If the opening page of this series opener doesn't draw in even the most reluctant of readers, then nothing will. Barnaby is a most satisfying hero -- bright, massively competent, utterly independent, as good with a sword as with a scientific investigation or a bit of detective work. Though his age, both in text and illustrations, is indeterminate, young readers will have fun imagining a life as free and exciting as his. The Dickensian setting adds another layer of fascination; it's a nice combination of mystery, humor, and horror, and the action is well-paced.
While the text size, length, and publisher's recommendation make this look like a middle-grade book, the level of violence is a bit higher than in most stories aimed at 8-year-olds. Some kids will find the violence is too much for them, but upper elementary kids and reluctant middle school readers will think it's a hoot, and look forward to the next installment which, judging by the excerpt at the back of this book, has a Temple of Doom feel to it.