Beyond Catfights: TV That's Good for Girls

Do you remember when you were a kid, about 9 or 10, and your best friend was everything to you? You'd stay up late during sleepovers, play silly games, and concoct crazy stories about your future? And then one day, you grew up, and you threw a glass of champagne in her face for calling your sequined cocktail dress ugly. Wait ... what?

If we believe the stories that so many TV shows tell us about female friendship, this scenario would seem wholly realistic. From America's Next Top Model and Dance Moms to The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills, girls are portrayed as competitive, backstabbing rivals who overreact to every perceived slight.

And it's not just reality shows that reinforce the stereotype that women can't get along. Scripted teen favorites like Gossip Girl and The Secret Circle regularly pit so-called friends against each other. Most of us grown-ups can see through the hype of TV shows that amp up the drama -- shows that egg on the competition, poking the camera into the melee, just hoping for the perfect catfight. But what kind of message is this girl-fight mentality sending to young women who are still trying to figure out their place in the world?

It's an unsettling message, that's for sure, one that undermines the support that real female friendships can provide.

And while networks pump up the drama to attract viewers, there are lots of shows that don't wallow in the negative. You can counteract iffy messages by reminding kids and teens what friends can achieve together. Also, point out when shows go for cheap entertainment with tired stereotypes. And finally, choose entertainment that sends a better message to your kids. Here are our favorite weapons against girl hate.

SciGirls , 7+ (PBS) -- This science-oriented educational show highlights girls working together to construct or develop experiments to learn about the world around them. Girls encourage and have fun together while modeling enthusiasm for science.

iCarly, 8+ (Nickelodeon) -- This hugely popular tween sitcom might not be the most realistic, but Carly and Sam are good friends, even though their relationship isn't always perfect. Though they do sometimes compete with each other, they also stand up for each other, and some touching moments highlight how valuable female friendships can be.

Jem and the Holograms, 8+ (Hub) -- A flashy animated series from the 1980s and now reairing on The Hub, this group of rock star women play music and battle meanies as a team.

Picker Sisters, 10+ (Lifetime) -- These interior designers travel the country looking for odd junk that they can transform into boutique-friendly best-sellers while demonstrating how well two women can work together. Their enthusiasm for each other and their work is infectious and positive.

Tia & Tamera, 13+ (Style) -- Real-life sisters go through ups and downs as they navigate different stages of their lives, but in the end they're always there for each other.

Buffy the Vampire Slayer, 13+ (DVD) -- This is an oldie but goodie that never fell victim to silly stereotypes about female friendships. Buffy and Willow are best friends through thick and thin, and even Buffy's female rivals don't fight her over a man -- but rather over the survival of the world.

2 Broke Girls, 14+ (CBS) -- The latest girl-buddy show (aimed at adults, but OK for mature teens) trades a few barbs between the female leads, but ultimately this odd couple shows that being different doesn't mean being rivals.

Parks and Recreation, 14+ (NBC) -- Amy Poehler and Rashida Jones are hilarious and realistic as friends/co-workers who encounter all sorts of wacky scenarios. Their friendship shows that they can stand by each other, even if they sometimes disagree. That's what real friendship is, right?

Add comment

Login or register to post comments

Comments

02.12.2012
Good list. Girls off or on the TV are always getting into Cat fights, even over something as silly as a boy. Live your life, Girls!
MonicaMom 02.17.2012
I haven't seen any of the shows except for "2 Broke Girls", and I would not recommend that show! In my opinion, the worst thing about it is the racism. I don't know why in the world Common Sens Media would recommend it at all for anyone, let alone teenage girls. Better get advice about the show from these links instead: *://*vancouversun*/entertainment/Broke+Girls+offensive/6001732/story.html *://*balancingjane*/2012/01/2-broke-girls-lets-talk-about-racism-on.html *://*tvline*/2012/01/2-broke-girls-crude-racist-humor/
jp523 02.21.2012
I would also mention My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic as a good addition to this list, as it is a show centering around friendships within a group of girls, and while there is often conflict, the bonds of friendship always endure through these trials. It also is genuinely entertaining (in most cases), and provides strong role models without being too preachy.
oporst 03.01.2012
Hoof-bump
CaryMom 03.01.2012
I watched Two Broke Girls just once and that was enough! I nearly cancelled my cable subscription as a result, simply because there is a risk my 9 year old girl might over hear the trash those two broke girls were spewing! It was raunchy TV at its worst and nothing any teenager needs to be watching. I'm stunned and disappointed CommonsenseMedia would suggest it. Bad call!
Sassy18 03.02.2012
Seriously, I am pretty permissive with my 13 1/2 year old but this 2 Broke Girls show is offensively crude. TOO many references to sexual acts, promiscuous attitudes, and the minorities represented are stereotyped. Terrible show unless you are an adult who finds this entertaining. Would not even want my older teen to watch this if I had one.
Jessie rocks 03.02.2012
Yeah. I think that TV shows a litte too much of the "friends" who don't get along as far as girls go. It's no WONDER teen girls feel they're supposed to ditch the other girls so much.
Big Time Mom 03.02.2012
First of all, this column is a repeat of one that was posted last September. I know, because I wrote directly to CSM expressing my concern over one of the choices (never heard back). While in general I am in full agreement that female friendships are portrayed as vicious and backstabbing on TV - and that this is a sending the wrong message to our children - I absolutely have to object to iCarly as being on the list of shows that send a positive message. For several years I banned iCarly in my home because I was disturbed by the way Carly and Sam poke fun at other people. Although I cannot recall any particular episodes, I do remember thinking that their antics bordered on cruel. Recently I saw some newer episodes and it does appear as if this element of meanness has toned down a bit, but since older episodes are still aired along with the new ones, I am still not a fan. I also am disturbed by their being no true adults in the home, and that almost all adults are portrayed in a negative light on this show. Is this really the best you could find for my daughter to watch?
diaryofamommy 03.02.2012
While I may not have a daughter, my son watches a few of the shows on this list like "iCarly" and I find them harmless. 2 Broke Girls is a hilarious treat for me, but not something I'd let an 11-year-old watching, son or daughter.
03.02.2012
Mabey because girls are mean, backstabbing people. I hate to break it to the world but girls are horrible to eachother, and I don't know if it has anything to do with the media or not, but girls can never get along! There always has to be drama, or cliques.