Common Sense Note
This lighter version is good family fare, but mediocre songs bog the story down. The long-winded ending takes a bizarre detour from Dickens's classic source material. Six-, 7- and 8-year olds will enjoy the songs and the lively story, but the youngest may not go for the ghost angle, which may frighten them. Older kids can use an occasional reminder of what Christmas is really about. A meatier version might be in order for teens and adults.
One man's miserliness contributes to others' poverty and misery. Families who watch this film may want to discuss how family members' greediness or generosity affects others. Why did Scrooge eventually change? What rewards did he receive?
Common Sense Review
Reviewed By: Scott G. Mignola
Incorrigible skinflint Ebenezer Scrooge gets the musical treatment in this 1970 adaptation of Dickens's A Christmas Carol. The songs, while unmemorable, provide a cushion for young ones who might be intimidated by scarier versions. Albert Finney stars, with Alec Guinness as an eerie, surprisingly subdued Jacob Marley.
Unlike George C. Scott in the 1984 film version, or Alastair Sim in the 1951 classic, Albert Finney doesn't contribute much to the role. His performance is a mere caricature. Hearing him sing robs him of his menace (even when he's singing "I Hate People"), and what is a Scrooge without menace? Humbug!
But this is a non-threatening version, good for kids, and for adults who don't want all that chain-rattling and wailing, so its lighter touch is forgiven. Less forgivable are the songs, which slow the whole production down. Sure, it's funny to see Scrooge's death foreshadowed as a funeral parade with joyous crowds singing "Thank You Very Much," but that's as good as the musical numbers get. Composer Leslie Bricusse may still have been recuperating from his fine work on 1967's Doctor Dolittle, for which he won an Oscar.
In the battle for the best Marley, Alec Guinness makes a convincing entrance, doing a slow, swimming sort of walk capable of raising a few neck hairs. The movie's worth seeing for Guinness alone, and for the weird ending in which Scrooge falls into his own grave and winds up in hell, where Marley offers to show him to his quarters.
For a moderately sinister holiday musical, The Nightmare Before Christmas is hard to beat.
Rate It!
| Content | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CS | adults | kids | ||
Sexual Content |
 |
|||
ViolenceThe appearance of the ghost of Jacob Marley and some moderately grotesque flying spirits. Scrooge falls into his own grave and lands in hell. |
|
|||
Language |
|
|||
Message |
|
|||
Social BehaviorThis is a powerfully moralistic tale demonstrating not only how greed can overshadow love, but how even a seemingly hopeless man can turn his life around. |
 |
|||
Commercialism |
 |
|||
Drug/Alcohol/Tobacco |
|
|||
