Game Details
Price
  • $39.99 each
Available on
Genre
More details

Pokemon HeartGold & SoulSilver Versions (Nintendo DS, Nintendo DSi)

common sense media says

Collect & battle game uses a pedometer to get kids walking.


parents & educators say
  • 44% say there are positive messages
  • 44% say it's educational

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that Pokemon HeartGold and Pokemon SoulSilver are two slightly different versions of the same game. Each version contains some exclusive creatures that kids can "capture" and then trade with friends who also have one of the games. These games also come with a new peripheral called the Pokewalker, which is essentailly a pedometer that kids use. Kids are rewarded for walking with the Pokewalker, but they can also use the pocket-sized device to connect with friends for more Pokemon battling and trading. This game has a very high appeal to kids, so parents need to be sure their children won't sneak Pokemon action in where they're not supposed to.

Educational value: Not applicable.
Positive messages: This particular incarnation of Pokemon carries with it a positive message that no other Pokemon game has had before: Get out and get some exercise. The Pokewalker peripheral works like a pedometer, and the more you walk with it, the more you're rewarded with "watt" points that you can use to help train your Pokemon or get new items.
Positive role models: There have always been somewhat mixed messages in caring for Pokemon. You need to keep their health and well-being in mind, and treat them as you would pets. But at the same time, you've just captured these creatures from out of their natural habitats and you now use them to fight one another.
Ease of play: Pokemon games have always been built with a very easy to learn system, perfect for newcomers to quickly join in on the action.
Violence & scariness: While fighting is as the heart of the Pokemon games, battles between Pokemon creatures are shown in very abstract ways. The language -- "tackle," "scratch," "poison," etc. -- sounds far worse than what you see on screen. Visually, most of the attacks consist of one Pokemon quickly leaning toward the other (but staying several body lengths away), and then seeing a couple of gray puffs appear over the other Pokemon, along with a buzzy, bump noise.
Language: Not applicable.
Consumerism: First, there are two versions of what is essentially the same game (each has a couple of exclusive Pokemons to call its own). Kids may beg to own both: "But Mom, I can't get Ho-Oh unless I buy the other one!" These games also tie into the vast Pokemon merchandising empire to which these game belong.

More on Pokemon HeartGold & SoulSilver Versions

What to talk about

Talk to your kids
  • Families can talk about the benefits of using the Pokewalker add-on. The Pokewalker is not necessary for playing these games, so why use it? Does it actually encourage kids to walk more? Instead of driving, will your children walk or ride a bike to, say, a friend's house if they know they could increase their Pokemon's power by doing so?

  • Families can also talk about how to limit the time kids can play this game so that a reasonable amount is the norm.

What's the story?

What's the story?

Whether you play POKEMON SOULSILVER or POKEMON HEARTGOLD, your story will center around a young Pokemon trainer exploring his (or her) world to help a scientist find new species of Pokemon. At the same time, the young trainer will enter into Pokemon fighting leagues and battle tournaments. Players can transfer one of their captured Pokemon into the accompanying Pokewalker peripheral (a pedometer that connects to your DS) to take with them and continue to train even when not playing with the main DS game. Pokemon can earn experience points from going on a walk with the player in the real world.

Is it any good?

Is it any good?
 

Pokemon HeartGold and SoulSilver are just as good as any previous titles from the main line of Pokemon games. They look, sound, and play almost exactly the same way those earlier incarnations did. Yet, while there's not much in the way of startlingly new gameplay, Pokemon fans will certainly get a whole lot more of what they're looking for and love about playing these games. Kids who have only a passing interest in Pokemon and who have played any of the last few years' Pokemon titles might find these new ones a bit repetitive, but they do make excellent jumping on points for kids who are new to the Pokemon world. Also, kudos are due for the inclusion of the Pokewalker, which adds an interesting -- and healthy! -- new level to Pokemon gaming.

Online interaction: Kids can trade captured Pokemon. This encourages interaction between friends.

Game themes & details

Game Details
Available on: Nintendo DS, Nintendo DSi
Available online
Genre: Adventure
Developer: Nintendo
Released on: March 14, 2010
Price: 39.99 each
ESRB Rating: E for Mild Cartoon Violence
Screenshots

This review was written by Christopher Healy
 
 

Review It

 

Review Pokemon HeartGold & SoulSilver Versions





Hang on! You need to be a member to post your review.
A safe community is important to us. Please observe our guidelines.
 

