Common Classroom: The Common Sense Education Blog

Should Teachers Change How They Teach Media Savvy Kids?

Kelsey Herron Blogger Categories: Research & Studies
Blogger

Our survey on the impact of digital media on students begs the question: Is it educators’ teaching styles or youth’s habits that need to change?

In May 2012 we surveyed 685 middle and high school teachers to hear their perspectives on how students’ increasing use of digital media has affected their academic performance. Although some questions garnered more varied results than others, 71 percent of those surveyed agreed that entertainment media use—which includes television, music, video games, texting, iPods, cell phone games, computer programs, social networking sites, apps, online videos, and websites students use for fun—has had negative effects on students’ attention span. Among the various forms of media that today’s youth are consuming, educators pointed to texting and video games as the most troublesome, and distractibility and instant gratification as the biggest culprits.

“Students have been both helped and hurt by the instant access to information. Being able to ‘Google’ answers to questions provides much quicker access, but it also makes students less comfortable wrestling with uncertainty or curiosity,” said one elementary school teacher who took part in the survey, available in full online. “The instant rewards of video games have made activities that require depth of commitment much harder for the kids,” said another participating middle school math teacher.

Many teachers voiced that, not only do they have to work harder to gain, and maintain, students’ attention, but that being an “entertainer” is now a part of their everyday job. “I have to do a song and dance to capture their attention,” said English teacher of 14 years Hope Molina-Porter to Matt Richtel of the New York Times. “I’m tap dancing all over the place,” agreed fourth grade teacher Dave Mendell. “The more I stand in front of class, the easier it is to lose them.”

It’s important to keep in mind that the results are merely a gauge of teachers’ insights and not a rigorous study of cause and effect. “However,” as the survey team notes, “it does surface some important and broadly held concerns of the nation’s teachers.”

This balance between entertainment and engagement appears to be the crux of the issue. It’s no surprise that many teachers who have more experience in the classroom are reporting a change in learning styles. The technological advancements we’ve seen in the last ten years alone are vast, and have redefined the way youth, especially those who have grown up with these digital tools, collect and process information. It appears there may be a different kind of “digital divide” occurring in the classroom, one that has caused experts to question if it is today’s teaching styles that need reevaluation, and not youth’s media habits.

Cathy Davidson, researcher and co-founder of HASTAC, an organization dedicated to the “future of thinking in a digital age,” has been a vocal proponent of reforming the classroom. She published a response to Richtel’s article on the organization’s website.

It's not our job … in 2012 to teach them how to use calculators or an abacus:  it is our job in 2012 to teach students now for the challenges of their lives--in a historical time, in a historical place.  It is our job to help them learn how to be successful adults in their future; it is not our job to preserve for them some nostalgic vision of the future that is clearly past.

Associate director for the Pew Research Center Kristen Purcell had a similar response. She told Richtel, “What we’re labeling as ‘distraction,’ some see as a failure of adults to see how these kids process information. They’re not saying distraction is good but that the label of ‘distraction’ is a judgment of this generation.”

The responses of the teachers surveyed reveal what teaching at a historical moment of massive change looks like. In most things we do, whether crossing the street, interpreting a story, or teaching, we draw on our store of personal history to make sense of it. Teachers today are naturally drawing from their own experience in a classroom when teaching—yet that classroom is quickly disappearing. As a former UK teacher now with Mozilla, Doug Belshaw recently wrote,  “The ability to sit still and concentrate for three hours on examination questions testing feats of memory does not sound to me like a 21st century skill.” Indeed.

Education in modern society, as James Mulhern wrote in “A History of Education,” is a form of social inculcation; it infuses in children a society’s key philosophies, prepares them for the structure of a later work life, and “socializes” them to the expectations of the society in which they live.  Yet the classroom Mulhern refers to was designed for a worker who was about to embark on a newly industrialized workplace of rote actions on an assembly line, not a world in which memory is no longer as central when you can “Google” the answer, when teamwork has replaced rows of workers in the secretary pool or the factory floor, and when the literacy we need today is more often how to filter information and use it smartly—knowing what information to let in, how to find it, and how to filter it.

Educators, what do you think about these study results? Have you seen similar behavior in the classroom, or have you found yourself trying to adapt to a media-savvy generation’s learning habits? We’d love for you to share your thoughts and comments. After all, your perspective is the key to meeting students where they are, and turning that insight into engagement.

Add comment

Sign in or sign up to share your thoughts

Comments

Parent written by markwillson

Recent advantages in technology have added fuel to this video watching revolution. New video hosting platform websites have been popping up all over. HTML 5 and its built-in video player make it easy for anyone with server space to show off videos. Digital media distributors http://www.rushmyessay.com/research-paper/ can provide and package the means for anyone to create their own video hosting platform website. Sites that used to just let you showcase photos are now bursting with video.
Parent written by scihealth

In my opinion, we need to incorporate modern technology in our teaching along with some traditional methods. There is great value in getting students to "think deep". Finding quick answers on the internet is fine in some instances. It is imperative that students learn to problem solve, build models, depend on their own research, develop confidence in their own abilities without receiving instant answers to questions that others have solved. The search for knowledge should be intrinsic. I have taught for 26 years (in my 27th year of teaching HS Health and Science). I have seen vast changes in education, from Madeline Hunter to Rigor, Relevance and Relationships. The use of technology is now taking over how we do things in the classroom. Why cut up animals in biology when you can do interactively? Personally, I think there is value in physically dissecting various critters, but biology seems to be going away from that exercise. I suppose that is OK in some respects. Not everyone wants a career in medicine. As a "seasoned" teacher, I see value in incorporating as much technology as we can while still teaching patience through "old fashioned" problem solving. Multiple step problems are necessary if we want to compete with other top nations in math and science. Instant gratification has become the norm rather than the exception. Might need to turn that around.