be responsible and respectful of other people’s creative work by providing proper credit.

 

teach 1

Henry's Story (10 minutes)

DEFINE the Key Vocabulary terms piracy, plagarism, and acknowledge with students. Ask students to listen for these words in the video they are about to watch.

DISTRIBUTE the A Creator’s Responsibilities Discussion Guide.

EXPLAIN to students that are going to watch a video about a teen boy who likes to take clips of music and movies and make them into his own creations.

SHOW students the “Henry’s Story – Making Mashups” video.

DISCUSS the video with the whole group. Use the A Creator’s Responsibilities Discussion Guide – Teacher Version for guidance about leading the discussion.

EMPHASIZE to students that there are right and wrong ways to use copyrighted work. People who pirate or plagiarize not only risk getting in trouble at school or with the law, but their behavior is also unethical and disrespectful to creators. Students should always show respect for the creative work they use by acknowledging – or giving credit to – the work they use. Provide an example of a citation (e.g., bibliography of a book).

 

teach 2

Reflection and Discussion of Case Studies (20 minutes)

DIVIDE students into groups of four or five.

HAVE groups choose one or two of the case studies listed in the A Creator’s Responsibilities Discussion Guide. They should read each case study and answer the discussion questions that follow.

ENCOURAGE students to use the Ask, Acknowledge, Add Value steps on the first page of the guide to craft advice specifically for their case studies’ characters.

INVITE students to choose a representative from their respective groups to summarize their case studies for the whole class. Then ask the representatives to share their group’s advice for the characters in the case studies.

 

closing

Wrap-up (5 minutes)

You can use these questions to assess your students’ understanding of the lesson objectives. You may want to ask students to reflect in writing on one of the questions, using a journal or an online blog/wiki.

ASK: Why do you think it’s illegal for people to pirate or plagiarize other people’s work?
It hurts the original creator’s ability to receive credit, get paid, and get respect for his or her work.

ASK: What are some ways to use and rework copyrighted materials ethically and legally?
Encourage students to recall the Ask, Acknowledge, Add Value steps. These questions will help students reflect on the type of copyright they are dealing with, how they might ask the creator for permission to use the original material, how to give the creator credit, and the extent to which they have reworked the material to make new meaning and add something original.

ASK: What is something new you learned that helps you be responsible and respectful toward other people’s creative work?
Students’ answers will vary.

 

EXTENSION ACTIVITY

Have students break into small groups to develop their own real-life stories of ethical dilemmas about respecting creative work, which should be similar in format to the case studies they read. Students might address dilemmas regarding piracy, plagiarism, file sharing, remixing and mashing, or how to comment constructively on other people’s work. Students then perform their stories of ethical dilemmas in front of the class. The class then discusses solutions to the dilemma portrayed, emphasizing how to be responsible with others’ creative work.

AT-HOME ACTIVITY

Students use the case studies from the A Creator’s Responsibilities Discussion Guide to interview family members. Students read the scenarios aloud and ask the questions to their family. Students then explain the responsibilities creators have to respect other people’s work.

 


Alignment with Standards -- Common Core & NETS•S

Source: Common Core State Standards Initiative ©2012 & National Educational Technology Standards for Students ©2007, International Society for Technology in Education

Common Core: RI.6-8.2, RI.6-8.3, RI.6.7-8, RI.7-8.8, RI.7-8.10, W.6-8.4, W.6-8.10, SL.6-8.1a-d, SL.6-8.2, SL.6-8.6, L.6-8.6, RST.6-8.2, RST.6-8.4, RST.6-8.10, WHST.6-8.4, WHST.6-8.10, 

NETS•S: 1a-c, 2a, 2d, 5a-c

 

Family resources
  • Henry's Story - Making Mashups
    download right click to save

Key Vocabulary
  • piracy: the stealing copyrighted work by downloading or copying it in order to keep, sell, or give it away without permission and without paying
  • plagiarism: the copying, “lifting,” or making slight changes to some or all of someone else’s work and saying you wrote it
  • acknowledge: giving credit to someone’s work you use by clearly stating their name, title of the work, year it was made, and a hyperlink

 

 

poll

Did this specific Top Picks list help you decide to do any of the following?