About our rating system
ON: Content is appropriate for kids this age.
PAUSE: Know your child, some content may not be right for some kids
OFF: Not age appropriate for kids this age

A safe community is important to us.
Please observe our guidelines.

All member reviews for The Secret of Roan Inish

lotterz
teen, 17 years old
 
I'm 14 and I LOVED IT!! :)
I am 14 years old and we watched the movie in my music class. I thought it was very nice and had great footage of Ireland. I would give it an 8 out of 10. My only complaint is that some of the shoots were a little bit long and it was hard to understand what the characters were saying at times.

foleywags
parent of 13 year old
 
Good for kids 12 and older who like more complex stories
I love this movie and my 12 year old liked it, too. It is slower paced and more like a "dream" movie where you have to let it all wash over you rather than expect it to be fast paced. Beautiful story, very enchanting; main character is a little girl who's very bold and independent in a quiet way. If you liked Whale Rider, you will probably like this movie.

RRRReviewer
kid, 11 years old
 
It's a FILM, not a movie
Love the seals and the girl is brave.

zoomdrm57
parent of 10 and 13 year old
 
Get the popcorn and enjoy!!
What a delightful magical well-done film! Just a great time for the family!! This is what movies should do for us!!

Ghillie
teen, 14 years old
 
Adorable
It is a beautiful family story. My brother and I absolutely love it. There is a drunk man, though, and pubs are depicted.

Grey
teen, 14 years old
 
wonderfull movie!! i was hooked all the way through!

barb42
adult
 
My favorite movie. Ever. Of all Time.
Our whole family really loves this movie. The performances are perfect, and the setting is stunning. Whenever we watch this, we long for and aspire to the simple, but important, ideals that Fiona and her family achieve.

somgop
parent of 9 and 13 year old
 
A delightful, wonderful tale of family triumph over tragedy. Beautifully crafted by John Sayles. Among the best movies for all ages.

CelticHeart
parent of 9 year old
 
Celtic legend brought to life
As American of Irish Heritage and a traditional Celtic musician, I loved that a classic Celtic fairy tale was brought to life in such a precious and compelling fashion. This is a family favorite and we even own the soundtrack. Give this a try for your next Saint Patrick's family time.

rgh
parent of and 8 , 11 , 13 year old
 
Beautiful Family Freindly Film
This film will hold the attention of people of most ages. It starts slow but steadily draws you in. My (sensitive) 9 year old was a little spooked when the selkie turned into a human, but it did not bother my 5 year old in the least, although the story may have been a little over his head.

 
One of the best
The films I seek out for my eight-year old daughter are ones that unfold at a leisurely pace, tell intriguing stories,have engaging characters and rich imagery. This film has all of those in spades. It's the antithesis of frantically paced hollywood "family" fare".This story is about living close to nature and involves magical creatures called "selkies", seals that take on human form and that occur in Irish and Scots folktales. There are a few scenes of peril, but they are mild by today's standards: a young baby floats to sea in a cradle and is thought to be lost, and an older child briefly goes adrift in a rowboat in a fog. One scene of a seal transforming into a woman might be mildly disturbing to some kids, but wasn't to my fairly sensitive daughter. The biggest obstacle for many kids would be the thick Irish brogues, which prompted the producers to provide English subtitles even though the film is in English. But my daughter followed things pretty well, and when she didn't, we just hit "pause" and did some explaining.All in all a great, great family film, enjoyed by the adults and the kid in our household equally and hugely.

irishwaters
kid, 12 years old
 
Wonderful culturally endorsed movie!!! :D FANTASTIC
I love this movie! The Secret of Roan Inish is a great movie to watch with family. Its a nice relaxing movie that gives off positive messages to viewers about loving your family as well as your surroundings. The whole movie is a wonderful, extremely cultural experience the whole family will enjoy! Besides a smoke on the pipe and extremely minor drinking one scene, THIS MOVIE IS A+