What parents & educators say

7
Based on 16 parent & educator reviews:
  • 44% say there are positive messages
  • 44% say it's educational
  • 31% say they noticed product placement

Most useful reviews by all members

obnoxiousm
educator and parent
 
Not the best Pokemon, but a pedometer! You can't beat that!
I'm an educator (my supposed 13 year old kid is supposed to represent my students until I figure out how to get an educator account), and also a longtime Pokemon player, ever since it first came out when I was 11. HeartGold is not the best installment gameplay wise, but it's one of the more appropriate ones due to the lack of controversial content the Pokewalker, a pedometer that gives you in-game rewards for reaching certain stepcounts in th day. In HGSS you play a ten year old kid. The local pokemon professor gives you a Pokemon and asks you to walk with it (instead of keeping it in a ball all the time like most people do) to see how that effects its development. You get a rival in the form of a kid who stole another pokemon from the professor, and you have to go up against Team Rocket, an evil criminal syndicate who want to use Pokemon for power and profit. Gameplay is great, and as always educational. Pokemon is text-intensive and can help kids with reading, and I personally got through college math because Pokemon kept my estimation, multiplication, and algebraic knowledge fresh. You don't need to know algebra to play, but if you do it can be a lot easier to do well, as the game is controlled by a master equation consisting of your Pokemon's offensive stats, divded by the other pokemon's defensive stas, times the type multipliers. The violence of the game is comparable to boxing in our world, though very young kids might require a talk about this. Concerns I have with the game are the fact that the rival isn't punished for stealing the Pokemon, the apparent aimlessness of Team Rocket, and of course the ridiculous levels of consumerism. Also, as it's very hard to cheat the Pokewalker, lazy kids might do adventurous things to get their watts, like throw the walker in the dryer or attempt to attach it to a treadmill (I, an adult, have already nearly broken the Pokewalker several times trying to cheat it when my feet were tired from teaching!). Luckily replacements can be cheaply ordered from Nintendo. If your child has trouble with computers or reading you may want to get them Diamond/Pearl/Platinum instead. The computer system in which you store Pokemon is a little... confusing. Also very biased toward right-handed people.

Brizboy
kid, 12 years old
 
Good game but too hard? :-(
This game is to hard for ages 9 and below. The Reasons are 1. The game has 2 regions so that means 16 badges to collect. 2. Some thing are relly confusing. There are more reasons but the reason is this game is more complicated than other version.

gamer dude
kid, 11 years old
 
only pokemon game worth getting
it is one of the coolest games ever! it is certinaly better than the other pokemon games, probably the only one worth getting. it does have consumerism though, its trying to get you to buy other pokemon junk. but all in all, its a great game!

mdinger2
kid, 12 years old
 
Very Good, Until I Traded It In To Save Up For My Xbox 360 Slim.
Okay, my little brothers have played it, I've played it, its pretty good but i wish it had a new region in this game. I played through the game and then traded it in at one video game store so I had enough money for my Xbox 360 Slim.

annefessler
educator and parent of 8 year old
 
It's an awesome game. You should get it! In it, you can catch powerful Pokemon such as Entei. In it you can solve puzzles, such as you might have to go across ice in the game, and if you need to stop, you have to run into rocks or something on the ice to stop. There are people called Gym Leaders in the game, and I have beat 16 of them. -- Jacob, age 8

mmcm1126
parent of 8 and 13 year old
 
this game is a great starting game that causes its players to stratigize.
i like this game for my kids because it has the educational value that comes from forming stratigies, the positive message of takeing care of animals, in this case pokemon, and once the concept of levels and types are understood this game is very easy to play.

chimera
kid, 12 years old
 
A.I.L.T.G (amazing i love this game)
i love it. it seems strange that almost all of my friends have this game in their car, always playing it on the phone, and calling me to tell them they caught groudon or something. but still, its educaational (or at leats teaches strategy and patience) has good messages about saving the world and you can be strong by lovbing your pokemon, and is pretty easy, execpt for the skill course onn pokeathalon wich is rigged and stupid. but you might get teased and beaten up at school for it if you 4th grade+.

whyamiusingthi ...
teen, 17 years old
 
I want everyone to look at this review and use it as an example.
This is what kids should be playing! Not Assassi's Creed or Grand Theft Auto. Your kids need to learn sportsmanship, teamwork and, now more than ever, phyisical fitness. NOT HOW KILL SOMEONE THEN STEAL HIS CAR! I am going to be the last 13 year old on this earth with parents who care for his wellbeing. Well thank you SMART PARENTS AND KIDS for taking this message to heart!

