Just as dumb as the title suggests
The premise is interesting and the animations are alright for motion capture, but this story is a mess. They rush the beginning and everything else is just repetitive. The worst thing has to be the message and how they get it across. The moral is to always be good to your mother... and if you do, she'll get taken away by aliens and blown up... what!? What kind of message are you trying to send kids, movie!? Make up your mind!
What other families should know:
Flag as inappropriate
Parent of 7 year old
April 11, 2011
i think its very good & entertaining movie for kids...they will njoy a lot...has a good message..
What other families should know:
Flag as inappropriate
Parent of 6 and 9 year old
May 7, 2011
Great for young and older kids
I loved this movie! It had a very positive message about Moms and how important they are to a child's life. There may be a few scary moments (when the mom is abducted or when one of the moms dies - the latter isn't really shown and is only suggested) that might be upsetting to a younger child, and some violence, but my kids loved it and we thought it was really entertaining. I even got teary at one point!
What other families should know:
Flag as inappropriate
Best for older kiddos
I took my 10-year old son and same-age friend to this movie. While they understood the happenings were fictional and appreciated the humorous parts, I would not recommend for a child younger than 8 or 9 (depending on the child's maturity level and ability to handle intense scenes). This could be scary and confusing for younger children.
Overall positive message; but also fairly deep underlying messages for a children's movie.
What other families should know:
Flag as inappropriate
Parent of 7 year old
March 13, 2011
Surprisingly Scary and Some Weird Messages.
Quite scary - my 7 year boy sees lots of movies - but this had too many near death scenes and was disturbing. One of the main characters was not able to save his mom.
The messages were confusing and unclear. The moms that had well behaved kids and were stricter moms were the ones that could get abducted and killed by the Martians. So the message almost becomes don't behave too well or your mom could be abducted and killed. Also, there were male martians that behaved like unintelligent, fun-loving, crazy creatures that were not part of the orderly female run martian culture, they were not valued as bright or effective enough to raise the "hatchlings" along with the females. The male martians were ostracized from the society and lived together in the garbage dump. Very strange message that seemed to minimize the value of men & boys.
The movie also had non-stop stressful moments - which was frightening for my son (who has actually seen parts of many live action movies such as "Lord of the Rings", "Star Wars", etc.). There was no down time for the child viewer - very few funny moments.
Usually the reviews from Common Sense Media are right on - but this movie was not suitable for my family. This was an intense, stressful movie for my son with a very stressful subject matter (the idea of losing one's mom).
What other families should know:
Flag as inappropriate
Parent of 7 and 9 year old
March 13, 2011
Okay for most kids, with a few caveats.
Not a great movie, but one that my 7-year-old enjoyed (my son, not so much), and I tolerated. Some concerns were the scary mom abduction scene; scary scenes where they show how they extract mothering thoughts from the mom; scary flashback scene of a mom being obliterated 26 years earlier; and sort of stereotypical dad vs mom behavior...moms are strict, dads just wanna have fun. And one possibly negative message (that I quickly debunked w/my kids DURING the movie): the "movie" mom was abducted b/c she was strict and her son obeyed her. Moms whose kids were ill-behaved brats were safe. Bad message!
What other families should know:
Flag as inappropriate
Parent of 13 year old
March 12, 2011
This is the most disturbing kids' movie I've ever seen. I did not enjoy this movie at all.
Most disturbing was when Gribble was remembering how his mom had been killed by the aliens. This was shown through a series of flashbacks. Gribble was a kid and unable to save her.
The message of the movie was good, but the content leading to it was very heavy.
What other families should know:
Flag as inappropriate
Parent of 7 year old
March 12, 2011
Beware! Very Scary Themes!!
My son asked us to leave the theater 20 minutes into this film, which we willingly did because the movie was creepy. The characters are almost too real, and for sensitive kids (or most kids at this age, I'd think) the idea of a mom being taken away by aliens is too much. I'll admit I made a snap judgment to take him to this movie after seeing the 7+ rec. on CSM, and I didn't read the movie summary in advance - my mistake. But I think this 7+ age rating is way off base.
What other families should know:
Flag as inappropriate
Parent of 7 year old
March 13, 2011
YIKES!!! Unclear messages, parents MIGHT like, but it will scare kids!
Hated it. Messages were unclear, male Martians were portrayed as the huggers', they were stupid, partied, and relegated to the dump. Moms were too strict or...??? And the robots that were created to raise Martian children were shown as spanking the baby Martians. It was great 3-D, but an unbelievably bad movie for 7-8 year olds. My grandson thought the movie was a 'tear-jerker'. (My daughter also read the CSM 7+, without reading further.) I was so surprised that Joan Cusack agreed to portray motherhood in such a way. Maybe the editors deleted the message that mothers make rules that benefit the child and society...I don't know, it was a mess. My husband and I were groaning out loud. Role models were poor, I don't see how a 7 year old could learn that mothers are good from this movie! And our grandson has seen many movies that WE think weren't age appropriate. This one was one of the worst. We went to the 7pm show on the day after it opened, and the theatre was almost empty, we changed seats to try to accomodate the 3-D, and weren't disturbing a soul...there was no one else there!
