YouTube (http://www.youtube.com/)

common sense media says

Vast video site entertains and educates; iffy stuff abounds.


parents & educators say
  • 42% say language is an issue
  • 38% say sexual content is an issue

What parents need to know

Parents needs to know that there are many videos on YouTube that may not be age-appropriate for their kids. The site is entirely user-generated and relies on its community to flag videos that violate YouTube's terms of service (mostly for sexual content, language, and hate speech). Plenty of age-inappropriate content can be surfaced by typing in the most innocent of search terms, so parents will want to monitor kids' use. Videos here run the gamut, from commercial to educational to music videos to homemade clips. Many kids love YouTube and rely on it as a way of keeping up with popular culture; videos go "viral" when viewers share the clips they like. One of the web's most popular destinations for people of all ages, YouTube now curates its videos, suggesting clips and new "channels" based on what you've watched previously. Kids can also discover new videos by seeing what's popular and trending throughout its immense collection. These new features can easily increase the amount of time your kids spend on the site. YouTube does offer parents the ability to filter out objectionable content and comments using Safety Mode. However, Safety Mode doesn't catch everything, and it's easy to disable.

Educational value: Although YouTube is designed to entertain more than anything, there are plenty of educational and informative videos to be found. But because videos are not prescreened and can be posted by anyone, parents may want to view them first to ensure they are age appropriate.  
Positive messages: This immense site is a mixed bag. There are definitely positive messages to be found, and by design, YouTube encourages creativity and sharing (its tagline is "Broadcast Yourself."). But you will come across negative messages, stereotypes, poor role models, and inappropriate comments and content interspersed with the good.
Violence: Violent content exists (including some anime, movie trailers, video game scenes, and music videos) and sometimes users' comments are less than tame. Still, there are plenty of videos that are violence-free. YouTube has a Safety Mode that should block some inappropriate content, but it was easy to disable during our review.
Sex: Because there's such a wide variety of content in general, sexual images, innuendo, and comments exist in various places (including music videos, which are popular viewing for teens and tweens). Porn videos cannot be viewed without logging in, but it's not difficult to lie about your age to get an account, and porn-like videos can be found even if they're not labeled as such. YouTube has a Safety Mode that should block some inappropriate content, but it was easy to disable during our review.
Language: There's no shortage of lewd and crude language on YouTube. It's prevalent within certain videos and frequently found in the user comments section. Of course, there are just as many clean, wholesome, helpful comments. However, curse words and inappropriate language can be filtered out or hidden by enabling the site's Safety Mode, although Safety Mode was not difficult to disable during our review.
Consumerism: Ads of all kinds appear on every page and are even embedded at the bottom of each video you're viewing (though they can be clicked on to close). Some ads are iffy, and clicking on them can lead you off YouTube and onto other sites. Marketers often use YouTube to promote their movies, music videos, products, and more. Users may indicate their ad preferences (but not disable ads) in settings.
Drinking, drugs, & smoking: There are references to all kinds of substances in some of the videos as well as within the user comments. Enabling the site's Safety Mode helps filter out much of it, although Safety Mode was not difficult to disable during our review.
Privacy & safety: YouTube raises potentially serious privacy concerns. Anyone can access YouTube, but you must be 13 or over to create your own account or channel (necessary for uploading your own videos). Creating your own channel enables you to keep your videos completely closed to anyone but selected friends if you choose. But it's also easy to share (and over-share) if you choose. Beginning in March 2012, Google plans to track users across its services, including YouTube. When you're logged into YouTube, your search information is collected and follows you to other Google services, such as Gmail and Picasa. You cannot opt out of this data-sharing. YouTube has a Safety Mode that allows parents to filter out potentially objectionable content, including videos with age restrictions and mature content. It also hides comments on videos and replaces most inappropriate language with symbols. Opt in to this Safety Mode, and that objectionable content will not show up in video search, related videos, playlists, shows, and movies. Lock in Safety Mode and it will always filter content on that account in a particular browser (otherwise, you'll need to enable Safety Mode every time you log in). However, Safety Mode was easy to disable during our review, and YouTube acknowledges that no filter is 100 percent accurate.

More on YouTube

What to talk about

Talk to your kids

Is it any good?

Is it any good?
 

YOUTUBE.COM has easily secured its place in pop culture, primarily because it offers so much to discover -- and love -- in this comprehensive video library. Information. Education. Instruction. Entertainment. Distraction. Delight. Want step-by-step guided instructions for making dozens of different styles of friendship bracelets? Need to know how to create a unique Halloween costume? Want to show your child what the robot from Lost in Space looked like or check out the Earth's solar system? You'll find that and much, much more here, including the latest viral videos of that kid or cat that everyone's laughing about. The beauty of YouTube is being able to see so much in one place at any given time. That, however, also makes it difficult to know what your kids are finding and viewing when you're not supervising. Yes, YouTube provides an endless source of useful information. But like other Internet search engines, it is also rife with questionable content and inappropriate user comments that are easy for computer-savvy kids to find and view.

