A Christmas Carol (1984)

  • Review Date: May 12, 2005
  • PG
  • Genre: Classic
  • 1984
 Review

Common Sense Media says

Bleak but solid adaptation of Dickens' classic.
greenON: Content is age-appropriate for kids this age.
yellowPAUSE: Know your child; some content
may not be right for some kids.
redOFF: Not age-appropriate for kids this age.
not for kidsNOT FOR KIDS: Not appropriate for kids any age.

Find out more

Quality
 
Sometimes media can be age appropriate but a real waste of time. Our star rating assesses the media's overall quality.

Find out more

Parents say

Kids say

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that in this movie, the granddaddy of morality tales, Dickens' timeless material looks unglamorously at 19th century English life and shows us how wrong turns, if not righted, can lead good people astray. The music dramatically complements a finely adapted script. Delivered dryly, the humor hits its mark; you can't help laughing at Scrooge's expense. Despite the valuable message, this version may be too dark and frightening for some. There's plenty here for the entire family to enjoy, and even shed a few tears over. But the scenes are bleak. Glimpses of desperate families and sickly children. A once bitter and resentful man anguishes over the pain he's caused others. Glimpses of a tortured childhood place partial blame for Scrooge's condition on an uncaring father.

  • Dicken's classic tale of compassion has been through so many incarnations, but it still presents an important and eloquent message that doesn't fail.
  • Scrooge is greedy, selfish, and lacks compassion -- but in the end he sorely regrets this behavior.
  • Ghosts! Cruel, tormenting ghosts!
  • Not applicable.

What's the story?

In A CHRISTMAS CAROL, the ghost of Ebenezer Scrooge's business partner pays him a visit on Christmas Eve. Bound in the chains of greed and contempt he forged in life, Marley warns tightfisted Ebenezer that he awaits the same fate if he doesn't change his ways. "You will be visited by three spirits," Marley tells him, and at the stroke of 1 a.m., Scrooge awakens to the first of them, who leads him through his past to revisit the poor choices that made him the man he is. A second spirit shows him the present, and the dreadfully silent final spirit presents grim shadows of Christmases yet to come. At the sight of his own lonely grave, Scrooge breaks down and begs forgiveness, vowing sincerely to carry the spirit of Christmas in his heart all year round.


Is it any good?

 

This 1984 retelling of the Charles Dickens classic boasts an exceptional cast (among them Frank Finlay as Jacob Marley and David Warner as the put-upon Bob Cratchit), splendid costumes and backdrops, and a timelessness that comes from smart filmmaking and avoidance of gaudy effects that too soon show their age. It's perhaps the finest version yet of this often-told story, right up there with the 1951 version starring Alastair Sim, but it's not for everyone.

This is a painfully expressive movie filled with bleak, chilling imagery. Children may shudder at the sight of crutch-ridden Tiny Tim, whose pale flesh and sunken eyes make him in some ways a more disturbing apparition than the shrieking, milky-eyed ghost, Marley. Scrooge, magnificently played by George C. Scott, is a sneering, despicable tightwad who delights in his humbuggery, yet goes almost willingly with his phantom guides as only a man seeking atonement would. When he breaks down at the end and pleads for forgiveness, he's a pitiable sight, and there can be no doubt that he is truly saved.


Explore, discuss, enjoy

  • Families can talk about how we make right our wrongs.

  • How do you recognize your wrongs?

  • Do you find them on your own, or do
    you, like Scrooge, need someone else to help you see them?

  • How do you
    make things right?


This review of A Christmas Carol (1984) was written by
Kid, 12 years old
December 23, 2009
 
Not Scary, but boring
hated this movie, had 2 watch it in school... i watched the first 45 minutes... my teacher turned it off because nobody wanted to watch it.

Flag as inappropriate 
Parent of 2, 5, and 9 year old
December 28, 2010
 
Absolutely love this movie!!
What other families should know:

Flag as inappropriate 
Kid, 10 years old
January 7, 2011
 
good for family
i liked this movie but it was not the best movie i have seen

Flag as inappropriate 
Kid, 9 years old
December 31, 2010
 
BETTER THEN DISNEYS
Wow this is alot better then disneys i do respect disneys movies but there version was plain creepy,anyway this version is alot better and done well plus it has people in it not CG charcters but this great,i think this well based on the book. and fine for 7+
What other families should know:

Flag as inappropriate 
Kid, 9 years old
January 28, 2011
 
boring...........
What other families should know:

Flag as inappropriate 
Kid, 10 years old
January 17, 2011
 
hate it not a good movie
What other families should know:

Flag as inappropriate 
Kid, 9 years old
January 3, 2011
 
a christmas carol
its about a grumpy old man called mr scrooge that has a dream about ghosts that teach him to be nice and caeing.
What other families should know:

Flag as inappropriate 
Kid, 9 years old
January 14, 2011
 
it is nice but some parts are dirty and scary
What other families should know:

Flag as inappropriate 
Kid, 12 years old
December 16, 2010
 
Just Like the Original Book!
I think it really captures the Dickens tale. The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come and the ghost of Marley are very creepy, but the movie is not scary and sends a good message about Christmas being friendly, generous, and cheerful.
What other families should know:

Flag as inappropriate 
Kid, 10 years old
November 8, 2012
 
Good movie for older kids
I love this movie and so does my sister. When I first Saw "a Christmas carol" I got really scared of Jacob Marley, so I think if you are under the age of 9 you should not watch it. Now that I am 10 years old I am not scared anymore. ALERT: this movie will give you very happy dreams about rainbows!
What other families should know:

Flag as inappropriate 

This review of A Christmas Carol (1984) was written by
Topics:book characters, holidays, monsters, ghosts, and vampires
Studio:Twentieth Century Fox
Director:Clive Donner
Cast:David Warner, Frank Finlay, George C. Scott
Genre:Classic
Run time:100 minutes
Theatrical release date:January 1, 1984
DVD release date:October 5, 1999
MPAA rating:PG
MPAA explanation:thematic intensity

This review of A Christmas Carol (1984) was written by
 

Review It

Share your review with others

Hang on! You need to be a member to post your review.
A safe community is important to us. Please observe our guidelines.

Learning Products Quick Finder