TheVampire
teen, 13 years old
 
i think its a VERY good game. ive loved these games 4 as long as i can remember. the pokewalker is a very good move 2 get kids off thier couch if they did'nt lose it like i did. those who played Gold and Silver in 1999 will love to play it again with all the new features. parents however, will have to give the advertisment lesson 2 kids first. this is another large chunk of pokemon franchise. other than that, this is just like any other pokemon game

Giygas
teen, 16 years old
 
Pokemon HeartGold, The Perfect Remake
This game is definite proof that the Pokemon series has yet to go stale. This game definitely stays to true to the original games, while also adding on plenty of post-game content to keep you occupied for hours on end.

 
Good remake of a classic
This game is a remake of a classic; my first GameBoy game which I received in second grade. It was (and still is) the very best friends to take along for long car rides and other waits to pass the time. Its a hard game for younger kids too, and can even be challenging for older kids--this game built up so much patience, dedication, and strategy for me when I was little. The premise is that you raise fantasy creatures called Pokemon to protect you as you explore the wild world. Wild pokemon attack your character, and you use your own pokemon to fight for you (kind of like a guard dog!) and bring them down. Doing this makes your pokemon get more experienced and get stronger. No blood, no contact even, everything very implied and cartoonish, and no pokemon dies. Yet its a good first strategy game and can be either as simple or as complicated as the child is able to play. I bought this game for old time's sake! Enjoyed a good many hours with an old friend. Its exactly the same as the older version but with much better graphics...good game. I recommend it.

Zoe Grace1
kid, 11 years old
 
I Like this Game The Glitches Are funny and the story is about "Saving Johto\Kanto From Team Rocket" Although You Have Caught Pokemon From Thier Natraul habitat They Eventully Start To like You

Poke493
kid, 11 years old
 
Pokemon Soul Silver Review
It is most-likely one of the best games I ever played! When my parents aren't telling me to do chores or shoolwork and I've earned gametime, I play it for as long as possible without having to shut it down. I don't see why anyone should hate it. 'Cause it's one great game!

 
This game happens to be my best game I haved played. I even got this game at GameStop. ... and this game is easy to play. I like this game. I give it the age to play will be 8+.

 
Requires good problem solving skills, use of maps, solving puzzles, etc. This particular version has a bit of an odd message giving phone numbers out to strangers you meet - this should be a discussion point with youngster.

mesguy
kid, 10 years old
 
graet game
love the game plus theres so much to do.

pinkkittyninja
kid, 13 years old
 
Fun, addicting game for all ages! :)
Pokemon Soulsilver is my first ever pokemon game, and to tell you the truth, I LOVED IT!! It's very addicting to play and sometimes I find myself playing on it for hours at a time. It's sometimes a little tricky though, and it gets a little frustrating at times, like when I walk through a cave I cant walk around without facing a pokemon every 10-20 seconds!!! And also--Strategy is key. Fighting the different pokemon is like a rock, paper, scissors match but with more strategy involved. Overall, this is an insanely addicting game that will be great for a pokemon fanatic to someone new to the series alike! Have fun :)

Deega
kid, 12 years old
 
perfect for anyone
I love it! i played it like three hours this morning and like 2 this afternoon. its that good! Nothing is bad in it except that you can name your pokemon and your charachters anything you want, but if you let like your 4 year old or something get it your not gonna see like the s word as their lugias name or something, but lots of people (like me) are gonna want to name their rival something stupid or offensive like fool or dope. but still, its ok for anyone. and it gets you active by making a pokewalker, thats a pedometer that gives your pokemon one exp. point for every step, and you cant just shake it and get steps, which is good. nintendo has also made this a hidden ad though by making like the fifth generaion of pokemon or something, so your kids might wanna buy like the first second third and fourth generations too, so dont let them blow their money on the 20-something other pokemon games if they get it. and if oyure 10 and you think its baybish, think again becuase the only haters are stupid idiots who all they play is M games.

msfan645
kid, 12 years old
 
Good.
This game is awesome. But it has worn out over the years...

Epic dude4477
kid, 10 years old
 
Good game
Good for younger kids

An independent voice for families
Age-appropriate reviews
 

vote now

Will you play Pokemon HeartGold & SoulSilver Versions?


Already played it? What do you think?

 

About our rating system
ON: Content is appropriate for kids this age.
PAUSE: Know your child, some content may not be right for some kids
OFF: Not age appropriate for kids this age