The Human Stain (R)

Flawed adaptation of Roth’s novel isn’t for kids.

(Flash is loading. If this text does not disappear you need to install the latest flash version)

Common Sense rates it
3
Seen the movie? Review it
1743_orig.jpg
Movie details
  • Studio: Miramax, Miramax
  • Directed By: Robert Benton
  • Cast: Anthony Hopkins, Nicole Kidman
  • Running Time: 107 minutes
  • Release Date: 10/30/2003
  • Video/DVD Release Date: 07/19/2004
  • Genre: Drama
  • MPAA Rating: R
  • MPAA Explanation: language and sexuality/nudity

Parents need to know

Parents need to know that this movie has some very strong language and some very explicit sexual references and situations, including nudity. Characters drink and smoke, sometimes to excess. Characters are in peril and there are some tragic (offscreen) deaths. The movie's themes about racism and "sanctimony" are provocatively presented.

Families can talk about Coleman's choices. What were the turning points? Would he have chosen differently if he had known that the world was about to change so dramatically?

Message

Social Behavior:

A theme of the movie.

Consumerism:

Drugs/Alcohol/Tobacco:

Characters drink and smoke.

Violence

Character deaths. Characters in peril.

Sex

Some very explicit sexual references and situations, including nudity.

Language

Some very strong language.

Common Sense says

What's the story?

Reviewed by Nell Minow

When Professor Coleman Silk (Anthony Hopkins) calls on two students who aren't present and asks, "Are they spooks?," he's hit with a formal complaint because the two students are African-American, and "spook" is considered a racist epithet. Coleman points out that since he'd never seen the students, he couldn't have meant the word that way. But no one defends him, despite his long-time support for minorities. Coleman has one more rebuttal up his sleeve -- he's a light-skinned African-American who's been "passing" as white for years. Coleman leaves the college and tries unsuccessfully to write about the injustice before asking reclusive novelist Zuckerman (Gary Sinise) to write his story. They become friends, but Zuckerman turns him down. Then Coleman gets involved with the beautiful-but-guarded Faunia (Nicole Kidman), who's stalked by an abusive ex (Ed Harris). Coleman's past is shown in flashbacks, and just as Coleman and Faunia are able to reveal themselves to each other for the first time, volatile forces from the past converge inexorably and terribly.

Is it any good?

3
THE HUMAN STAIN is a flawed but engrossing story about the way that people try to escape their pasts -- and the way that carefully constructed new personas, no matter how scrubbed and burnished, can't erase the stain of the original. Philip Roth's ambitious and literary novel is awkwardly adapted for the screen. The book's almost allegorical structure is supported by Roth's use of language, but on screen, the characters are more plot devices than people. Zuckerman, though well-played by Sinise, is a narrative convention who adds nothing to the drama. And the menace provided by Faunia's Vietnam veteran ex-husband borders on melodrama.

The most affecting part of the story is the flashbacks. Young Coleman (Wentworth Miller), in love for the first time with a beautiful, intelligent, and sympathetic Midwestern girl (Jacinda Barrett), experiments with the feeling of being not black or white but just free of any color. Then he brings her home to meet his mother (Anna Deavere Smith), not letting either one know ahead of time that they're of different races. Nothing that happens in the Hopkins/Kidman segment of the story is anywhere near as compelling.

Other choices

Pinky (1949)
Imitation of Life (1959)
Jungle Fever
Support Common Sense Media
Common Sense Media is a non-profit and will receive a portion of your purchase from Pricegrabber. Learn more.

Parents and kids say

Be the first to post a review.

Log in or Register to post a review
Review It
Who's your favorite TV holiday special character?
Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer
26%
The Grinch
34%
Frosty the Snowman
11%
Charlie Brown
18%
Shrek
10%
209 votes