The Golem's Eye (The Bartimaeus Trilogy, Book 2) - Jonathan Stroud

Bartimaeus returns -- alas, not to center stage.

(Flash is loading. If this text does not disappear you need to install the latest flash version)

Common Sense rates it
4
Read the book?
2429_orig.jpg
Book details
  • Author:Jonathan Stroud
  • # of pages: 556
  • Publisher:Hyperion Books for Children
  • Original Publication Date: 09/12/2004
  • Genre: Fiction - Fantasy
  • Hardcover: $17.95
  • Publisher's Recommended Reading Level: 10 up
  • Read Aloud: 9+
  • Read Alone: 10+

Parents need to know

Parents need to know that this book is full of amoral and immoral characters. There's only one semi-admirable character, but most readers won't be rooting for her to succeed.

Families can talk about the characters' morality. Do you like any of them? Why? How have your opinions of them changed?

Message

Social Behavior:

The main character, and pretty much everyone else, behave selfishly, unscrupulously, deviously, and dishonestly. The only relatively good character lies and steals.

Consumerism:

Drugs/Alcohol/Tobacco:

Pipes, cigarettes, and alcohol all mentioned.

Violence

Lots of fantasy violence, including quite a few deaths, involving all sorts of magical creatures, monsters, and devices.

Sex

Language

Common Sense says

What's the story?

Reviewed by Amy Brotman

Nathaniel, the main human character (though certainly not the hero) of the first book, is now the youngest junior minister ever in the government of an alternative British Empire run by magicians. To him falls the job of dealing with the increasingly annoying anti-magician resistance movement. When the destruction grows in scale, no one will believe Nathaniel that it's unrelated to the resistance, that it is in fact the work of a golem, controlled by a traitor in the government. So he summons Bartimaeus, as snide and reluctant as ever, and travels to Prague to find the secret of the golem.

Meanwhile Kitty, a member of the commoner resistance introduced briefly in the first book, is part of a group planning to raid Gladstone's tomb for artifacts of great power. Both her plans and Nathaniel's go badly wrong, setting the stage for a climactic confrontation with the golem.

Is it any good?

4

The good news is that Bartimaeus is back. The bad news is that there's not enough of him. What made the first book in this series a standout was his sarcastic commentary, self-aggrandizing descriptions, witty banter, and delightful footnotes detailing the workings of magic and demons in this alternative world. They're all still here, just less of them.

Meanwhile Nathaniel and Kitty alternatively take center stage in a complex and often exciting, if too loosely edited, adventure involving, among many other things, grave-robbing, a demon living in Gladstone's bones, political intrigue, war, werewolf police, destruction, and a shadowy figure who seems to be playing all sides like puppets. Nathaniel, one of the least likeable main characters in children's literature, continues to fascinate and frustrate the reader with his growing power -- and obtuseness. The stage is clearly set for a grand finale in Book 3, presumably including Nathaniel's reclamation. Let's just hope Bartimaeus has a much bigger role to play in it.

From the Book:
I was floating high above the Strahov monastery, just inside the magnificent city walls I'd built three hundred years before. My leather wings moved in strong, slow beats, my eyes scanned the seven planes to the horizon. It did not make for happy viewing. The mass of the British army was cloaked behind Concealments, but its ripples of power lapped already at the base of Castle Hill. The auras of a vast contingent of spirits were dimly visible in the gloom; with every minute further brief trembles on the planes signaled the arrival of new battalions. Groups of human soldiers moved purposefully over the dark ground. In their midst stood a cluster of great white tents, domed like rocs' eggs, about which Shields and other spells hung cobweb-thick.

Doubtless, this was where the British magicians were skulking, at a safe distance from the action. My Czech masters were just the same. In war, magicians always like to reserve the most dangerous jobs for themselves, such as fearlessly guarding large quantities of food and drink a few miles behind the lines.

Other choices

First Book in this Series
The Amulet of Samarkand

Other Big Fat Fantasies
The Amber Spyglass by Philip Pullman
Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire by J. K. Rowling
City of the Beasts by Isabel Allende
Summerland by Michael Chabon
Abarat by Clive Barker
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix by J. K. Rowling
Eragon by Christopher Paolini
Midnight for Charlie Bone by Jenny Nimmo
The Merlin Conspiracy by Diana Wynne Jones
Inkheart by Cornelia Funke

Parents and kids say

All Reviews

There are 11 reviews.

4


Posted on 07/16/08 by Bibliophile Kid contributor, age 14

Go demo- I mean, djinni!

