Shane (NR, 1953)

common sense media says

"Come back, Shane!" Classic Western for the ages.


parents & educators say

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that this is a serious-minded Western, not one of the charming but silly singing-cowboy fantasies that stampeded by the hundreds out of old Hollywood. Death is a serious thing here, and gunplay is realistic, not cartoonish or gratuitous. There's also a sense of the harshness of frontier life. The possibility of an adulterous love triangle is present but tastefully handled. Some viewers may be more troubled by the hints of Hollywood's longstanding Gone With the Wind sentimental representation of the Confederate South (the movie takes place shortly after the Civil War), or the equating of drinking whiskey with being a "real man."

Positive messages: Most characters take principled stands, putting their lives on the line for what they believe is right. But their hidden motivations result in violence. Shane tries to put his deadly past behind him, but gets dragged back into killing. He resists temptations to join the bad guys and have an affair. A supporting character is depicted (warmly) as a Confederate. Indians and other people of color are invisible.
Violence: Fistfights and shootings, many of the bullets turning out to be fatal. Director Stevens, a WWII veteran, was determined to keep the gunplay realistic -- not gory, but not harmless and cartoony either.
Sex: Only the modest indication that Mrs. Starrett is attracted to Shane.
Language: Not applicable.
Consumerism: Based on a popular (and equally fine) novel.
Drinking, drugs, & smoking: Whisky galore in a cowboy saloon, with Shane significantly humiliated, abused, and told he's not a "man" when he orders non-alcoholic stuff. Other characters get notably drunk.

More on Shane

What to talk about

Talk to your kids
Families can talk about how the characters seem unable to escape their social roles. Though it's not spelled out in detail, Shane is a veteran gunfighter trying to put his violent past behind him, but he winds up pulled back into killing, even if he is supposedly defending innocent people. Even the villains seem to be offering a last-minute compromise solution, which is declined. Did the conflict have to turn out the way it did? What do you think would have happened if Shane stayed with the Starretts?

What's the story?

What's the story?
Shortly after the Civil War, a traveler named Shane (Alan Ladd) lingers with a family of Wyoming homesteaders, the Starretts, who are in the thick of a land feud between settlers and cattle ranch boss Ryker (Emile Meyer) and his posse. Shane is never fully accepted by the suspicious settlers. Still, he stays with the Starretts, partially because of friendship with their little boy Joey (Brandon de Wilde) who idolizes him. There's also a developing love triangle with gun-loathing Mrs. Starrett (Jean Arthur) and a rivalry with her husband Joe Starrett (Van Helfin). Shane is obviously a veteran gunfighter and, to the farmers, no better than the thugs on Ryker's payroll, even as he (reluctantly) straps on his six-guns to defend against the villains. You'd think the settlers would be grateful, but (except for Joey) they aren't. Ryker eventually tries to negotiate a peace with Starrett, and the range boss has got a surprisingly strong argument that suddenly makes the farmers seem slightly less like poor victims and more stubborn and selfish.

Is it any good?

Is it any good?
 
A classic Western, Shane is based on a novel that's widely assigned in schools. This is a morally complex Western (not just white hats and black hats) that can play well for both the action fans and families seeking serious drama. Even though Westerns in general are nowhere near as popular and plentiful as they were in times past, this one is a must-see.

Shane functions on multiple levels for young viewers and parents, addressing questions of youthful idol-worship, adult redemption, the uses of violence, forbidden attraction, and people forced to live out unpopular roles against their wills.

Movie themes & details

Movie Details
Studio: Paramount Pictures
Director: George Stevens
Cast: Alan Ladd, Brandon de Wilde, Emile Meyer, Jack Palance, Jean Arthur, Van Heflin
Genre: Western
Run time: 118 minutes
Theatrical release: April 23, 1953
DVD release: August 15, 2000
MPAA Rating: NR

This review was written by Charles Cassady Jr.
 
 

Review It

 

Review Shane





Hang on! You need to be a member to post your review.
A safe community is important to us. Please observe our guidelines.
 

Most useful reviews by all members

zuzu2266
kid, 8 years old
 
The best movie ever
This is my FAVORITE movie even my name is Shane!!! I just cant stop seeing it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! the #1 movie for a kid who likes old film and thats ME

Katy0
teen, 17 years old
 
Classic
"Shane" is only tainted slightly by the overly pointed direction.

who3697cares
teen, 18 years old
 
As much as I like classic westerns, this one has been unbearable to sit through, but that is just me. Others may like it, and they have good reasons.

An independent voice for families
Age-appropriate reviews
 

vote now

Will you see Shane?


Already seen it? What do you think?

 

Great alternatives handpicked by our editors


About our rating system
ON: Content is appropriate for kids this age.
PAUSE: Know your child, some content may not be right for some kids
OFF: Not age appropriate for kids this age