What a disappointment! This movie had so much potential -- It had a beautiful story for all faiths, stunning art, Tom Hanks' captivating voices, and a world of fantasy where truly great film could have happened. But once the Polar Express pulled out of the boy's neighborhood, it was a runaway train. The action scenes were so repetitive that by the umpteenth rollercoaster ride, I was wishing my watch had an illuminated dial. Some of the "exciting" scenes - featuring the train skidding across ice, cracking under its weight -- were terrifying to my children, who live in Alaska where cracking ice claims several lives each year -- but worse, these scenes were repeated so many times that I wondered why the producers couldn't find some other misadventures to fill up the time. The addition of a handful of characters (also a time-filler) worked about 50% of the time -- the ghost on top of the train was interesting to the over 13 set; younger kids didn't get it. The redneck engineers seemed out of place, and added nothing to the movie. The main characters worked, but the animation made the insides of their mouths black, which was creepy. The "poor kid" was a wonderful addition, but his character seems to have been given short schrift, so Tom Hanks's ghost could get more airtime. A shame, given the point of the story. Perhaps the most disappointing aspect of this movie was the music. What an opportunity there was, for a truly memorable score! Except for one sweet song sung by the lead female character - to a modestly successful background -- the score was as hollow as the animated characters' eyes. There was nothing that approached "Can You Feel the Love Tonite?" or "Colors of the Wind". The musical let-down was compounded toward the end of the movie, when Frank Sinatra-style Christmas songs were piped through loudspeakers in a deserted Santa Land. The sound was so eerie, and the scene so strange, I couldn't wait for Santa to load up the sleigh and take off. I wanted to get outa there. What a nightmare, indeed!
My almost-6-year old son loves this movie. Parts of it are a little too intense for his sister (age 3 1/2)--there are some suspenseful action sequences that she can't sit through. But all in all it's a wonderful film.
I read the book to my kids when they were younger, and they all loved it. So when we saw a trailer for this movie, we all rushed to the theater the day it came out. By the time the movie was over, we were all almost crying with disappointment. This movie is so unlike the book in so many ways.The conductor and waitors on the Polar Express break out dancing at random moments, there's a ghost on top of the train, and the movie doesn't explain how he got there or what his purpose is. Read the book, don't see the movie.
Way too scary for children. Besides the children getting on a train alone without parents, my child was really distressed when the little girl was taken away by the conductor because her ticket got lost, and then was even more frightened when the boy followed them and climbed up on top of the moving train. Turned it off at that point. Cool animation, but inappropriate for children. Should be rated PG.
My four-year-old girls watched this on Christmas eve with three-year-old brothers. All the kids but one of the girls loved it, and the exception found it to be scary. When I asked her what her objection was, she said, "I don't like the conductor yelling too much." Overall, there are some high-speed train scenes and intense moments that could be overwhelming to some young ones, but the message of faith and wonder is a beautiful one.
My son admitedly is too young for this movie at almost 3 but he loves it. He's enthralled with the train, the elves, and the idea of traveling to see Santa. The movie is sweet but does have disturbing scenes.
The children are celebrated for who they are and are encouraged to believe, lead, and trust.
This will be a classic in our home for years to come.
We have the book and my 3 year old daughter begged me to take her to see this. Before we went, based on feedback from many other parents, I sat her down and prepped her that the movie was "VERY SCARY" at times. We talked about what we would do if we were scared and she helped come up with solutions ("We'll go get popcorn", "I'll cover my eyes", etc.).
With the prepping she was just fine and very proud of herself that she wasn't too scared during what she viewed as the two scary parts ("the puppets and broken toys" and the "wolves"). In fact the only way I knew she was scared was the pause in popcorn chomping. It was a great mother/daughter event because I enjoyed it too. The animation, albeit a bit creepy (too human but not human enough), was technologically fascinating and who can dislike Tom Hanks?
I am so upset I let my kids watch this film. They have turned what should be a lovely holiday film into a creepy movie that will make your kids terrified of Santa, Elves and the North Pole. I myself will have nightmares tonight. How this got a G Rating is completely beyond me...obviously somebody paid off the rating agency so they could sell this fil
A beautifully animated, much embellished film adaptation of the well loved book. More than a little scary in places, and none of us got the point of the slightly menacing hobo on top of the fast-moving train?! Please, someone explain this one to us! Our 4-year-old was not completely at ease watching this, especially with the creepy old toys grabbing the boy, or the hobo shattering against the tunnel wall - brutal!
In my opinion the movie focussed more on the intense action packed scenes than on the actual message of Christmas, but it is a good fun family film to see in the run up to Christmas. Tom Hanks does a wonderful job with all the different characters he's lending his voice to.
My 2 year old had to see this movie TEN times in the theater and I never regretted a single screening. There was always something new to enjoy. The animation is extrodinary. The hairs and cloth seem so realistic, but beyond artistic excellence, this is really a fun film with refreshing storyline-- it's really something Joseph Campbell would have explored to analyze the archetypes a single person matures through to the journey of Faith (the soul), and it's easy to imagine because all the heros are performed by Tom Hanks-- from the boy, to the father, to the conductor, the vagabond hobo, the engineer and ultimately Santa. Some would say that Harry Potter holds the market on deep thought, but I must say that this film quietly has earned this golden award. Well done! Oh, but now that the DVD is out, I recommend that you buy the WIDESCREEN and NOT the TV formatted version.
Wow, this movie was amazing. Take your kids, even if they're sixteen! GO SEE THIS MOVIE - but there are some intense roller-coaster scenes that may not be for sensitive young children.
This Movie was awesome. The only thing I had a problem with was the hobo (spirit) That was always poping up. They could have made him real like everyone else. This movie is sure to be a favorite for years and years to come.
This movie was so good. I took my 5 1/2 year old daughter - she loved it! The graphics were so wonderful - it was like being in the book. I think the movie should have been rated PG though. On the train ride, there were a few parts that made us all jump.
Awesome movie. Will buy when it comes out.
Go see this with your whole family!
This is one of my kids' all time favorite books. I took my 2 oldest (7 & 5) on opening night. I didn't think my 3 year old would appreciate and I was right. My oldest loved it but I think a little bit was above his understanding since it expanded the storyline from the book and he's a young 7. My 5 year old definitely didn't get parts, but he loved the lonely boy storyline which didn't exist in the book. The dvd will definitely be on next year's wish list from the boys - and I think they'll be old enough to get it then. On another note - if you don't like the feel of roller coasters - take some dramadine. They did a great special effect with the train ride!! Overall, the movie is geared to the age that starts to doubt, but it reinforces some great social values that are appropriate for younger (4-7) children.
Family Favorite. If you haven't seen it yet, go to the store real quick and buy it! :)
Definite family favorite at Christmas. We would watch it all year long if we didn't impose a Christmas time only restriction. It gets packed away with our decorations every year and is the first movie we watch after putting our lights up. There is a lot you can discuss with your children with about character and the true gift of the season.