What makes YouTube such an innovative site is its usefulness as a creative outlet for kids and adults alike. Homemade movies -- from silly to serious and everything in between -- are commonplace, and innovative video creations are easy to find. It's not only a place to experience and enjoy the creativity of others, but also a place to exercise your own.


This review was written by Conny Coon
 
 

Review It

 

Review YouTube





Hang on! You need to be a member to post your review.
A safe community is important to us. Please observe our guidelines.
 

What parents & educators say

12
Based on 210 parent & educator reviews:
  • 42% say language is an issue
  • 38% say sexual content is an issue
  • 31% say violence is an issue
  • 29% say there are positive messages
  • 29% say it's educational

Most useful reviews by all members

robinrunner
teen, 14 years old
 
viewers should stay cautious
Youtube can be an educational place or a place to get information through video. The only problem is anyone can upload one, with whatever innopropriate content they'd like. And once you see something through your eyes, it's hard to get out of your brain

gir8
kid, 12 years old
 
It depends on what you watch
Youtube is a good website, but is it inaproppiate? It really depends on what you watch. If your a parent and think that your child is looking up inaproppiate stuff on Youtube, then watch them the next time they're on. Other than that, it's an awesome website!!!!!

icarlyloverforever
kid, 11 years old
 
Wrong! Wrong! WRONG!
OK the common sense people are wrong. I know for a fact that youtube should be for age 10+. And it can't be iffy for 13 to ages 15. It should be inappropriate for ages 6 and under, iffy for 7 to 9, then age appropriate for ages 10+ OK so I cleared it up. Now I hope they take my advice and do what I say. They are very wrong.

AnimeGirl-Nikki
teen, 15 years old
 
I say that it's okay for tweens and up, but you should use your own judgement when it comes to your own kid
Youtube has been one of my favorite sites to visit and submit things to since I found out about it in '07. Just like the site's motto, Youtube is a place where you can 'Broadcast Yourself'. You can find educational, entertaining, and even inspirational videos on this site. However, like any site that has user-submitted material, there are some inappropriate things. Language in some videos and the comments of videos isn't always the cleanest. The content of certain videos may be violent or sexual. One of the good things is is the fact that you can use the Safety Mode feature to turn off anything that you don't want to be shown. And even if you don't use the Safety Mode, many videos that are overtly violent or sexual aren't available to users under 18. (Of course, people can lie about their age on their account, but if you set up the account with your child, you can ensure that this doesn't happen.)You can also flag or report videos that you may find offensive or inappropriate, and Youtube actually takes this into consideration and has actually suspended or shut down people on the site for posting the bad material. But all in all, Youtube is a great site to connect with other people who share your interests, entertaining yourself, and 'Broadcasting Yourself'.

c0nFuS3d
teen, 14 years old
 
Uhmm.... over reacting much??
It all depends on the the parent!! Some times people post videos that are "iffy" but other times, its just fine. When you search you can find both good AND bad videos The thing is, if you have a youtube channel and post videos about anything, be ready to have haters (aka people who leave bad comments on page) especially about certain beliefs. In the end, it depends on the parent because, they have to trust they taught their children right from wrong. Some of my friends love watching innappropriate vids, but I leave the room when they start to. I also live in constant fear that if I click something on accident, my parents may see it. Another thing I advise, staying up-to-date with the history of the computer. That way, your kid knows and will watch what he or she clicks on.

nsvv
teen, 14 years old
 
Loads of great content and loads of bad content: only for mature children.
You've certainly heard all about YouTube, so there's no need to describe what it is. YouTube has got an incredible amount of fantastic, entertaining and educational user content, but this is balanced by a large amount of more inappropriate user content. You can't put an age rating on it because it depends on your child's maturity. If you trust them and know that they are sensible enough to make good decisions, by all means let them use it as it is an incredible invaluable resource. However, if you suspect that your child will negatively exploit it, keep it banned.

