The Clearing (R)

Good performances almost make it worthwhile.

(Flash is loading. If this text does not disappear you need to install the latest flash version)

About Our Ratings

Common Sense rates it

Seen the movie?

Watch video review
Save It!
Email it
Compare Prices

Movie details

Studio: Fox Searchlight, Fox Searchlight
Directed By: Pieter Brugge
Cast: Helen Mirren, Robert Redford
Running Time: 91 minutes
Release Date: 07/01/2004
Video/DVD Release Date: 11/08/2004
Genre: Drama
MPAA Rating: R
MPAA Explanation: brief strong language

Parents need to know

Parents need to know that this movie has brief strong language and some violence. Characters drink and smoke. There are sexual references, including adultery. There are very tense scenes that may be upsetting to some audience members.

Families can talk about the choices made by Wayne and Eileen. If you had the chance to write a note like the one Wayne writes to Eileen, what would it say?

Message
Violence
Sex
Language

Message

Social Behavior:

Consumerism:

Drugs/Alcohol/Tobacco:

Smoking, drinking.

Violence

Tense and violent scenes.

Sex

Sexual references, including adultery.

Language

Brief strong language.

Common Sense says

What's the story?

Reviewed by Nell Minow

In THE CLEARING, Robert Redford plays Wayne, a very successful businessman who lives in a beautiful house with Eileen, his loving if somewhat reserved wife (Helen Mirren). When he does not show up for a dinner with friends he did not particularly want to see, at first she is annoyed and embarrassed. But then she is worried. She files a missing person report. And then she hears from the kidnappers. Wayne has been abducted by Arnold (Willem Dafoe), who is frog-marching him to the top of a mountain, but won't tell him why or what will happen to him. Wayne is known for his skills at communication and negotiation. Can he use them to persuade Arnold to let him go? At home, Eileen waits as the FBI tries to find Wayne and get him home. Her daughter and her son (Alessandro Nivola) with his wife and baby join her to wait.

Is it any good?

Why would such a murky movie be called The Clearing? There are glimpses and hints of a deeper plot and interesting characters, but the movie doesn't explore beyond the surface. The adult daughter seems to be retreating, sleeping in her mother's bed and curling into the fetal position, barely speaking. Eileen insists on celebrating her grandson's first birthday. Why do we learn that after Wayne sold his business, his next venture failed? Either these were intended to provide some subtle atmosphere and complexity to a straightforward story or (more likely) they relate to plot points that may have been diminished by last-minute cuts after unsatisfactory test screenings. They are more distracting than evocative.

But Mirren's performance almost makes it worthwhile. She is strong and vulnerable at the same time. Her Eileen is richly complex, whether trying on clothes or confronting Wayne's mistress. She makes us feel Wayne's ache at the thought of losing her and adds depth and resonance to the movie that makes us feel its other failures even more sharply.