Great book and great reading. Great story that lets kids get absorbed into a fantasy world that is built around them in classic language and artistry that is CS Lewis. The CommonSense reviewer ...
concernedNAparent’s profile

- Pennsylvania
- 2 kids: ages 6, 11
What My Kids Love Now
House Rules
When the Kids Are Asleep…
My Biggest Challenge Is:
Titles You’ve Reviewed

Book: The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe
I rate this titleonand give itAnother reason to question the ConnonSense reviewers

Book: Among the Hidden (Shadow Children, Book 1)
I rate this titleoffand give itNot age appropriate for 9 yrs -- maybe 14?
Not sure how this rated OK for 9 yr olds, but the scene when kids are killed and they have to mop up the blood before tourists come through the White House is disturbing. NOT for 9 yr olds - maybe ...

Book: The Giver
I rate this titleoffand give itNot appropriat efor 11 yr olds - maybe 15 yr olds
This site is not looking at the content if it thinks this book is OK for 11 year olds/5th graders. The 2 objectionable parts are sex and infanticide. Sex: This is not appropriate imagery for 11 ...
