The Fairy's Mistake (The Princess Tales, Book 1) - Gail Levine

A fairy's reward and punishment backfire.

(Flash is loading. If this text does not disappear you need to install the latest flash version)

Common Sense rates it
4
Read the book?
2397_orig.jpg
Book details
  • Author:Gail Levine
  • # of pages: 87
  • Publisher:HarperCollins Children's Books
  • Original Publication Date: 08/29/2004
  • Genre: Fiction - Fairy Tale
  • Hardcover: $8.95
  • Publisher's Recommended Reading Level: 7-12
  • Read Aloud: 7+
  • Read Alone: 8+

Parents need to know

Parents need to know that the behavior of both sisters is filled with points for discussion, as the bad sister gets what she wants through blackmail, and the good sister marries a man she does not love.

Families can talk about how the fairy's reward and punishment are exploited. Do you think she could have foreseen the consequences? Would you be happy if jewels fell out of your mouth every time you spoke?

Message

Social Behavior:

The greedy, selfish, mean sister uses her punishment as a reward by blackmailing others into giving her whatever she wants. The good sister agrees to marry a prince just to get out of the house.

Consumerism:

Drugs/Alcohol/Tobacco:

Violence

Sex

Language

Common Sense says

What's the story?

Reviewed by Amy Brotman

Rosella helps the fairy, Ethelinda, disguised as an old woman, get a drink of water from the well, and is rewarded by having jewels tumble from her mouth whenever she speaks. Her selfish sister, Myrtle, is punished with bugs and snakes coming out of her mouth. But Ethelinda's plans backfire when Myrtle uses her affliction to force townspeople to give her whatever she wants, while Rosella is married to a greedy prince who only loves her jewels.

Is it any good?

4

This is the first of The Princess Tales, a series of short retellings of fairytales by the Newbery-honored author of Ella Enchanted. Her light sense of humor and deadpan descriptions of absurdities, along with the short length and easy to read text, make this a delightful snack, rather than a heavy meal. But she never talks down to her audience, which makes this a good choice for young readers, reluctant readers, and reading aloud.

Some may find the values here a little questionable: Myrtle's outrageous behavior is never punished, bringing success to her and her nasty mother. She even helps Rosella deceive the prince to get him to behave somewhat better, but he still gets to keep half of all the jewels Rosella produces, while she gets to give the rest to the poor. But it's all meant in fun, and it's unlikely any young readers will take Myrtle as their role model.

From the Book:
Something funny was happening in her mouth. Had she lost a tooth? There was something hard under her tongue. And something hard in her cheek. "Excuse me." Now there was something in her other cheek. She spat delicately into her hand.

They weren't teeth. She was holding a diamond and two opals.

"There, dearie," Ethelinda smiled. "Isn't that nice?"

Other choices

Other Books by Gail Carson Levine
Ella Enchanted
The Princess Test
Princess Sonora and the Long Sleep
Cinderellis and the Glass Hill
For Biddle's Sake
The Fairy's Return

More Fractured Fairy Tales
Truly Grim Tales by Priscilla Galloway
Tales from the Brothers Grimm and the Sisters Weird by Vivian Vande Velde
The Stinky Cheese Man by Jon Scieszka
The True Story of the Three Little Pigs by Jon Scieszka

Parents and kids say

All Reviews

There are 2 reviews.

1

Posted on 03/05/07 by Anonymous Adult contributor

5


Posted on 12/16/04 by The Man Kid contributor, age 10

WOWIE! WOW this was great.

I liked the details of the emotions of the people, and fairies. I liked how it ended when the two sisters worked together to make the prince stay away long enough to gain her health, and voice. She started to like the prince untill she stopped counting her jewels in her poor box. I finnished the book and, all ready for the next book THE Glass Hill and, The Fairys Return.

Adult Reviews

There are 1 reviews.

1

Posted on 03/05/07 by Anonymous Adult contributor

Kids Reviews

There are 1 reviews.

5


Posted on 12/16/04 by The Man Kid contributor, age 10

WOWIE! WOW this was great.

I liked the details of the emotions of the people, and fairies. I liked how it ended when the two sisters worked together to make the prince stay away long enough to gain her health, and voice. She started to like the prince untill she stopped counting her jewels in her poor box. I finnished the book and, all ready for the next book THE Glass Hill and, The Fairys Return.
Review It
What do your kids do online?
Surf
44%
Homework and research
11%
Download music
7%
Chat with friends
38%
45 votes