• CSM Reviews <--
• Adult Reviews
• Kid Reviews

Common Sense Note

Though in picture book format, this combination of nostalgia and cynical humor is really aimed at older children and adults.

Rate It!

Common Sense Review

Reviewed By: Matt Berman

While this looks like a picture book, and the publisher recommends it for age 4 and up, it is really aimed at older children and adults. Seinfeld did not write it for children: it was taken almost word for word from one of his standup routines, and is a combination of nostalgia and cynicism that is unlikely to appeal to the picture book set, though they will enjoy the goofy illustrations.

But for kids who are starting to get a bit jaded about Halloween, it's a hoot, and one they can share with their parents. James Bennett's illustrations brilliantly match the tone: glossy, bigheaded caricatures, with the main character looking hilariously like a youthful Seinfeld. The CD provides added humor, as no one can perform this material better than Seinfeld himself.

From the Book
They come to the door; they always ask you the same stupid question. "What are you supposed to be?"

"I'm supposed to be done by now. You want to move it along wit the 3Musketeers? I got eighteen houses on this block, sweetheart. You hit the bag, we hit the road. That's the way it works."

Plot Summary:

Noted comedian Jerry Seinfeld reminisces about the Halloweens of his youth, beginning with eager enthusiasm ("EVERYONE WE KNOW is just giving out candy? I gotta be a part of this!"), proceeding through normal trials and difficulties (cheap, flimsy costumes, breaking rubber bands on masks, etc.), and ending with teenage cynicism ("Bing-bong, come on lady, let's go! Halloween, doorbells, candy, let's pick it up in there.").

The deluxe edition contains a CD of Seinfeld performing this routine in front of an audience.

Related Books:

Another Picture Book for Older Readers
The Watertower by Gary Crew

Rate It Now

OR