All member reviews for Stormchaser: The Edge Chronicles, Book 2

About our rating system

  • ON: Content is age-appropriate for kids this age.
  • PAUSE: Know your child; some content may not be right for some kids.
  • OFF: Not age-appropriate for kids this age.
  • NOT FOR KIDS: Not appropriate for kids of any age.

Find out more

Quality

Our star rating assesses the media's overall quality.

Find out more

Learning ratings

  • Best: Really engaging, great learning approach.
  • Very Good: Engaging, good learning approach.
  • Good: Pretty engaging, good learning approach.
  • Fair: Somewhat engaging, okay learning approach.
  • Not for Learning: Not recommended for learning.
  • Not for Kids: Not age-appropriate for kids; not recommended for learning.

Find out more

Common Sense Media says

Violent, overlong entry in imaginative Edge series.

Age(i)

2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17

Quality(i)

 

Users say

(out of 6 reviews)
AGE
10
QUALITY
 
Review this title!
Kid, 11 years old July 14, 2010
AGE
12
QUALITY
 

Boon's rating

Gets very gory as it goes on. not for kids. (cute charcters that you can get atached to die)
What other families should know
Too much violence
Too much drinking/drugs/smoking
Teen, 13 years old Written bycatwiz97 October 11, 2009
AGE
9
QUALITY
 

Great for Adventerous People

It was a great, easy read for me. I loved it and am finishing off the series.
What other families should know
Too much violence
Great messages
Great role models
Teen, 14 years old Written byCSM Screen Name... April 9, 2008
AGENot rated for age
QUALITY
 

I would have given it 3.5 stars but the choice was between 3 & 4 so 4 it is

I thought this book was disgusting, the whole thing with toe taking was kind of sick for a children's book.
Adult Written byVarisLoddsWife July 8, 2014
AGE
8
QUALITY
 

Please stop underestimating your children

I read this book, and others in the series, when I was approximately eight years old and I can honestly say that no other series of child/young adult novels has had a more significant or beneficial impact on my life. The Edge Chronicles are rich, inventive, bursting with imagination and deal maturely with complex issues in a manner engaging for children. The hand-wringing over the violence in this book completely misses the point and is honestly quite sad. Children are not as fragile as parents like to believe, they are able to process and deal with violence within fiction often in manners far more mature than many adults, and dealing with these difficult themes within a fantasy context allows them a "safe space" as it were to come to terms with the harsh realities of life, from which, one way or another, their parents will ultimately never be able to shield them. What's the quote again? "Children already know there's a monster under the bed; stories teach them that the monster can be slain". I feel in cases such as this, that is an important adage to keep in mind. Back to the book itself... firstly, the accusations of Stormchaser being "overlong" are actually quite ridiculous, and I can't even think of where they're coming from. If an adult reader is bored by the book and as such perceives it as being "overlong" then all well and good for them, but I was under the impression that this site was aimed at gauging what a child or teenager would enjoy. This is the demographic that can lap up the entirety of Harry Potter 5 in a single sitting and love every moment of it; I really don't think conciseness is an issue for any child reader. Also, literally every paragraph of that book adds to the plot, there is no extraneous scenes there at all. Concerning the morality and the "message" of this story... "children can explore themes of good and evil in this book" really, really doesn't cover it. In fact, "good versus evil" can't even be said to be relevant in this book, with the exception of Vilnix Pompolnius, the primary antagonist. Even then, his motivation- discovering how to produce more phraxdust and so provide the people of Undertown with clean water- can be viewed in a somewhat sympathetic light, particularly given his status as an outsider in a classist, highly conservative society. As for the character of Screed, the cause of most other reviewers' distress over this book... to consider him "evil" is an incredibly shallow reading of a highly complex character. In the character of Screedius Tollinix we find an incredibly cynical yet highly necessary deconstruction of the easy, comfortable tropes all too common in fiction and reality- that duty and dedication to a cause are moral ideas in and of themselves and that the the truest of intentions and the noblest of causes can never lead an individual towards a moral wrong. This deconstruction is further subverted by the fact that Screedius' immoral actions ultimately *do* end up saving the city of Sanctaphrax. Sanctaphrax, as portrayed in Stormchaser, can itself be considered a highly complex moral quandary- a city of immense beauty and knowledge and aspiration, yet also of decadence, cruelty and prejudice. A city which feeds off Undertown below it, and the labour of the common people, the parasitic imagery compounded by the fact that the stormphrax delivered there by Twig at the end (ultimately saving the city) is literally gained at the expense of the lives of thousands of innocent people. Furthermore, at the end of the book, while the overthrow of Vilnix, the vicious tyrant, is clearly a positive event, both the manner of his death and the fact that the city is then returned to the old-school order of overly-traditional and myopically privileged academics, with no real ethical evolution of Sanctaphrax society taking place. While this moral message may seem too cynical and depressing, it is vital for young people to explore literature where morality is not always clear-cut and ambiguity is celebrated. The ability to think critically about the actions and motivations of characters is an essential lesson which can be gained easily and safely from fiction before needing to be applied to the real world. Furthermore, it is easy to argue that a certain level of cynicism is revoked by Twig's act of selflessness at the end of the book- as the sole possessor of the secret to making phraxdust he could easily have exploited the vulnerable people of Undertown, but instead he chose to share the secret with Undertown residents, thus ensuring safe water for all. This, and other aspects of the novel, can be considered to have a strong anti-industrialist and anti-capitalist theme- the environmental message of the Edge series rarely comes through clearer than it does when discussing the issue of the production of chains for Sanctaphrax and the pollution of the Edgewater river as a result of this. The unsustainable nature of such industry and the corruption and vested interest of both the academics and, most importantly, the leaguemasters (who can be thought of as a metaphor for the way in which government and the corporate world are heavily entwined, to the detriment of the common people) is made all too clear. Young people can use the messages in this book to explore these very pressing real-world issues and to decide how they would (or, should I say, *will*) react when faced with such issues. Will they act like the professors of light and darkness, clinging to the old traditions and ignoring the real world in favour of ivory-tower abstractions, or like Vilnix Pompolnius and Splytho Spleethe and pragmatically carve a place out for themselves in a changing world, despite signs that their actions are equally unsustainable? Or will they take the route of Twig, and seek to do only what is right, refusing to be taken advantage of while still ensuring that the helpless and the innocent are protected and provided for? That is the ultimate moral lesson in Stormchaser, and one which every child would stand to learn. Refuse to let your child read this book for fear of violence if you must, but at least be aware of what you are depriving them of.
What other families should know
Educational value
Great messages
Great role models
Adult Written byscreedius July 8, 2014
AGE
8
QUALITY
 

