Parent reviews for The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society

The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society Poster Image

Common Sense says

age 12+

Based on our expert review

Parents say

age 9+

Based on 5 reviews

Kids say

age 12+

Based on 5 reviews

age 9+

The movie is great - but the audiobook of the novel is truly extraordinary and complimentary

After watching this movie get the audiobook of it - a totally different and transporting experience. There is so much more in the audiobook which cannot be crammed into a movie - the feel of the 1940s, the horror of WWII, the humanity and the extraordinary power of a love of literature and books. The pictures the audiobook can paint in a mind are truly wonderful. And there is nothing to worry about in respect of bad language.

This title has:

Great messages
Great role models
1 person found this helpful.
age 12+

This title has:

Great messages
Great role models
age 8+

Such a great film!

Great romance and so much more. Interesting and clever plot. Finally a movie to watch with your family that does not offend personal values. So great. You will not be disappointed!

This title has:

Great role models
age 10+

Slow-paced writing overshadows intriguing storyline

Families should know that this extremely slow-placed, period-piece is about as clean as could be... A female publisher with her own war scars hears about a story of a once Nazi occupied town and goes there to write about the villagers. In all honesty, thats really all that happens. Considering the setting, [WWII and its aftermath], one might expect more Nazi violence and gore, but not so here. The story is fairly predictable, with minimal plot twists so younger children [pace and dialogue may lose 10 or younger viewers' interest] could easily follow along. There are some allusions to fornication; it is vaguely stated that a male character is gay. For parents of young children and tweens, this movie may be something of a God-send; no sex scenes or over the top swearing, very minimal violence [seen through flashbacks, if at all], yet with just enough mystery and romance to keep them intrigued. However, older audiences may find themselves bored with the movie's often sluggish pace, as well as disappointed with the waste of an otherwise clever war story as it is unfortunately buried underneath banal subplots. For a similar storyline suitable for older audiences [ONLY], one might consider, Island at War [2004, BBC].

This title has:

Great role models
age 8+

-"She's only four. how could she understand that?!" -"I'm older than time, and I still don't understand"

Warm, delightful, and so sweet. Maybe even be so sweet for its own good at the beginning. But no one can resist this movie's charm. Its cheerful and light-hearted tone may make you think you're watching Paddington! The Guernsey Literary & Potato Peel Pie Society is also a well-made film. It has a great performances, specially from Penelope Wilton as Amelia who has some of the movie's most powerful lines. Yes, this movie is also has some very strong lines that could stick in your head. But they are even more powerful when you're invested in the characters. Mike Newell used only the flashback technique to unravel the story of the titular society, and there's no doubt he could have taken a riskier and more challenging way to do so. But the result is nothing short of impressive. I always wanted to know more and more about the members and their story, and I loved how I was getting minor details piece by piece like I was collecting a jigsaw puzzle. I cared about all the side characters. Thanks to the solid script, each one of these characters was so intriguing to know about. But I would Juliet Ashton, our protagonist, is well-wrought character as much as the minor characters. Don't get me wrong, I cared about the character so much, and her romantic sub-plot and relationships in the story, but it's her background that I found unfulfilling and half-baked. We didn't get to know anything about her past, except from a very very short, and poorly-shot flashback at the beginning. But it's not just because the fact I felt it's unsatisfying that the main character lacks a well-established background, it's also because I did need that at some point in the movie. That being said, Lily James delivered a nice performance, and she was as charming as always. There are also some things that I think are a bit hard to swallow. Things like "I don't know exactly how he, or she knew about that but let's go on anyway." The movie looks gorgeous in general. It has a beautiful cinematography, a decent the production design, and top-notch costume design that fits perfectly the movie's setting. Also, I loved the music, and it's also as traditional as the movie itself. (7.5/10)

This title has:

Great messages
Great role models
Too much drinking/drugs/smoking