Shepherded to Montauk for the wedding of their good friend Greg (
Mark Feuerstein), married-but-aimless David (David Harbour), tightly-wound banker Ted (Alexander Chaplin), crunchy-granola existentialist Spooner (Chris Bowers), is-he-gay Will (Samrat Chakrabarti), recently divorced lawyer Richard (Reg Rogers), and blissfully unquestioning reality-TV producer Steven (
David Alan Basche) gather for one special performance of their old a capella group. As the wedding day nears, the guys complain endlessly about not getting enough sex and obsess over Steven's sexy Swedish nanny, Elsa (Camilla Thorsson). The pals also recall the glory years of college, when life was rife with possibility and adventure. So what's their beef? David's wife, Dana (
Rosemarie DeWitt), wants a baby, which makes him feel like his life is over. Ted can't stand his hostile wife, Trish (
Molly Shannon; Richard's marriage just imploded after he cheated on his wife; and nearly everybody else is down on life, too.