 
The main reviewer is an idiot
Reviewing this site is pretty dumb, the material on this site is whatever the other users wish to put up with the exception of nudity. There's nothing to stop users from using profanity but there is a profanity guard available in video options so that isn't a problem. There's pedophiles on the site so don't let your children run a blog.

iliketurtles45
kid, 11 years old
 
The safety mode isn't very accurate. I once had SAFETY MODE on and I accidentally watched a video with the f-bomb in it. Way to go for making dad ground me for a week, Youtube.

beckzzy
teen, 14 years old
 
I Started Using It When I Was About 9 I Luv It Too Much

teamjacobgirl2.0
teen, 17 years old
 
Stop overreacting parents!
YouTube is one of those websites that is 100% unavoidable. Everyone has been on YouTube and even thought some comments\videos are going too far with drugs and things like that parents can't stop their kids from going on. I think YouTube is easy to get around and its fun to sit and watch weird and random videos. Defentily a great site and parents shouldn't overreact.

angelostar
kid, 12 years old
 
youtube isnt that bad I go on it every day I just choose not to go on anything bad

labtop909
parent of 10 year old
 
I don't know
I can't say I love this website or that I hate it. The good thing is that it inspires children to be creative. Creativity is something all children need but CAN get better sources of it in other places. Alot of bad languge, sexual behavoir and other inoproproit things have popped up on youtube. One time, my four year old got on youtube all by herself. She clicked a random vidio becouse she saw Rudolph the red nosed deer becouse she likes him. It turned out to be a gory horor.She was scared out of her mind and ran to me. She showed me this clip.I banned her from the internet for a while. Although in this case youtube has been unsafe, my sister bought a sofywear that block inopproproit content. Youtube can either be terrible or great.

Cooldee
parent
 
Be careful of bad talk!
I love Youtube, but there is alot of swearing, violence, and bullying. Block Youtube for ages younger than 13!

mr.travis
parent of and 4 , 7 , 10 year old
 
WAY too many wildcards on youtube
There is a smuttiness prevalent on youtube that ultimately has made it off-limits to my kids. Example: a friend forwarded a funny Christmas video showing costumed monks presenting the "Hallelujah Chorus," silently using signs. As soon as it was finished, up come the suggested videos, one of which is entitled "the 12 gays of Christmas." I didn't watch that one - maybe it was funny too - but I surely didn't care to explain to by children age 8, 6 and 3 what the title might mean. So even when I'm in territory on youtube that seems kid safe, it seems somewhere on the page there something about (actual examples again) "how to shoot up heroin" or something about oral sex techniques. I have posted several videos to youtube and been disappointed and often shocked at the abusive, sexual language left as comments, even though the videos were of my small children and were posted simply for their grandparents to see. (We're not posting any family videos to youtube any longer.) There seems to be a poisonous misanthropy among youtube users - or at least among commenters - that to me is starting to feel like the lingua franca of the web in general. Based on experience in the last year I'm starting to find the web an unsafe place for kids overall. Maybe these problems will be addressed by the new safety feature. It will be hard to convince me, though. With the exception of text content, it seems to me that safety features will rely on user-provided tags and flags. As I have said, I don't have a lot of faith in youtube users as advocates for children. As for quality, it's a phenomenal challenge to find content of genuine merit. Flippant fun is what we find primarily. All this was a lot more fun before we had children. Now comes responsibility... sigh.

unixworm
parent of 18 year old
 
shut it down!

goodperson4
teen, 14 years old
 
kids aint pervs
kids shouldnt be perverted to look bad stuff up

leku200
parent of and 3 , 5 , 10 , 13 , 15 year old
 
Can be helpful, sinful, and just plain weird!
If you or your kid plays video games it's likely that you've watched some gameplay, walkthoughs, ect. Almost every single video from the main gaming video suplier, Machinima, it's loading with language. Usally the gamers making the video compare video games with sexual content. "Those two games are my whores that I ride while waiting for my princess to come home...." Whatever game they were talking about followed. Stuff like that usally is in gaming videos on Youtube from Machinima. BUT, there is A TON of perfectly fine channels with funny videos or whatever else you were looking for. I havn't scene a single porn video availble on Youtube, the owners of Youtube are great and keeping that stuff off of the site. Anyways, it's really just a guessing game when it comes to the content of the video. Hope this helped!

drmwelsh
parent
 
When using the new filter make sure you turn the filter on for every web browser on your computer (Explorer, firefox). Turning it on using explorer does not turn it on for firefox. Also, make sure to log on and save and lock your setting. Finally, you also have to log back out to finalize the deal. This filter should be a opt-out system in order to keep more kids safe!

 

personpersonperson
teen, 16 years old
 
good,but check what ur child is veiwing
its a good site for videos,just dont let your children watch nasty videos.my only concern is there IS alot of violence even though the review says there isnt,i have seen ALOT of bloody crap.also the pop out videos ,those still scare the crap outta me.

An independent voice for families
Age-appropriate reviews
 

vote now

Will you visit YouTube?


Already visited it? What do you think?

 

Great alternatives handpicked by our editors


About our rating system
ON: Content is appropriate for kids this age.
PAUSE: Know your child, some content may not be right for some kids
OFF: Not age appropriate for kids this age