What other families should know:
Flag as inappropriate
Your tween and younger may be very sad seeing the mom disappear.
This was a great movie, stressing the importance of mothers and fathers in a child's life. However, Gribble's mother is zapped with a memory gun and disappears (is killed) by the martians, just as he is trying to save her. This shocked me, and my son cried right there in the theater. No warning in any other reviews, so I was really surprised.
What other families should know:
Flag as inappropriate
Parent of 5 and 8 year old
April 8, 2011
I took my 5 year old boy, and my eight year old girl and her friend. They all thought is was super. I enjoyed it also.
Flag as inappropriate
I regret that I took my 7 year old daughter to this movie. She was scared most of the movie and did not like the mom being taken. I do not recommend taking your kids to see this. Read the other reviews toward the bottom of this page. They explain pretty well the problems with this movie: too scary, bad male female roles (males play too much and moms are too strict), mom dying flashback, mom abduction, and almost mom death.
What other families should know:
Flag as inappropriate
Parent of 7 year old
March 23, 2011
The computer animation was great. Part of the time I forgot I was watching animation. It was interesting to watch my son's reactions to different scences of the movies and discuss what his feelings and thoughts were afterward. I even heard him say how mean the mom was at the beginning of the movie when she made her son turn off his movie and go to bed because he lied and fed his broccoli to the cat instead of eating it himself. (BTW - the broccoli had made the cat sick - how Mom found out.) The movie is not really violent, but there are some scenes which involve laser guns, and when the Mom appears dead (I cried - it can be intense). There are also some wonderful messages in the movie and a few unlikely heroes. I do not believe I have ever seen my son on the edge of his seat like at this show.
What other families should know:
Flag as inappropriate
Best for Boys, Tweens of any gender and their parents..esp Moms
We thought this was a good movie. Depending on who you ask, there are differnt ratings of good. As the Mom, I think it was awesome-obviously. My teenage daughter enjoyed it and thought the best part was watching the behind the scenes at while the credits roled. She also thought the "hippie" theme was funny. It is probably not very entertaining for teenagers. Any time we go to the movies she enjoys it. As for my 10 yr old son, he was the only one reluctant to go. Ironically he ended up enjoying it almost as much as I did. He liked the action. I thought the language was pretty mild compared to the reviews I read for "Rango". (Which I originally planned to see until I read the reviews....WHAT WERE THEY THINKING?!) I rated this as educational because he actually got the moral of the movie. I also thought it was educational in that it showed the importance of family and how "technology" could be used improperly. As for the violence and peril....is it any better or worse than what happens to the parents in "Bambi, "The Lion King" and "Finding Nemo"?
What other families should know:
Flag as inappropriate
Parent of 4 and 8 year old
March 27, 2011
Glad I read the reviews and didn't trust the preview
(Spoiler alert) I thought the movie was fine, but only because I was able to prep my 5 year old son before hand that the mom doesn't die and it's all make believe. He did still worry that she was going to die during movie but a quick reminder that she will be OK and he was fine with seeing it through. Other then that, he and I thought the movie was cute, funny, exciting, and fun to watch. Had I believed the trailer I would have through it was all fun and games without the implications of death. Thank you to all the other reviewers and to common sense media for the advance review.
What other families should know:
Flag as inappropriate
Strange, Creepy and Basically Boring
Terrible movie, my 7 year old son was bored and my nine year old son thought it was creepy. Very strange movie and a waste of money. My husband and I both agree it was one of the worst movies we've ever taken our kids to.
What other families should know:
Flag as inappropriate
Parent of 6 year old
March 12, 2011
Definitely not for 7+, more 9+
I'm torn on this movie. The messages that children need families & the importance of love in our lives were great. But the scene where Gribble remembers his mother's death was really hard to watch.
What other families should know:
Flag as inappropriate
Parent of 4 and 7 year old
March 23, 2011
Not For Every Kid
My seven year has always been sensitive about movie and t.v. content and she was overwhelmed by this movie. Specifically the idea of having a mother stolen out of her bedroom at night and then being used for her maternal memory bank was too much. Especially the part in which "Gripple" retells his eye-witness experience of losing his own mother. My 4 year old was basically unaffected by the movie and said, "It wasn't even true!" But if you have a kid who is sensitive to loss, be careful.
What other families should know:
Flag as inappropriate
Parent of 6 and 8 year old
March 15, 2011
I liked the message that Moms are good, but my kids already know that. I took my 8 year old girl and she liked it, but it was very fast, a little confusing, parts were scary and sad. It definitely had heavy themes. She ended up on my lap in the middle of the show. I would not recommend it for anyone younger than 12.
What other families should know:
Flag as inappropriate