I like this game because you get so deep into Hogwarts, which you can't do in the movies. Like when you think, I wonder how Muggle Studies is like, and all you see is the trio walking out of it. You can experience it for yourself. The one downside is that the character's dialog is over dramatic. Like in Umbridge' s classroom. She says "Who would ever attack children such a yourselves?" And Harry SCREAMS "I DON'T KNOW, MAYBE VOLDEMORT!!" And she says "Detention, Mr. Potter!!" And when Hermione says to fire a spell, she says it in a happy tone, unless it's a really important battle, which she matches the right tone. Also, some characters don't sound like the real characters. Overall, 4 1/2 stars.