But Let's Actually Examine the Book...

I will praise every novel of The Edge Chronicles to the end of the Earth because each of them has complex characters, amazing plots, a broad world, and beautiful illustrations. Every one of those books pulls you in. Each one has a different tone and feel and once you’re done reading one you can’t help but want to know more about the world and characters. Stormchaser makes you question things you never thought you would question. Makes you think, makes you wonder. It calls up the adventurer in all of us and inspires us to be just that little bit better. Because if Twig can survive stormchasing, Slyvo Slpeethe, the Twilight Woods, and the Mire, then we can pull ourselves out of bed and we can face the world. Because no matter how bad things get there Twig finds a way to make the best of his situation. In addition it provides insightful commentary on the dangers of unchecked industrialization and its effect on the environment as well as social classes. The inclusion of Screed Toe-Taker in the novel is vital, not only for plot and character progression, but to drive that message home. Okay in order to properly discuss Screed Toe-Taker we must explore what the Mire is. As described by Paul Stewart the Mire is, “[…] a stinking, polluted place, rank with the slurry from the factories and foundries of Undertown […].” As any environmentalist (myself included) will tell you, factory sludge is dangerous and nearly always toxic in some way. And Screed Toe-Taker is the shining example of said dangers. There is no better way that the author could have portrayed just how toxic of an environment the Mire was without the inclusion of Screed. Without Screed the rest of the book and, in fact, the rest of the series could not take place. He is an integral part of the world and his story should not be glossed over because of his descent into madness. I highly recommend that everyone read Stormchaser, and indeed the entirety of The Edge Chronicles. All of the books carry such important messages and such incredible plots and characters.
What other families should know
Educational value
Great messages
Great role models
Parent of a 1 year old Written bythensch September 19, 2012
AGE
11
QUALITY
 

Disappointed in the amount of violence

I would definitely agree that this was disappointingly violent. I've actually read the whole series and can say that the books continue in that vein. They are wonderfully imaginative and quirky, but it was surprising to me the amount of violence and how gruesome some of it was. The books seemed too bloodthirsty for kids.
What other families should know
Too much violence