With delightfull witty sarcasm, and lots of nice little footnotes, Bartimaeus is back! A must read for the avid fantasy-goer.
5

Posted on 04/13/08 by Anonymous Kid contributor, age 13

I loved it

it must have been the best book i ever read since harry potter. It kept my attention and i could read it over and over again if i had to. It is my favorite book ever. I cant believe how good it is. I read it in about a week and i am only 8 years old. I am smart for my age but if i gave it to a fellow 8 year old it would make no sense because he isnt a genius like me. E=mc2
5


Posted on 02/15/08 by the dad Adult contributor

a very well put together book i liked it so did all my kids

5


Posted on 01/08/08 by Art_is_a_Bang Kid contributor, age 16
5

Posted on 05/14/07 by Anonymous Kid contributor, age 13

This book was the best book i have ever read.

THIS BOOK WAS THE BEST BOOK I HAVE EVER READ!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
5


Posted on 04/24/07 by wildey101 Kid contributor, age 14

brilliant book

this book was brilliant i read the first one then got really into it and had to read the second, i always think the second in a series will be the worst but this was just as good as the first. it is a must read book and i strongly advise anyone to read it, even my parents thaught it was great!!
5


Posted on 02/16/07 by Eragonfan Kid contributor, age 13

A good book

It's good, but only good, it drags out a bit too much, but the plot is good. stars 5 (4 1/2) not for children 9 and under
4


Posted on 12/12/06 by elenmadil Kid contributor, age 14

Really got me thinking about social classes and stuff like that. And Bartimeus's footnotes are fabulus!
5


Posted on 09/21/06 by Kitty Jones Kid contributor, age 13

I laughed till my sides ached1

this funny and noble djinni bartimaeus better have more to say because i wanna hear it! I'd say 4 thumbs up but i only have two Everyone should read the series!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
4


Posted on 12/30/05 by ski123 Kid contributor, age 13

wonderful!!!

this trilogy is awesome!!! Everyone 8 years old and up should read this book.

See all 11 reviews >

Adult Reviews

There are 1 reviews.

5


Posted on 02/15/08 by the dad Adult contributor

a very well put together book i liked it so did all my kids

Kids Reviews

There are 10 reviews.

4


Posted on 07/16/08 by Bibliophile Kid contributor, age 14

Go demo- I mean, djinni!

With delightfull witty sarcasm, and lots of nice little footnotes, Bartimaeus is back! A must read for the avid fantasy-goer.
5

Posted on 04/13/08 by Anonymous Kid contributor, age 13

I loved it

it must have been the best book i ever read since harry potter. It kept my attention and i could read it over and over again if i had to. It is my favorite book ever. I cant believe how good it is. I read it in about a week and i am only 8 years old. I am smart for my age but if i gave it to a fellow 8 year old it would make no sense because he isnt a genius like me. E=mc2
5


Posted on 01/08/08 by Art_is_a_Bang Kid contributor, age 16
5

Posted on 05/14/07 by Anonymous Kid contributor, age 13

This book was the best book i have ever read.

THIS BOOK WAS THE BEST BOOK I HAVE EVER READ!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
5


Posted on 04/24/07 by wildey101 Kid contributor, age 14

brilliant book

this book was brilliant i read the first one then got really into it and had to read the second, i always think the second in a series will be the worst but this was just as good as the first. it is a must read book and i strongly advise anyone to read it, even my parents thaught it was great!!
5


Posted on 02/16/07 by Eragonfan Kid contributor, age 13

A good book

It's good, but only good, it drags out a bit too much, but the plot is good. stars 5 (4 1/2) not for children 9 and under
4


Posted on 12/12/06 by elenmadil Kid contributor, age 14

Really got me thinking about social classes and stuff like that. And Bartimeus's footnotes are fabulus!
5


Posted on 09/21/06 by Kitty Jones Kid contributor, age 13

I laughed till my sides ached1

this funny and noble djinni bartimaeus better have more to say because i wanna hear it! I'd say 4 thumbs up but i only have two Everyone should read the series!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
4


Posted on 12/30/05 by ski123 Kid contributor, age 13

wonderful!!!

this trilogy is awesome!!! Everyone 8 years old and up should read this book.
4

Posted on 10/19/05 by Anonymous Kid contributor, age 12

A Great Book

I throughly enjoyed this book. I can't wait until the third one of the trilogy comes out.
See all 10 kids reviews >
Review It
What do your kids do online?
Surf
44%
Homework and research
11%
Download music
7%
Chat with friends
38%
45 votes